Practical adoption of novel value elements in health technology assessment remains uneven because components are frequently defined inconsistently and may overlap. To address this methodological challenge, researchers have constructed a welfare-grounded accounting framework designed to organize societal value components systematically and determine when proposed elements represent distinct welfare changes rather than alternative labels for the same underlying effect.
Rather than treating novel elements as independent add-ons, the authors grounded their analytical formulation directly in established economic fundamentals to evaluate how healthcare interventions affect societal well-being.
Methodologically, the authors drew upon individual utility theory and social welfare functions to establish a sequential three-step accounting structure. The first step specifies the primitive consequences experienced by affected individuals. The second step maps those primitive consequences into individual utility, and the third step aggregates individual utilities into a broader social welfare function.
Under this analytical architecture, primitive consequences are organized into two primary categories: changes in health-related functioning or experience, and changes in consumption or other non-health resource consequences. By clearly differentiating primitive consequences from the subsequent utility mapping and aggregation stages, the framework provides a transparent mechanism to reinterpret commonly cited value elements and identify where conceptual duplication occurs.
The resulting framework categorizes proposed value elements across three distinct structural levels. Level 1 expands the outcome space. This level includes caregiver and relational spillovers, productivity, fear of contagion, value of knowing, and scientific spillovers.
Level 2 concerns features of the utility mapping. This includes severity, outcome uncertainty, and value of hope through risk preferences or cross-domain dependence.
Level 3 focuses on aggregation choices within the social welfare function, explicitly incorporating societal preferences regarding equity and intergenerational considerations. Notably, the authors demonstrated that relational spillovers, financing effects, and future-cohort effects serve as distribution channels that broaden the set of affected individuals across populations, rather than operating as separate add-on value components.
Ultimately, the researchers concluded that establishing a welfare-based accounting framework organizes societal value components while clarifying exactly where proposed elements enter economic evaluations. By making overlap explicit and auditable, the framework helps reduce double counting without treating novel elements as independent add-ons.
Subject of Research: Welfare-based accounting framework for societal value in health technology assessment
Article Title: Back to economic fundamentals: a welfare-based accounting framework for societal value in health technology assessment
Article References: Li, M., Cohen, J., Shi, L., Neumann, P., & Monfared, A. A. T. (2026). Back to economic fundamentals: a welfare-based accounting framework for societal value in health technology assessment. Health Economics Review. https://doi.org/10.1186/s13561-026-00856-3
Image Credits: AI Generated
DOI: 10.1186/s13561-026-00856-3
Keywords: health technology assessment, societal value, welfare-based accounting framework, social welfare functions, individual utility theory, novel value elements, double counting, caregiver spillovers, productivity, fear of contagion, value of knowing, scientific spillovers, outcome uncertainty, value of hope, risk preferences, cross-domain dependence, relational spillovers, intergenerational considerations
News Source: Ophelia Keating. (November 19, 2026). Welfare Accounting Framework Clarifies Societal Value Elements in Health Technology Assessment. Scienmag.



