A bacteriological survey investigating retail meat safety in Osogbo, Nigeria, has detected multidrug-resistant strains of Shiga toxigenic Escherichia coli contaminating raw beef sold across municipal abattoirs and market stalls. The investigation, conducted across the local government areas of Olorunda and Osogbo in Osun State, assessed the microbial quality of beef products destined for local consumption and revealed extensive contamination by enteric bacteria indicative of severe hygiene lapses along the meat production and distribution chain. Laboratory analysis confirmed that eighteen percent of the sampled beef harboured viable Shiga toxin-producing strains possessing key virulence determinants associated with severe gastrointestinal pathology in humans. Beyond demonstrating persistent bacterial carriage on commercial meat surfaces, antimicrobial susceptibility testing uncovered widespread resistance to multiple frontline and critical clinical antibiotics, underscoring significant concerns regarding foodborne zoonotic transmission and the ongoing dissemination of resistant pathogens within regional food supplies.
Foodborne diarrhoeal illnesses represent a profound global public health burden, causing more than two million deaths annually with a disproportionate impact observed among children under five years of age. While preventable through adequate sanitation, hygienic food handling, and safe dietary practices, diarrhoeal diseases remain challenging to monitor and document comprehensively in developing nations such as Nigeria due to limited epidemiological surveillance systems, diagnostic resource constraints, and the absence of unified disease registries. In Nigeria, domestic ruminants—predominantly cattle managed through extensive nomadic pastoralist practices—serve as the principal source of animal dietary protein. However, the gastrointestinal tracts of cattle represent well-established natural reservoirs for pathogenic Escherichia coli, particularly Shiga toxigenic and enterohaemorrhagic variants. As consumer demand drives continuous throughput across municipal abattoirs and open-air retail shops, unsanitary slaughtering conditions, evisceration errors, and manual carcass portioning frequently facilitate cross-contamination, transforming essential food commodities into potential transmission vehicles for human infection.
To rigorously characterize bacterial carriage and resistance profiles, the research team implemented a structured five-month sampling campaign spanning March to July 2023 across selected municipal abattoirs and meat retail shops located within the geographic boundaries of Osogbo. Exactly one hundred raw beef samples were systematically gathered, comprising fifty specimens from Olorunda Local Government Area and fifty specimens from Osogbo Local Government Area, with collections split evenly between twenty slaughterhouses and eighty retail butcher outlets. Beef samples were procured early in the morning immediately following slaughter, placed aseptically into sterile containers, and maintained under refrigerated conditions using frozen gel packs during transit to the microbiology laboratory at Osun State University. Processing occurred within two hours of procurement, ensuring that microbiological analyses accurately reflected the baseline sanitary state of the meat at the point of distribution and sale to local consumers.
Initial bacteriological screening involved the quantitative enumeration of total coliform populations and selective culturing of potential Escherichia coli isolates. Homogenized beef samples were prepared in phosphate-buffered saline and evaluated using pour-plating on MacConkey agar to establish baseline coliform burdens, while selective enrichment in tryptone soy broth supplemented with novobiocin preceded isolation on sorbitol MacConkey agar. The resulting coliform counts revealed heavy bacterial colonization across all sampled commercial facilities. Abattoirs in Olorunda Local Government Area exhibited the highest mean coliform density at 6.7 log colony-forming units per gram, with corresponding retail shops averaging 6.69 log colony-forming units per gram. In Osogbo Local Government Area, mean abattoir counts reached 6.3 log colony-forming units per gram while retail shops averaged 6.6 log colony-forming units per gram. These microbial levels notably exceed established international safety thresholds, such as the United States Department of Agriculture regulatory ceiling of 3 log colony-forming units per gram for boneless beef, indicating severe fecal contamination during processing.
Following culture-based screening on selective media and confirmatory tests on eosin methylene blue agar, twenty-two presumptive Escherichia coli colonies were isolated from the one hundred analyzed meat samples. Definitive species identification was established through molecular amplification and 16S ribosomal RNA gene sequencing, confirming eighteen distinct isolates as authentic Escherichia coli and establishing an overall sample prevalence of eighteen percent, with a ninety-five percent confidence interval spanning from 10.5 percent to 25.5 percent. Subsequent evolutionary analysis using the software MEGA X and neighbour-joining phylogenetic reconstruction demonstrated that the recovered beef strains shared close evolutionary lineage with verified reference strains catalogued in the National Center for Biotechnology Information database. When compared with broader geographic literature, this eighteen percent recovery rate surpassed prevalence figures previously documented in other Nigerian regions, including Kwara State at 5.6 percent and Delta State at 13.8 percent, while remaining lower than figures recorded in Plateau State at 26.3 percent and Ghana at 92.7 percent.
The confirmed bacterial isolates were subsequently examined for critical virulence determinants that govern the pathogenicity of Shiga toxigenic strains, specifically screening for the Shiga toxin 1 gene, Shiga toxin 2 gene, intimin-encoding gene eaeA, and enterohaemolysin gene hlyA. Polymerase chain reaction assays revealed that sixteen of the eighteen confirmed isolates carried at least one of these major pathogenic markers. The Shiga toxin 2 gene predominated across the collection, being detected in thirteen isolates, representing 72.22 percent of the recovered strains, while three isolates carried the intimin eaeA gene and two isolates tested positive for enterohaemolysin hlyA. None of the screened strains harboured the Shiga toxin 1 gene. Genetic profiling revealed that fourteen strains encoded a single virulence factor—eleven possessing solely stx2 and three possessing eaeA—while two strains exhibited the concurrent carriage of both stx2 and hlyA, a combination frequently associated with heightened virulence and severe clinical outcomes such as hemorrhagic colitis and hemolytic uremic syndrome.
Antimicrobial susceptibility characterization performed via the standardized Kirby-Bauer disk diffusion method revealed alarming patterns of drug insensitivity across thirteen tested therapeutic compounds representing seven major pharmacological classes. Across all recovered Shiga toxigenic isolates, total resistance of one hundred percent was documented against cefoxitin, cefepime, and the second-generation combination agent ceftazidime/avibactam. Markedly high resistance frequencies were likewise observed against aztreonam at 94.44 percent, sulfamethoxazole/trimethoprim at 83.33 percent, ampicillin/sulbactam at 83.33 percent, meropenem at 77.77 percent, nitrofurantoin at 72.22 percent, and doxycycline at 61.11 percent. Overall, the isolates displayed a cumulative resistance rate of 71.37 percent across all tested antibiotic agents. Effective antibacterial activity was limited to a small subset of agents, with moderate susceptibility recorded only for the fluoroquinolone levofloxacin at 61.11 percent and the aminoglycoside gentamicin at 55.56 percent.
Classification under international surveillance criteria established by public health agencies revealed that 94.44 percent, representing seventeen of the eighteen recovered isolates, satisfied the definition of multidrug resistance by displaying non-susceptibility to at least one agent in three or more antimicrobial categories. Furthermore, among these multidrug-resistant organisms, 35.29 percent were categorized as extensively drug-resistant, exhibiting resistance to at least one agent in all except two or fewer tested classes, though no isolates met the criteria for complete pandrug resistance. Of notable clinical gravity was the recovery of fourteen isolates exhibiting resistance to meropenem, a carbapenem compound conventionally reserved as a critical, last-resort therapeutic agent for managing complicated, refractory Gram-negative infections in hospital settings. The emergence of carbapenem non-susceptibility within food-associated bacteria highlights an alarming breach of critical clinical defense lines within standard livestock environments.
The extensive carriage of resistant pathogens documented in Osogbo reflects longstanding structural challenges surrounding agricultural antibiotic administration and informal animal husbandry. Although Nigeria’s National Agency for Food and Drug Administration and Control enacted formal prohibitions against incorporating medically important antimicrobials as subtherapeutic growth promoters in livestock feeds, regulatory enforcement across decentralized agricultural markets remains difficult. Extensive field surveys indicate that up to seventy percent of pastoralists and nomadic livestock handlers lack formal training regarding the biological hazards of antimicrobial misuse, routinely obtaining veterinary and human pharmaceuticals over the counter without clinical prescriptions. This sustained selective pressure fosters the emergence and persistence of mobile resistance determinants within cattle herds, which subsequently transfer directly into human food chains through abattoir waste, surface contact, and contaminated equipment during slaughter.
Mitigating the imminent public health hazards presented by antibiotic-resistant foodborne pathogens necessitates targeted operational reforms throughout the regional livestock sector. The substantial coliform counts documented throughout municipal abattoirs and retail markets demonstrate that structural deficiencies in water safety, inadequate hand hygiene monitoring, unsterilized butchering blades, and contaminated meat display platforms represent primary vectors driving product contamination. Implementing standardized prerequisite sanitation programs, improving clean running water infrastructure at slaughter slabs, and enforcing routine microbial monitoring are essential immediate interventions. Concurrently, regional authorities emphasize the necessity of a coordinated One Health strategy linking veterinary oversight, public health surveillance, and educational outreach to pastoralist communities to curtail indiscriminate antimicrobial administration, thereby preserving therapeutic efficacy and protecting consumer populations from virulent foodborne infections.
Subject of Research: Surveillance and antimicrobial resistance profiling of Shiga toxigenic Escherichia coli isolated from beef in Osogbo, Nigeria
Article Title: Surveillance and potential health risks of antibiotic-resistant shiga toxigenic Escherichia coli isolated from beef sold in Osogbo, Nigeria
Article References: Olaitan, J. O., Dieseru, M. A., Oluwajide, O. O., Titilawo, M. A., Akinde, S. B., & Daramola, O. B. (2025). Surveillance and potential health risks of antibiotic-resistant shiga toxigenic Escherichia coli isolated from beef sold in Osogbo, Nigeria. Discover Bacteria, 2(1), Article 6. https://doi.org/10.1007/s44351-025-00012-y
Image Credits: AI Generated
DOI: 10.1007/s44351-025-00012-y
Keywords: Escherichia coli, Shiga toxigenic E. coli, Food safety, Antimicrobial resistance, Beef surveillance, Osogbo, Nigeria, Multidrug resistance, stx2 gene, eaeA gene, hlyA gene, Bacterial contamination, Coliform count, Public health, One Health, Abattoir hygiene
News Source: Kristina Jarvis. (November 13, 2026). Study Finds Antibiotic Resistant Shiga Toxin Producing E Coli in Nigerian Beef. Scienmag.



