A narrative review comparing human scar investigations with mechanistic laboratory experiments indicates that keloids and hypertrophic scars share central fibrotic repair programmes despite exhibiting markedly divergent clinical trajectories. By synthesizing emerging single-cell and spatial profiling literature, the authors examine how similar cellular programmes can ultimately yield fundamentally different tissue outcomes.
Central to these shared biological features is the recurrent identification of periostin-expressing, or POSTN-rich, fibroblast states across both keloid and hypertrophic scar samples. However, comparative spatial multi-omics reveals that the physical distribution of these matrix-producing cells varies considerably across separate human investigations. In one keloid study, researchers identified dispersed mesenchymal fibroblasts throughout the lesion, whereas an independent study observed POSTN-rich signals concentrated in deep, vessel-associated dermal locations. The review emphasizes that these conflicting spatial distributions support a shared matrix-producing programme far more strongly than they support any uniform anatomical tissue compartment.
To clarify these spatial discrepancies, the authors define multicellular niches specifically as local tissue microenvironments, drawing a rigorous conceptual distinction between directly observed cellular organisation and speculative hypotheses regarding biological function. Under this framework, single-cell and spatial data reveal a candidate fibrovascular niche positioned within the deep dermis of keloids. This microenvironment is composed of activated fibroblasts situated alongside neighbouring endothelial cells, generating the working hypothesis that reciprocal local signalling within this vascular-associated niche actively sustains matrix production and ongoing endothelial activation.
In parallel with vascular interactions, neural–stromal investigations highlight alternative multicellular configurations that link local microenvironments to patient symptoms. Specifically, studies evaluating stromal communication show that direct signalling between fibroblasts and Schwann cells associates with clinical manifestations of itch and pain.
Beyond observational tissue mapping, the review assesses functional experiments that identify distinct mechanical, epidermal, and metabolic inputs capable of driving profibrotic activity. In keloid fibroblasts, mechanical investigations demonstrate that PIEZO1-dependent calcium entry directly governs downstream YAP activity. At the epidermal interface, regulatory signalling involving FOSL1 and MED1 connects to MMP3-dependent fibroblast activation. In hypertrophic scar models, metabolic experiments demonstrate that macrophage-derived lactate triggers MCT1-dependent fibroblast responses, establishing three separate regulatory axes converging on profibrotic cellular behaviours.
Synthesizing these experimental results, the authors note that mechanical force, epidermal factors, and immune-derived metabolites provide distinct triggers for profibrotic activation across cutaneous fibrosis. Functional studies demonstrate how individual inputs provoke fibroblast activation in experimental settings, yet human spatial profiles show marked differences in cellular arrangements across separate studies.
The review concludes that while shared matrix-producing fibroblast programmes consistently operate in both keloids and hypertrophic scars, spatial studies continue to report contrasting tissue arrangements. Crucially, how mechanical, epidermal, and metabolic inputs are organised locally within multicellular niches, and how they contribute to persistent tissue growth or symptoms like pain and itch, remains to be established.
Subject of Research: Fibroblast repair programmes and multicellular niches in keloids and hypertrophic scars
Article Title: Single-cell and spatial multi-omics of keloids and hypertrophic scars: shared repair programmes and candidate multicellular niches
Article References: Zhao, S., Chen, Y., Xie, J., Lu, Z., Chen, L., Li, L., & He, Y. (2026). Single-cell and spatial multi-omics of keloids and hypertrophic scars: shared repair programmes and candidate multicellular niches. Molecular Medicine. https://doi.org/10.1186/s10020-026-01687-y
Image Credits: AI Generated
DOI: 10.1186/s10020-026-01687-y
Keywords: Keloids, Hypertrophic scars, Fibroblasts, Multicellular niches, POSTN, Fibrovascular niche, Spatial multi-omics, Single-cell analysis, Endothelial cells, Schwann cells, Neural–stromal communication, PIEZO1, YAP activity, FOSL1, MED1, MMP3, MCT1, Macrophage lactate
News Source: Ophelia Keating. (November 18, 2026). Keloids and Hypertrophic Scars Share Matrix Programmes Despite Divergent Spatial Distributions. Scienmag.



