Critically ill adult patients living with obesity undergo a more prolonged and clinically complex trajectory when discontinuing invasive mechanical ventilation, yet obesity itself does not independently increase the risk of weaning failure or patient mortality, according to a secondary analysis of the international prospective WEAN SAFE investigation published in Annals of Intensive Care. Supported jointly by the European Society of Intensive Care Medicine and the European Respiratory Society, the study examined whether elevated body mass index directly impairs liberation from mechanical breathing support across global intensive care units. Conducted across 481 intensive care units in 50 countries spanning five continents, the parent trial recruited adult patients who required at least two consecutive calendar days of invasive mechanical ventilation. The resulting multivariable findings challenge previous concerns that increased body mass index inherently predestines intubated individuals to adverse extubation outcomes, demonstrating that adjusted weaning success and clinical survival rates in patients with obesity match those observed in normal-weight individuals.
The clinical investigation addresses a pressing global epidemiological challenge within modern critical care environments. According to data cited from the World Health Organization from 2022, sixteen percent of adults worldwide live with obesity, defined as a body mass index of at least thirty kilograms per square meter, while forty-three percent are classified as overweight with an index of at least twenty-five. Furthermore, projections from the Global Burden of Diseases collaborators indicate that over half of the global adult population will live with overweight or obesity by 2050, guaranteeing an expanding population of critically ill patients presenting with altered physiology. Obesity causes marked alterations in respiratory mechanics, including substantial reductions in respiratory system compliance, functional residual capacity, and expiratory reserve volume, alongside elevated airway resistance that promotes ventilation-perfusion mismatching and hypoxemia. Increased intra-abdominal and transthoracic pressures displace the diaphragm cranially, precipitating widespread atelectasis and severely impairing pulmonary gas exchange during mechanical ventilation.
These mechanical compromises complicate the process of ventilator liberation, as intrathoracic pressures theoretically increase with escalating adiposity by approximately 2.5 centimeters of water for every ten units of body mass index above thirty. Consequently, conventional clinical practices that apply a standardized, one-size-fits-all weaning strategy, typically titrating positive end-expiratory pressure down to five to ten centimeters of water regardless of body size, risk provoking severe atelectasis, hypoxemia, and secondary extubation failure in obese individuals. Delayed or unsuccessful liberation from invasive mechanical ventilation is widely documented to exacerbate clinical complications, prolong intensive care unit and hospital lengths of stay, and substantially increase mortality risks. The WEAN SAFE investigators established their primary objective around determining the precise impact of obesity on the weaning process and subsequent clinical outcomes following invasive ventilation, testing the explicit scientific hypothesis that increased body mass index would substantially prolong the liberation trajectory and diminish overall rates of successful weaning.
To rigorously evaluate these questions, the authors analyzed data from the prospective WEAN SAFE cohort, which enrolled patients older than sixteen years who were admitted to participating units between October 2017 and June 2018. Of the 5,869 patients receiving invasive mechanical ventilation two calendar days after intubation, 4,523 individuals entered the active weaning process by undergoing an initial separation attempt. After excluding 221 underweight patients exhibiting a body mass index below 18.5 kilograms per square meter, the primary study cohort comprised 4,302 patients categorized into four discrete weight strata. Within this analytical sample, 1,728 patients (38.2 percent) were categorized as normal weight with an index of 18.5 to 24.9, while 1,395 patients (30.8 percent) were classified as overweight with an index of 25 to 29.9. Additionally, 590 individuals (13.1 percent) presented with class one obesity spanning 30 to 34.9, and 431 participants (9.5 percent) exhibited class two or three obesity with an index of thirty-five or higher.
Baseline clinical characteristics differed markedly across the body mass index categories upon intensive care unit admission. Patients with obesity were significantly more likely to be female, were more frequently admitted for medical rather than surgical indications, and exhibited higher rates of chronic coexisting illnesses, particularly respiratory diseases, cardiovascular disorders, and diabetes mellitus. Furthermore, individuals in obesity classes two and three were significantly more likely to present with hypoxemic respiratory failure, hypercapnic respiratory failure, or systemic sepsis as their primary reason for admission. Physiological assessments revealed that patients with obesity had significantly lower ratios of arterial oxygen tension to inspired oxygen fraction at study inclusion, on the first day of meeting weaning eligibility criteria, and at the time of their first separation attempt. These patients also received significantly higher tidal volumes, higher respiratory rates, and elevated positive end-expiratory pressure levels, alongside lower dynamic compliance and elevated dynamic driving pressures at inclusion.
Standardized definitions established rigorous criteria for tracking patient progress throughout the weaning continuum. The authors defined weaning initiation as the moment clinicians executed the first separation attempt, whether conducted as a spontaneous breathing trial or as a direct extubation without trial, while tracheostomized patients underwent designated low-support trials. Weaning eligibility criteria required an inspired oxygen fraction below 0.5, positive end-expiratory pressure under ten centimeters of water, absent or low-dose vasopressor administration below 0.2 micrograms per kilogram per minute of norepinephrine equivalent, and cessation of neuromuscular paralyzing agents. Weaning outcomes followed a modified WIND classification categorizing patients into five distinct trajectories: those with no separation attempt, short weaning achieved within one day of the first attempt, intermediate weaning lasting two to six days, prolonged weaning extending to seven or more days, and failed weaning characterized by ongoing ventilator dependence at day ninety, transfer out of the unit, or death prior to liberation.
Analysis of weaning milestones demonstrated that individuals in obesity classes two and three experienced lower sedation levels and were more frequently awake when fulfilling eligibility criteria, yet their initial separation attempts occurred significantly later than normal-weight counterparts. Time to achieving weaning success through day ninety was extended in grade two and three obesity, and overall duration of mechanical ventilation and intensive care stay were significantly longer. However, the proportions of patients encountering delayed weaning did not differ significantly across weight strata, nor were there significant differences in the total number of separation attempts, extubation attempts, reintubations, or tracheostomy placements. Crucially, when researchers performed multivariable Cox proportional hazards and ordinal logistic regression adjusting for age, frailty, admission diagnosis, oxygenation impairment, driving pressure, positive end-expiratory pressure, and sedation, body mass index exhibited no independent association with delayed first separation attempt, overall weaning duration, or final extubation success.
Following extubation, clinical management diverged substantially among the designated weight categories across participating study centers, providing valuable insight into how intensive care teams mitigated heightened respiratory vulnerability. Patients categorized with grade two and three obesity were significantly more likely to receive prophylactic noninvasive mechanical ventilation post-extubation and were correspondingly less likely to receive conventional low-flow supplemental oxygen therapy than patients of normal weight. In crude outcome evaluations, overall weaning success rates, intensive care unit mortality, and hospital mortality rates showed no significant differences between patients with obesity and their normal-weight peers. Similarly, decisions regarding the limitation of life-sustaining measures occurred at statistically comparable frequencies across all evaluated weight brackets. In comprehensive multivariable models adjusting for baseline frailty, severe oxygenation deficits, and physiological covariates, body mass index category consistently demonstrated no independent statistical association with intensive care unit mortality, hospital mortality, or the implementation of end-of-life care limitations during patient hospitalizations.
A notable secondary observation emerged regarding the relationship between positive end-expiratory pressure at weaning eligibility and subsequent patient outcomes. In the general study population, higher positive end-expiratory pressure on the day eligibility criteria were met was independently associated with an earlier first separation attempt but also with longer weaning duration, elevated intensive care and hospital mortality, and increased decisions to limit life-sustaining measures. Intriguingly, in patients living with obesity, this detrimental relationship between elevated pressure and adverse outcomes appeared attenuated, with statistical point estimates for mortality risk reversing compared to the broader cohort, although interaction tests did not achieve formal statistical significance.
The study authors highlighted several methodological limitations inherent to the observational design of the global secondary analysis. While electronic case report forms were standardized and supported by quality control protocols, source data interpretation relied on local clinicians across diverse international centers, introducing potential practice variability. Furthermore, the convenience sample of 481 intensive care units may carry institutional selection biases, while four percent of patients were lost to follow-up due to early transfers before undergoing separation attempts. Additionally, researchers assumed patients discharged alive prior to day ninety survived through that benchmark. In conclusion, the WEAN SAFE investigators demonstrated that although critically ill patients with obesity navigate a more prolonged and mechanically challenging weaning course requiring intensified post-extubation noninvasive respiratory support, obesity per se does not independently worsen liberation success or patient survival, indicating that proactive, tailored critical care management effectively surmounts the underlying pathophysiological burdens of increased adiposity.
Subject of Research: Impact of obesity on weaning outcomes and survival from invasive mechanical ventilation
Article Title: Does obesity impact on weaning from invasive ventilation: a secondary analysis of the WEAN SAFE study
Article References: Bell, A., Kuriyama, A., Khazaei, O., McNicholas, B. A., Pham, T., Heunks, L., Bellani, G., Brochard, L., Simpkin, A. J., & Laffey, J. G. (2025). Does obesity impact on weaning from invasive ventilation: a secondary analysis of the WEAN SAFE study. Annals of Intensive Care, 15(1), Article 164. https://doi.org/10.1186/s13613-025-01586-1
Image Credits: AI Generated
DOI: 10.1186/s13613-025-01586-1
Keywords: critical care, mechanical ventilation, ventilator weaning, obesity, intensive care unit, extubation, positive end-expiratory pressure, WEAN SAFE study, Does, impact, weaning, invasive
News Source: Daisy Hatcher. (November 8, 2026). WEAN SAFE Study Finds Obesity Does Not Impair Ventilator Weaning Success. Scienmag.



