A new study published in Globalization and Health identifies three recurring discursive mechanisms that structure health-relevant governance during contemporary security crises. The research, led by Amir Khorram-Manesh, Harald De Cauwer, Dennis G. Barten, and Krzysztof Goniewicz, applies a critical geopolitics framework and critical discourse analysis to examine how geopolitical narratives condition humanitarian access and civilian protection. The authors argue that while the health consequences of war and economic coercion are widely documented, less attention has been paid to the discursive processes through which such consequences are rendered legitimate, unavoidable, or politically peripheral. This qualitative study focuses on institutional and policy discourse rather than media or public opinion narratives, aiming to reveal how security frameworks stabilize governance arrangements with significant health consequences.
The study draws on a purposive, illustrative corpus consisting of a primary set of institutional and policy documents and a secondary set of scholarly literature. The primary corpus includes state communications, United Nations and World Health Organization documents, sanctions guidance, and reports from international non-governmental organizations. These documents were produced between 2019 and 2025 and were selected for their prominence in contemporary security governance. The analysis covers five illustrative case contexts: US–China geopolitical rivalry, the Russia–Ukraine war, the Israel–Palestine/Gaza crisis, Iran-related sanctions and protest governance, and US–Venezuela sanctions governance. These cases provide variation across rivalry, war, protracted humanitarian crisis, and sanctions governance, enabling the cross-case identification of recurring discursive mechanisms.
The researchers employed critical discourse analysis as their primary qualitative methodology to examine how language functions as social practice. This approach investigates how institutional texts produce and reproduce authority, legitimacy, and the boundaries of what is politically thinkable and institutionally actionable. The analysis did not treat texts as neutral descriptions of events but rather as sites where competing narratives of security, sovereignty, responsibility, and humanitarian protection are articulated. The methodological aim was to show how discourse structures the field of permissible policy action, rather than to claim that discourse alone determines material outcomes. The study explicitly avoids inferring a direct causal chain from discourse to health outcomes, instead examining discourse as one governance condition among others that interacts with military, economic, legal, and health-system factors.
The analysis identified three recurring discursive mechanisms: securitization, exception-making, and displacement of responsibility. Securitization refers to the discursive movement through which health-relevant domains are represented as threats or strategic vulnerabilities requiring urgent or exceptional governance. Exception-making refers to the authorization of departures from ordinary protection norms through claims of necessity, proportionality, temporariness, or emergency. Responsibility displacement refers to language that diffuses agency by presenting harms as indirect, technical, logistical, market-based, or politically contested. These mechanisms interact to create what the authors conceptualize as a “permission-with-friction” governance architecture, in which access is formally enabled yet practically constrained through administrative, compliance, and operational conditions.
In the US–China geopolitical rivalry case, institutional discourse consistently framed health-relevant issues through the lens of strategic competition. Supply-chain resilience, technological sovereignty, and risk reduction were positioned as central concerns, with interdependence treated as vulnerability. Pharmaceuticals and medical technologies were treated as strategic dependencies requiring insulation from geopolitical risk. The study notes that this securitizing discourse performs governance work by making “resilience” and “insulation” the default rationales for actions that reshape access and allocation across borders. This framing shifts policy attention toward decoupling, redundancy, and strategic reserves, while equity-oriented frames, such as health as an entitlement or global public good, are displaced to the periphery of policy concern.
In the Russia–Ukraine war context, texts were structured around sovereignty and civilizational narratives. Civilian infrastructure, including healthcare facilities, was discursively absorbed into security imaginaries. The study highlights that even when international humanitarian law was acknowledged, the framing of existential conflict functioned to normalize prolonged disruption of healthcare delivery. Health harms appeared as documented and tragic yet were repeatedly positioned as an expected feature of war rather than a preventable governance failure. The analysis points to a discursive gap between moralized war justifications and technical documentation by organizations like the WHO, which can support responsibility displacement by making repeated attack patterns legible as structural features of war rather than linked to contestable operational choices.
The Israel–Palestine/Gaza crisis case illustrates how exception-making is enacted through the governance vocabulary of “pauses,” “corridors,” and “operating environment.” Institutional discourse dominated by security narratives structured whose vulnerability became visible and whose suffering was marginalized. Constraints on movement and access were framed as security necessities, while humanitarian measures enabled operational response while discursively bounding the scope of protection. The study argues that this language makes constraint administratively legible while narrowing the discursive horizon of what protection means. It suggests that the language of temporary relief can delimit the meaning of protection even when material risk remains high, effectively separating “security policy” from “health outcomes” in governance discourse.
In Iran-related sanctions and protest governance, the discourse combined moralized threat narratives with exception-making. Sanctions were legitimized as security measures, while humanitarian exemptions were affirmed in formal language. However, compliance risk and enforcement language foregrounded threats to financial and commercial actors, shaping how exemptions operated in practice. The study notes that this framing displaces responsibility for resultant health harms onto markets, logistics, and intermediaries. Additionally, the corpus shows how internal repression and external coercive policy can interact discursively, with protest governance disputing mortality and framing unrest as foreign-instigated threat. This produces a discursive environment in which both access barriers and death tolls can become governable without accountability, with longer-run impacts like disability burdens and mental health harms narrated as “indirect” and thus politically insulated.
The US–Venezuela sanctions governance case demonstrates how delegitimating language works in tandem with exception-making. Institutional discourse framed the Maduro government through legitimacy and security narratives, authorizing coercive measures. Humanitarian activity was governed as a licensed exception within a broader constraint regime, with formal authorizations enumerated in guidance while practical access remained conditioned by compliance structures. The study finds that responsibility for downstream harms was often displaced by foregrounding formal permissibility while relocating failures to implementation layers, such as bank de-risking and transaction friction. This stabilizes the coercive policy architecture while discursively insulating it from civilian health harms, rendering them politically peripheral rather than governance relevant.
The study emphasizes that these mechanisms do not operate in isolation but interact to narrow policy debate and normalize prolonged constraints on civilians. Securitization establishes strategic priority, exception-making authorizes departures from ordinary norms, and responsibility displacement stabilizes accountability gaps. The authors argue that health inequity functions not only as an outcome of crisis governance but as a diagnostic signal of deeper transformations in security-oriented governance. Disrupted access, constrained protection, and contested mortality become visible where these mechanisms converge, revealing how exceptional security logics displace commitments to civilian protection and the right to health. The research suggests that recognizing these discursive conditions is critical to preventing the routinization of health harm as an acceptable feature of crisis management.
Limitations of the study include the interpretive nature of critical discourse analysis and the absence of modeling of non-discursive determinants such as baseline capacity and macroeconomics. The analytic corpus consisted of English-language documents or documents available in official English translation, which may exclude different rhetorical forms or counter-discourses present in other languages. The purposive corpus supports mechanism-building and interpretive comparison but does not permit claims about the prevalence of these mechanisms across all crisis discourse. The authors note that the excerpts presented are illustrative rather than exhaustive, and that other selections and readings remain possible. Future research could triangulate critical discourse analysis with interviews, ethnography, and quantitative health indicators to provide a more comprehensive understanding of the health-security nexus.
Subject of Research: Critical discourse analysis of security governance and health inequity in contemporary geopolitical crises
Article Title: Security governance and health inequity in contemporary crises: a critical discourse analysis of securitization, exception-making, and responsibility displacement
Article References: Khorram-Manesh, A., De Cauwer, H., Barten, D. G., & Goniewicz, K. (2026). Security governance and health inequity in contemporary crises: a critical discourse analysis of securitization, exception-making, and responsibility displacement. Globalization and Health, 22(1), Article 55. https://doi.org/10.1186/s12992-026-01226-8
Image Credits: AI Generated
DOI: 10.1186/s12992-026-01226-8
Keywords: critical discourse analysis, health inequity, security governance, securitization, humanitarian access, geopolitics, crisis management, public health policy, sanctions governance, civilian protection, Security, governance
News Source: Courtney Benton. (November 11, 2026). Security Narratives Shape Health Inequity in Global Crises. Scienmag.



