PCR statement on evolving indications for transcatheter aortic valve implantation
Aortic stenosis, surgical aortic valve replacement, transcatheter aortic valve implantation
Paris, France, 21 May 2019. Severe symptomatic aortic stenosis, a degenerative disease-causing calcification and immobility of the aortic valve leaflets leading to left ventricular outflow obstruction, is the most common valve lesion leading to intervention in Europe and the USA. Symptoms include heart failure, syncope and angina, and have a dismal prognosis if left untreated. There is no effective medical treatment, except for replacement of the diseased valve by means of surgical aortic valve replacement (SAVR) or transcatheter aortic valve implantation (TAVI), but for which indications
Aortic stenosis is in most cases a degenerative disease-causing calcification and immobility of the aortic valve leaflets that in turn leads to left ventricular outflow obstruction. Severe, symptomatic aortic stenosis is the most common heart valve lesion leading to intervention in Europe and the USA. Affected patients suffer from symptoms including heart failure, syncope and angina and have a dismal prognosis if left untreated. There is no effective medical treatment, and the only intervention is replacement of the diseased valve by means of surgical aortic valve replacement (SAVR) or transcatheter aortic valve implantation (TAVI). The latter less invasive treatment has resulted in an unprecedented effort to conduct a series of high quality randomised clinical trials (RCTs) in a field devoid of randomised evidence prior to the advent of TAVI.
Previously accumulated evidence among patients with severe aortic stenosis, who are at extreme (inoperable), high- and intermediate-surgical risk were summarized in the 2017 ESC/EACTS Guidelines on the management of valvular heart disease (Baumgartner H et al. EHJ 2017, https:/
Recently, the results of two additional RCTs comparing TAVI with SAVR extend the available evidence to patients at low surgical risk. In the PARTNER 3 trial, TAVI with use of the balloon-expandable Edwards SAPIEN S3 prosthesis compared with SAVR was associated with a lower risk of the primary composite endpoint of death, stroke and rehospitalisation at 1 year among low surgical risk patients (mean age 74±6 years, STS score 1.9±0.7%) (Mack M et al. NEJM 2019, https:/
An updated meta-analysis of seven RCTs comparing TAVI and SAVR among 8,020 patients with severe, symptomatic aortic stenosis reported a lower risk of all-cause mortality (12% relative risk reduction) and stroke (19% relative risk reduction), irrespective of underlying surgical risk throughout two years of follow-up (Siontis G et al. EHJ 2019, https:/
In aggregate, the available evidence from the low surgical risk trials and meta-analyses can be summarised as follows:
- TAVI is superior to SAVR at two years with respect to patient-oriented endpoints including:
- TAVI is associated with improved health care resource utilisation owing to:
- shorter interventions without need for general anaesthesia, cardiopulmonary bypass and intensive care unit monitoring
- shorter hospitalisation duration
- reduced need for rehabilitation services
- faster recovery and more rapid restoration of daily life activities and quality of life
- notwithstanding, the cost-effectiveness of TAVI requires further study in view of the current cost of transcatheter heart valves
These findings constitute a paradigm shift that will affect the care of patients with severe, symptomatic aortic stenosis in several ways:
- The favourable outcomes of TAVI are consistent across the entire risk spectrum suggesting that surgical risk estimation is no longer the basis to guide the choice between TAVI and SAVR.
- Instead, the Heart Team will weigh clinical and anatomic characteristics to identify the best treatment option for individual patients with transfemoral TAVI replacing SAVR as default therapy in more patients.
- Prosthetic valve selection will be determined by life expectancy and durability with surgically implanted mechanical valve prostheses being favoured in younger patients (65 years of age).
Future research will need to address remaining uncertainties and options for further improvement in outcomes:
- evaluation of TAVI in younger patients ( assessment of long-term durability using predefined clinical and echocardiographic assessment
- evaluation of TAVI in patients with bicuspid aortic valve disease
- evaluation of TAVI in patients with concomitant coronary artery disease
- continued measures to reduce the need for permanent pacemaker implantation
- definition of the optimal short and long-term antithrombotic treatment therapy
- TAVI in asymptomatic patients with severe aortic stenosis
NOTES TO EDITORS
- A PCR Statement on evolving indications for TAVI in patients with severe symptomatic aortic stenosis presented by Stephan Windecker
- Palais des Congrès Porte Maillot – Paris, France
- Thursday 23 May 2019 – 14:45 – Main Arena
About EuroPCR 2019
The World-Leading Course in interventional cardiovascular medicine and the official annual meeting of the European Association of Percutaneous Cardiovascular Interventions (EAPCI) will take place from 21 to 24 May 2019 at the Palais des Congrès – Paris, France. The detailed Course Programme is available on: https:/
The mission of PCR is to serve the needs of each individual patient by helping the cardiovascular community to share knowledge, experience and practice. PCR offers a large range of many other educational meetings and resources for the continuing education of the interventional cardiovascular community. These include major annual Courses across the globe, e-Learning with high-profile PCR Webinars, Courses specifically dedicated to valvular heart disease, tailor-made PCR Seminars on specific topics, online resources and medical publications such as EuroIntervention, the official journal of the EAPCI.
Gateways to all PCR activities are available on http://www.
For further information, please contact Celia Vila: [email protected]
HELP FOR JOURNALISTS TO COVER EUROPCR 2019
Register and attend EuroPCR 2019 as a journalist
Open to accredited journalists, free of charge. Journalists must hold a valid press card and/or provide a letter of assignment from a recognised publication. To register as press go to
EuroPCR press releases can be found at
For the press briefing schedule check
For any press-related enquiries, please contact
EuroPCR Press Coordinator, Isabelle Uzielli: [email protected]