A qualitative investigation of kidney specialists reveals that shared decision-making during dialysis modality selection faces substantial barriers across clinical, interpersonal, and healthcare system levels, according to research published in BMC Nephrology. Although clinical evidence indicates comparable outcomes and potentially better quality of life associated with home dialysis and conservative kidney management, a larger-than-expected proportion of patients with end-stage kidney disease continues to receive in-centre haemodialysis. The findings indicate that clinicians’ individual perspectives interact directly with organisational structures, often reinforcing in-centre haemodialysis as the default management pathway rather than facilitating genuine shared choice.
To explore the subjective beliefs and working assumptions driving these decisions, researchers conducted an exploratory qualitative study employing vignettes-based Q-methodology combined with think-aloud interviews. The investigation sampled nephrologists across 15 medical centres, purposively applying maximum-variation sampling according to physician age, gender, clinical experience, and the size of their centre’s home dialysis programme. Recruitment and interviews continued until no substantial new themes emerged from the transcripts, ensuring the study captured a broad spectrum of clinical perspectives while adhering to the Consolidated Criteria for Reporting Qualitative Research guidelines.
The study cohort comprised 25 nephrologists whose recorded interview transcripts underwent systematic inductive thematic analysis. From this qualitative analysis, investigators identified three primary levels of operational challenges that impede the consistent implementation of shared decision-making. These levels spanned clinicians’ self-perceived professional roles and their views of other stakeholders, perceived institutional and systemic impediments across organisational tiers, and operational obstacles inherent to applying shared decision-making principles directly to dialysis modality choices.
At the individual and interpersonal level, clinicians exhibited a broad spectrum of perceived professional roles, ranging from paternalistic stances to supportive, interpreter, or purely informative roles. Concurrently, participating nephrologists described the roles played by other key stakeholders, including patients, family members, general practitioners, and pre-dialysis nurses. Although nephrologists widely recognized nurses as the primary providers of pre-dialysis patient education, the study revealed a critical absence of structured institutional strategies designed to support and enhance nursing competencies in shared decision-making.
At the meso and macro organisational levels, the analysis identified substantial systemic barriers within departmental units, healthcare institutions, and broader healthcare governance. Participating nephrologists reported limited availability of dedicated clinical resources and specialized support services necessary to deliver balanced modality education. Furthermore, existing economic structures and reimbursement mechanisms were perceived as insufficient, specifically regarding the financial compensation and structural support dedicated to the educational dimensions of pre-dialysis kidney care.
The study also delineated challenges specific to applying shared decision-making within kidney failure consultations, highlighting limited clinician engagement in shared decision-making processes and variable expertise in home dialysis modalities and conservative kidney management. The authors noted that persistent misconceptions regarding clinical contraindications and an inconsistent application of available clinical evidence often compromise shared decision-making before consultations formally begin. The researchers conclude that shifting clinical culture will require structural collaboration across units, broader clinician exposure to alternative modalities, and aligned financial and operational initiatives.
The qualitative exploration also examined the specific background conditions prompting this investigation into dialysis modality decision-making across nephrology centres. The study authors highlighted that conventional economic interventions, particularly those focused exclusively on modifying treatment reimbursement rates for dialysis sessions, have proven inadequate for shifting patients toward home-based care or conservative pathways, pointing instead toward entrenched departmental norms and local clinical cultures as powerful determinants of modality distribution.
By probing physicians’ subjective reasoning, the authors traced how unaddressed clinical predispositions and unfamiliarity with non-centre options actively restrict the scope of choices offered to individuals facing end-stage kidney disease. When clinicians lack sufficient direct clinical experience or ongoing exposure to home dialysis modalities and conservative kidney management, persistent prejudices regarding perceived treatment contraindications frequently arise. In practical terms, these subjective assumptions filter and narrow the range of educational materials, support structures, and clinical pathways presented during pre-dialysis discussions, subtly steering patients toward conventional in-centre haemodialysis long before any structured collaborative decision-making process can take place.
Addressing these entrenched dynamics, the investigators noted, will require healthcare systems to look beyond relying on individual physician goodwill or personal motivation.
Subject of Research: Qualitative analysis of clinician and systemic barriers to shared decision-making in dialysis modality selection
Article Title: Dialysis modality selection: Why do we not truly share? A qualitative study of kidney physicians
Article References: Clause, A.-L., Cortvrindt, C., Le Moine, A., Leune, T., Moreels, T., & Van Biesen, W. (2026). Dialysis modality selection: Why do we not truly share? A qualitative study of kidney physicians. BMC Nephrology. https://doi.org/10.1186/s12882-026-05498-5
Image Credits: AI Generated
DOI: 10.1186/s12882-026-05498-5
Keywords: dialysis modality selection, shared decision-making, end-stage kidney disease, in-centre haemodialysis, home dialysis, conservative kidney management, nephrologists, qualitative research, Q-methodology, think-aloud interviews, thematic analysis, pre-dialysis education, unit culture, healthcare system barriers, clinical decision-making, COREQ guidelines
News Source: Jerry Hayes. (November 13, 2026). Nephrologist Attitudes and System Barriers Constrain Shared Dialysis Decision-Making. Scienmag.



