A study published in Dairy Science and Management evaluated the physicochemical and microbiological quality of yogurt sold in Addis Ababa, Ethiopia, revealing significant deviations from established safety and quality standards. The research team, comprising Takele Wolkaro, Mihret Frew, and Ulfina Galmessa, analyzed 40 yogurt samples collected between February and May 2022. The samples were divided into two groups: 20 traditionally produced, unbranded yogurts, known locally as ergo, and 20 commercially produced, branded yogurts. The primary objective was to assess the quality of these products to safeguard the health of consumers in a market where yogurt demand has surged alongside urbanization and population growth.
The study design involved purposive sampling for the commercial brands, with four samples collected from each of five different brands in supermarkets. For the traditional yogurt, random sampling was employed, collecting samples from 20 different dairy shops. All samples were transported to the Animal Products, Veterinary Drug and Feed Quality Assessment Centre in Addis Ababa using iceboxes to maintain a temperature of 4°C within three to four hours of collection. This rigorous handling procedure was essential to prevent contamination during transit and to ensure that the analysis reflected the actual quality of the products as sold in the market.
The researchers measured several physicochemical properties, including pH, moisture, ash, fat, total solids (TS), and solids-not-fat (SNF). They also conducted microbial analyses to determine the Total Viable Count (TVC), Coliform Count (CC), and Yeast and Mould Count (YMC). The TVC was assessed using standard culture methods on plate count agar, while the coliform and yeast and mould counts were determined using the TEMPO system, a rapid enumeration method that uses a card-based system with wells of varying volumes to detect bacterial presence.
The physicochemical results showed distinct differences between the two types of yogurt. The traditionally produced yogurt had a mean fat content of 4.44%, a pH of 3.99, and a total solids content of 10.12%. In contrast, the commercially produced yogurt exhibited a higher fat content of 5.02%, a lower pH of 3.88, and a total solids content of 10.66%. The ash content, which indicates the mineral content of the yogurt, was significantly lower in the traditional samples at 0.53% compared to 0.62% in the commercial samples. These differences suggest that commercial production processes, which often involve milk standardization and the addition of stabilizers, result in a more consistent and nutrient-dense product.
Microbiological analysis revealed concerning levels of bacterial load in both categories. The Total Viable Count for traditionally produced yogurt was 10.72 log10 cfu/mL, while the commercial samples had a slightly lower count of 10.35 log10 cfu/mL. These values significantly exceed the standard aerobic bacterial count for yogurt, which is typically between 10^6 and 10^7 cfu/mL. The high TVC levels may indicate post-pasteurization contamination or inadequate hygiene during production, posing potential health risks to consumers who consume these products regularly.
The coliform counts, a key indicator of sanitary quality and potential fecal contamination, were also elevated. The mean coliform count for traditional yogurt was 3.72 log10 cfu/mL, compared to 2.81 log10 cfu/mL for commercial yogurt. Although the difference was not statistically significant, the levels were high enough to raise concerns about hygiene practices. According to Food Standards Australia New Zealand regulations, only 20% of the traditional and 40% of the commercial samples met the safety standards for coliform counts. This non-compliance suggests that a significant portion of the yogurt available in Addis Ababa may not meet international hygiene benchmarks.
Yeast and mould counts further highlighted quality issues. The mean count for traditional yogurt was 4.48 log10 cfu/mL, while commercial yogurt had a lower count of 3.92 log10 cfu/mL. Only 30% of the commercial samples complied with the FSANZ standards for yeast and mould. High levels of yeast and mould can lead to spoilage and undesirable sensory changes, affecting the shelf life and consumer acceptance of the product. The presence of these microorganisms in such high quantities may also pose risks to immunocompromised individuals, who are more susceptible to foodborne illnesses.
The study also noted that the pH values of both traditional and commercial yogurts did not fall within the acceptable commercial manufacturing standards of 4.0 to 4.6. A pH below 4.6 is generally required to inhibit the growth of pathogenic microorganisms. This deviation from standards could compromise the safety of the yogurt by allowing the growth of undesirable microorganisms, thereby posing health risks to consumers.
The moisture content of the samples also did not conform to the specifications reported in previous studies. High moisture levels can lead to a shorter shelf life and increased susceptibility to microbial spoilage. The failure to meet moisture standards in both types of yogurt indicates a need for improved quality control and production practices. Addressing these issues is crucial for ensuring consumer safety and satisfaction, as well as maintaining the integrity of yogurt as a healthy food option.
The authors concluded that there is an urgent need for enhanced quality control and food safety measures in both the commercial and traditional yogurt sectors in Ethiopia. The findings emphasize the importance of ongoing monitoring and assessment of yogurt quality to safeguard public health. The study highlights the challenges posed by the proliferation of yogurt products in a rapidly urbanizing market, where consumer demand outpaces the implementation of robust regulatory and quality assurance systems. By providing detailed data on the physicochemical and microbiological properties of yogurt in Addis Ababa, this study offers valuable insights for policymakers, industry stakeholders, and public health authorities aiming to improve food safety standards in the region.
Beyond broad category averages, the investigation detailed exact laboratory protocols and analytical instrumentation. Testing was performed in triplicate, with samples coded blindly to maintain objective handling throughout all assessment phases. The researchers measured fat content using a DA7250 Perten near-infrared spectrophotometer, while sample pH was determined using a Corning Pinnacle model 5A3i pH-meter. For statistical evaluation, the investigators transformed all microbial counts into logarithmic values and processed the data through the General Linear Model procedure in SAS software version 9.1, establishing statistical significance at an alpha threshold of 0.05.
The microbiological enumeration relied on an automated TEMPO system to examine coliforms and fungal contaminants. Laboratory analysts homogenized ten milliliters of yogurt in ninety milliliters of sterile peptone water for five minutes before reconstituting culture media and preparing sequential dilutions of one-to-forty and one-to-four-hundred. Each mixture was vortexed for thirty seconds and transferred into specialized test cards containing three distinct sets of sixteen wells, scaled in volume across 225, 22.5, and 2.25 microliters. Coliform cards underwent incubation at 35 degrees Celsius for 24 to 27 hours, whereas yeast and mold cards were incubated at 25 degrees Celsius for 72 to 76 hours, enabling automated digital reading within a calibrated range extending up to 49,000 colony-forming units per milliliter.
A closer look at contamination distributions showed clear variations across individual count thresholds. Among traditional yogurt samples, 20 percent had coliform counts below 10 colony-forming units per milliliter, 55 percent registered between 10 and 49,000 units, and 25 percent exceeded 49,000 units. For commercial yogurt, 40 percent were below 10 units, 35 percent fell within the intermediate range, and 25 percent exceeded 49,000 units. In yeast and mold assessments, not a single traditional sample fell below 100 colony-forming units per milliliter, with 35 percent falling between 100 and 49,000 units and 65 percent surpassing 49,000 units. Commercial products performed moderately better, with 30 percent below 100 units, 50 percent in the intermediate category, and 20 percent exceeding 49,000 units.
The nutritional composition data revealed notable disparities regarding solids-not-fat content and moisture standards. Commercial yogurts averaged 8.10 percent solids-not-fat, achieving compliance with the 8.2 percent standard established by Ethiopian guidelines as well as regional East and Southern African and United States regulations. In contrast, traditional yogurt averaged only 7.18 percent solids-not-fat, failing to meet these benchmarks. The researchers noted that commercial processors often stabilize products using whole milk, milk powder, or whey protein concentrates, whereas traditional fermentations rely on unstandardized raw milk. In addition, moisture content reached 89.88 percent in traditional samples and 89.29 percent in commercial yogurts, substantially exceeding standard commercial moisture limits that typically range between 80 and 85 percent.
The researchers also framed these findings within systemic supply chain challenges and regional public health concerns. Although commercial manufacturers utilize temperature-controlled transport, they depend heavily on raw milk sourced from smallholder farmers lacking basic sanitation infrastructure, allowing microbial risks to persist upstream. In traditional ergo, milk undergoes spontaneous fermentation without heat treatment, standardized starter cultures, or controlled fermentation temperatures. While specific yogurt outbreaks remain undocumented in Ethiopia, pathogens such as Escherichia coli, Salmonella species, Listeria monocytogenes, and Staphylococcus aureus have been recorded in regional dairy products, presenting risks of gastrointestinal infection, enterotoxin poisoning, and antimicrobial resistance. These realities underscore the need to modernize national regulatory systems, shifting focus from retrospective product testing toward proactive process control.
Subject of Research: Physicochemical and microbiological quality assessment of traditional and commercial yogurt in Addis Ababa, Ethiopia
Article Title: Physicochemical and microbiological evaluation of yoghurt sold in Addis Ababa, Ethiopia
Article References: Wolkaro, T., Frew, M., & Galmessa, U. (2024). Physicochemical and microbiological evaluation of yoghurt sold in Addis Ababa, Ethiopia. Dairy Science and Management, 1(1), Article 1. https://doi.org/10.1186/s44363-024-00001-7
Image Credits: AI Generated
DOI: 10.1186/s44363-024-00001-7
Keywords: yogurt quality, Addis Ababa, Ethiopia, food safety, microbiological analysis, physicochemical properties, coliform count, total viable count, yeast and mould, traditional yogurt, commercial yogurt, dairy science, public health, food hygiene, TEMPO system, pH levels, fat content, total solids, consumer safety, food standards
News Source: Alan Morgan. (November 14, 2026). Yogurt Quality Study in Addis Ababa Reveals Safety Concerns. Scienmag.



