A study examining clinical networks as safety and quality stewards in the Australian state of Victoria has revealed four distinct viewpoints that govern how healthcare professionals interpret and implement evidence. Utilizing Q-methodology, the research evaluated how practitioners from varied disciplinary backgrounds conceptualize evidence use within healthcare systems.
Ensuring the use of appropriate evidence at the point of clinical care remains a fundamental requirement for assuring the safety and quality of health services. Nonetheless, healthcare practitioners, institutions, and government departments continue to grapple with understanding the practical definition of evidence-based care and determining the strategies required to accelerate its adoption. To address these challenges, clinical networks have been established across all Australian states to define care expectations and facilitate continuous improvements in clinical care. Although these networks are formally mandated to operate on an evidence-based footing, interpreting what this obligation requires in day-to-day practice remains open to diverse perspectives.
To investigate the determinants governing evidence use by clinical networks acting as quality and safety stewards, researchers conducted an investigation using Q-methodology. This methodological framework, predominantly utilized within health and social sciences research, enables a holistic examination of participant viewpoints through the quantitative analysis of qualitative data. By design, Q-methodology provides a structured means to evaluate the subjective dimensions of tacitly understood operational issues. Drawing from existing literature, the research established core study domains that encompassed network management, participation, evidence types, and evidence use processes.
The investigation utilized stratified purposeful sampling across three distinct clinical networks within Victoria, engaging a total of 26 participants. Furthermore, the participants possessed varying degrees of tenure in their respective network responsibilities. Data regarding tenure duration were systematically recorded by the research team to provide necessary context for interpreting the resulting Q-sort configurations.
Analytical evaluation involved Q-method data intercorrelation followed by by-person factor analysis, from which four primary factors emerged. After rotation, these factors accounted for 45 percent of the total study variance, with construct validity successfully demonstrated across the analytical model. Full factor interpretations revealed clear divisions in how different health disciplines approach evidence. Viewpoint one reflected a scientific understanding of evidence, directing stewardship primarily toward clinical practice issues and prioritizing the authoritative application of evidence to guide practice. Medical professionals aligned predominantly with this first viewpoint, matching the core tenets of traditional evidence-based medicine.
In contrast to the medical alignment with Viewpoint one, participants from nursing and other health disciplines aligned primarily with viewpoints two and three, which embodied pragmatic and vision-centred approaches to evidence use. A fourth viewpoint was also identified, which placed its central value on knowledge generation and ongoing learning. Based on these findings, the study authors observed that evidence-based stewards in clinical networks must influence autonomous, diverse actors through trust, particularly in settings where conventional forms of power and control prove less effective. The authors concluded that while clinical networks remain grounded in positivist logic, their success relies on integrating strategic and pragmatic skills to improve population health outcomes, affirming Q-methodology as an effective framework for examining ill-defined concepts across multidisciplinary healthcare structures.
Subject of Research: Evidence use and governance viewpoints within Australian clinical networks
Article Title: How do clinical networks as safety and quality stewards understand evidence and evidence use? A Q-methodology study
Article References: Hart, J., Naccarella, L., & Dickinson, H. (2026). How do clinical networks as safety and quality stewards understand evidence and evidence use? A Q-methodology study. BMC Health Services Research. https://doi.org/10.1186/s12913-026-16097-3
Image Credits: AI Generated
DOI: 10.1186/s12913-026-16097-3
Keywords: clinical networks, Q-methodology, evidence-based care, health services research, safety and quality, stewardship, evidence-based medicine, by-person factor analysis, qualitative data analysis, construct validity, network management, evidence use processes, stratified purposeful sampling, population health outcomes, intersectoral structures, multidisciplinary structures, Victoria
News Source: Ophelia Keating. (November 14, 2026). Study Identifies Four Distinct Viewpoints on Evidence Use Across Clinical Networks. Scienmag.



