A new systematic review and meta-analysis published in BMC Ecology and Evolution synthesizes evidence on the distribution, major threats, and management methods of maple tree species in temperate forests. The study, led by Melkamu Kassaye and colleagues, aims to provide an inclusive understanding of these trees to facilitate their sustainability. The research team notes that despite the contribution of maple species to multiple ecosystem goods and services, their distribution, survival, and growth are declining due to multiple interconnected threats. The paper was published on August 4, 2026, and is available as an open access article.
The study employed PRISMA methods to conduct its systematic review and meta-analyses. The authors incorporated a total of 115 original studies into their analysis. This comprehensive approach was designed to address the lack of a comprehensive review for these species that would facilitate effective management and utilization. By synthesizing data from a large number of original studies, the researchers sought to establish a clearer picture of the current state of maple forests in temperate regions.
The meta-analysis calculated mean effect sizes for both major threats and sustainable forest management practices. The mean effect size for the included studies regarding major threats was found to be in the positive moderate range, with a Standardized Mean Difference (SMD) of 0.46. For sustainable forest management, the mean effect size was also in the positive moderate range, with an SMD of 0.44. These statistical results indicate a moderate impact from both the threats facing the trees and the management practices applied to them.
The statistical significance of these findings was confirmed with a p-value of less than 0.001. The level of heterogeneity among the included studies was considered acceptable, with I-squared values ranging from 7 to 28 percent.
The review identifies several specific factors that pose significant threats to the distribution, growth, and survival of maple trees and forests. Frequent climatic events are highlighted as a major concern. In addition to climate-related issues, man-made extreme disturbances contribute to the decline of these species. The study also points to intensive browsing and disease infestations as significant threats. These interconnected threats create a complex challenge for the conservation and management of temperate maple forests.
Regarding management, the review notes that some studies have explored sustainable forest management practices. These practices mainly focus on harvesting, regeneration, and restoration efforts to address the identified threats. However, the authors observe that most of the existing research focuses on fewer than ten common maple tree species. This narrow focus means that many native, endemic, and threatened species are often overlooked in the current body of literature.
The study specifically highlights a gap in research concerning East Asia. The authors note that many native, endemic, and threatened maple species in this region are overlooked in the majority of studies.
Based on these findings, the authors recommend further research into the current ecological dynamics and biological characteristics of maple trees. They emphasize the need for studies on silvicultural management, as well as pest and disease management. Additionally, the review calls for research into the short- and long-term ecological responses and resilience of these trees under changing climate conditions. This forward-looking approach is deemed essential for developing effective strategies to ensure the sustainability of maple forests in the face of ongoing threats.
Subject of Research: Systematic review and meta-analysis of maple tree distribution, threats, and management in temperate forests
Article Title: Distribution, major threats, and management methods of maple tree species in temperate forests: a systematic review and meta-analysis
Article References: Kassaye, M., Abdulmalik, D., Dongliang, Z., Yu, X., Jinyang, W., Adugna, D., Getnet, A., Clouds, E., & Huiyan, G. (2026). Distribution, major threats, and management methods of maple tree species in temperate forests: a systematic review and meta-analysis. BMC Ecology and Evolution, 26(1), Article 98. https://doi.org/10.1186/s12862-026-02567-z
Image Credits: AI Generated
DOI: 10.1186/s12862-026-02567-z
Keywords: maple trees, temperate forests, systematic review, meta-analysis, forest management, climate threats, ecology, conservation, BMC Ecology and Evolution, Distribution, major, threats
News Source: Gavin Prescott. (November 12, 2026). Review Finds Moderate Threat Impact on Temperate Maples. Scienmag.



