ALBUQUERQUE, N.M. — Water utilities have a Goldilocks problem: If they don't add enough chlorine, nasty bacteria that cause typhoid and cholera survive the purification process. Too much chlorine produces disinfection byproducts such as chloroform, which increase cancer risks. The amount of chlorine needs to be "just right" for safe drinking water.
Curtis Mowry and Mike Siegal with tiny nanoporous carbon coated SAW sensors in front of blue water pipes
Sandia National Laboratories researchers Curtis Mowry, left, and Mike Siegal show their nanoporous carbon coated surface acoustic wave sensors. Their sensor forms the heart of Parker Hannifin's Trihalomethane Water Analyzer that provides almost-instant feedback on the disinfection byproduct levels of water, before it reaches consumers. (Photo by Randy Montoya) Click on the thumbnail for a high-resolution image.
The Environmental Protection Agency regulates how much of the disinfection byproducts, including those known as trihalomethanes, are allowed in our drinking water. But if water utilities want to monitor and control their own trihalomethane levels, they have to send off samples and wait weeks for analysis by an EPA-qualified lab.
Working with Parker Hannifin, Sandia National Laboratories combined basic research on an interesting form of carbon with a unique microsensor to make an easy-to-use, table-top tool that quickly and cheaply detects extremely low levels of each trihalomethane: chloroform, bromoform, bromodichloromethane and dibromochloromethane.
No longer do utilities need to send samples to EPA-qualified labs, hire their own highly trained chemist to perform the EPA test, or buy an expensive mass spectrometer system to routinely monitor their trihalomethane levels and ensure cleaner drinking water for the public, said Sandia materials scientist Mike Siegal.
Recently, Parker Hannifin released an automated online version of the water analyzer for continuous monitoring of trihalomethanes.
Cool and controllable carbon coatings
The original goal of the project was to make a hand-held chemistry lab, like a tricorder, to detect airborne hazardous chemicals, including chemical weapons. A principal component of this lab-on-a-chip was a surface acoustic wave sensor. This SAW sensor works by vibrating a wave along a quartz sheet, said analytical chemist Curtis Mowry. By measuring how the wave changes on the SAW device, researchers can tell how many chemicals are sticking to the quartz surface.
In a way, it's similar to playing with a playground parachute. Those holding the parachute can tell the difference between a bunch of balls or a child by how the parachute moves when they shake it. However, the quartz surface isn't very sticky, which limits its sensitivity. This is where a special carbon coating comes in.
TEM image, nanoporous carbon coated SAW sensor on a quarter, and Parker-Hannifin's Trihalomethane Water Analyzer
Transmission electron microscopy image of nanoporous carbon, left, "the most controllable carbon in the world, in the terms of its mass density and its total surface area," according to Sandia National Laboratories researcher Mike Siegal. A nanoporous carbon coated surface acoustic wave sensor on a quarter, middle. This sensor is the key component of Parker Hannifin's Trihalomethane Water Analyzer, right. (Image courtesy Sandia National Laboratories) Click on the thumbnail for a high-resolution image.
Natural carbon can appear as exotic diamonds, common graphite composed of many layers of graphene sheets, and many other forms. Nanoporous carbon consists of stacked nanofragments of graphene sheets, engineered with lots of nooks and crannies where chemicals can lodge. Unlike carbon nanotubes or graphene with similar molecularly "sticky" surfaces, nanoporous carbon can be grown onto almost anything, including SAW devices, said Siegal.
This growth process, known as pulsed laser deposition, involves zapping graphite with a laser at room temperature. The liberated carbon atoms fly through a vacuum chamber to coat the SAW sensor in a uniform and reproducible manner. By adding a little bit of an inert gas to the vacuum chamber, Siegal can control and vary the density and total surface area of nanoporous carbon coatings from very fluffy to as solid as pure graphite.
For the SAW sensors, nanoporous carbon with a middling density turns out to be best. Only three grams of such nanoporous carbon has as much surface area as a football field, yet is rigid enough to work for SAW sensors.
To extend the parachute metaphor, nanoporous carbon is like Velcro, capturing every ball that touches the parachute. Siegal said, "The first time we applied the carbon coating, it turned out to be a thousand times better than any organic coating that Sandia, or anyone else, had ever studied to adsorb volatile chemicals."
Mowry added, "The winning combination was teaming up with Siegal and his nanoporous carbon coatings and using larger, almost retro SAW devices." For SAW devices — and for most electronics — smaller is better and newer. At the time, Sandia's newest and smallest SAWs used higher frequency vibrations with more advanced microelectronics. However, they were also more expensive, harder to make and less reliable. Using larger devices, roughly the dimensions of a Tic Tac, that were state-of-the-art in the '90s, it was easy to apply the nanoporous carbon coating — which increased the sensitivity a thousand times more than decreasing the size — and dramatically decreased the cost of the device.
The journey from basic science to commercial product for the public good
The journey began in 2002, building on years of chemical sensor research and development. Mowry was trying to develop a sensor to detect volatile organic contaminants, such as chemicals from an industrial spill or leaks, in water. His presentation at a water quality conference caught the eye of a Parker Hannifin engineer and led to the partnership in 2006.
It took several years to cross the "valley of death" from promising research to commercial product, but by 2011 Parker Hannifin released its first Trihalomethane Water Analyzer. The second, online version of the analyzer can automatically monitor individual trihalomethane levels every hour. Parker Hannifin has more dedicated trihalomethane analyzers installed in North America than any other company.
A video about the Trihalomethane Water Analyzer is available on Sandia's YouTube channel. The analyzer was an R&D100 Awards nominee in 2012.
Other potential uses for nanoporous carbon coated SAW sensors include detecting homemade explosives, contaminants in air and water and almost any volatile or semi-volatile organic compound, said Mowry.
Additionally, Siegal and others are exploring using nanoporous carbon for battery anodes. Siegal and Sandia Labs colleague Graham Yelton demonstrated the first steps toward viable magnesium ion batteries, which would be more energy dense than lithium ion batteries. Higher energy density batteries could lead to electric cars that can go farther, longer lasting cellphone batteries, even satellites with longer missions. Sandia researcher Katie Harrison and Siegal have continued the work by adding silicon to lithium-ion battery anodes, which could potentially triple their energy storage density.
The initial and follow-up work by Siegal, Mowry and their teams was funded by Sandia's Laboratory Directed Research and Development program.
"Everybody who's been involved with this project always smiles when they talk about it," Siegal said. "Not only did we see our basic research into what this carbon material was and the physics of how SAW devices work come together, but we helped develop a successful product that improves public health."