Published in Frontiers in Health Services, the investigation analyzed survey data to determine how an individual’s personal and situational background relates to their self-assessed physical health, mental wellbeing, and direct interactions with primary care services. The authors observed that while differences in patient-reported outcomes appeared across nearly every evaluated equity dimension, disparities in patient-reported experiences were concentrated within specific social and demographic domains.
The investigation was established in the context of ongoing health policy reforms across Wales, where healthcare authorities are rapidly integrating patient-reported outcome measures and patient-reported experience measures into routine clinical practice.
To investigate these dynamics, a collaborative research team drawn from CEDAR at the Cardiff and Vale University Health Board, NHS Digital Health and Care Wales, the Value Transformation team within NHS Wales Performance and Improvement, NHS Wales Hywel Dda University Health Board, and Cardiff University analyzed population-level survey records. The underlying data came from the Welsh Population Health Survey, which gathered responses between July and October 2023 from a substantial sample of more than 25,000 individuals aged 46 years and older residing in Wales. This extensive cross-sectional dataset enabled the investigators to evaluate how diverse population segments perceive their wellbeing and evaluate their encounters within primary care settings.
To identify and categorize relevant equity predictors, the authors utilized the PROGRESS-Plus framework, an established equity model that captures a wide spectrum of individual and situational factors. The framework served both to guide the selection of predictor variables incorporated into statistical models and to structure the synthesized findings. The researchers applied two distinct statistical modeling strategies tailored to the measurement characteristics of the survey instruments. Multilevel linear regression modelling was deployed to examine patient-reported outcomes, evaluating continuous scores across the Patient-Reported Outcomes Measurement Information System physical health scale, the PROMIS mental health scale, and the World Health Organization-Five Wellbeing Index. In parallel, multilevel ordinal logistic regression modeling was utilized to evaluate patient-reported experiences, focusing on ordinal survey responses reflecting patients’ trust in the healthcare system and their experiences of shared decision-making.
The resulting statistical models demonstrated that disparities in patient-reported outcomes are pervasive across older Welsh adults. Significant differences were observed across almost all PROGRESS-Plus elements for the evaluated outcome measures, indicating that socioeconomic, personal, and environmental characteristics are consistently associated with variations in physical functioning, mental health, and overall psychological wellbeing.
In contrast to the extensive disparities identified across outcome metrics, differences in patient-reported experiences were far more circumscribed. Rather than spanning the entire spectrum of PROGRESS-Plus elements, variations in trust in the healthcare system and experiences of shared decision-making were restricted to a defined subset of domains. Specifically, statistically significant experiential differences emerged only in relation to gender and sex, occupation, social capital, personal characteristics associated with discrimination, features of relationships, and time-dependent relationships. In other evaluated equity dimensions, differences in how patients evaluated their interactions with healthcare professionals were not observed.
The authors emphasized several critical caveats regarding the interpretation of these findings, concluding that while indications of potential inequity-related differences exist within primary care in Wales for adults aged 46 and older, the cross-sectional nature of the data precludes any determination of causal directionality. The analysis cannot establish whether specific population groups evaluate identical healthcare experiences differently due to varied expectations and perceptions, or whether they are systematically underserved and subject to poorer care quality. Additionally, the study did not evaluate the clinical significance of the observed differences in outcome scores. Consequently, the researchers noted that further work is required to develop and evaluate innovative solutions that actively address inequities in both patient-reported outcomes and care experiences.
Subject of Research: Equity in patient-reported outcomes and healthcare experiences among older adults in Wales
Article Title: Using PROGRESS-Plus to examine equity in patient reported outcomes and experiences in Wales: findings from a population based cross sectional study
Article References: Woolley, K. E., Rollings, J., Thuvesholmen, N., Shaw, A., Cox, S., Puntoni, S., Newman, C., & Withers, K. (2026). Using PROGRESS-Plus to examine equity in patient reported outcomes and experiences in Wales: findings from a population based cross sectional study. Frontiers in Health Services, 6, 1937782. https://doi.org/10.3389/frhs.2026.1937782
Image Credits: AI Generated
DOI: 10.3389/frhs.2026.1937782
Keywords: patient-reported outcomes, patient-reported experiences, PROGRESS-Plus framework, PROMIS physical health, PROMIS mental health, WHO-5 wellbeing index, Welsh Population Health Survey, Value-Based Healthcare, shared decision-making, trust in healthcare system, primary care equity, multilevel linear regression, multilevel ordinal logistic regression, cross-sectional study, adults aged 46 and older, social capital, NHS Wales
News Source: Ophelia Keating. (November 16, 2026). Patient-Reported Outcomes Show Broad Equity Differences Among Older Welsh Adults. Scienmag.



