Topical teething gels commercially marketed to alleviate infant discomfort exert significant, concentration-dependent, and time-dependent effects on epithelial barrier integrity and cellular viability in laboratory cell models, according to an in vitro investigation published in Head & Face Medicine. Tooth eruption represents a normal physiological developmental process in young children, during which the unerupted tooth moves through alveolar jaw bone before emerging into the oral cavity. Beginning at an average age of six months, the erupting tooth resides within the dental follicle, a anatomical site enriched with inflammatory cytokines, eicosanoids, and growth factors activated by intraosseous movement. Although scientific consensus remains absent regarding direct links between tooth eruption and systemic illness, the process frequently associates with localized gum irritation, gingival inflammation, excess salivation, finger sucking, appetite loss, irritability, fever, and diarrhea. To examine how topical preparations interact with mucosal tissues at the cellular level, investigators evaluated six commercial teething gels across four dilutions, discovering marked formulation-dependent variations in epithelial resistance and cell viability.
Caregivers commonly utilize pharmacological and non-pharmacological methods to manage pediatric distress during tooth eruption, ranging from chilled pacifiers and clean finger gum massage to systemic analgesics and topical over-the-counter gels. Commercial teething formulations feature diverse active ingredients, including local anesthetics such as benzocaine and lidocaine hydrochloride, choline salicylate, hyaluronic acid, and botanical extracts such as chamomile or clove oil. However, clinical bodies highlight notable safety risks associated with certain active compounds. The American Academy of Pediatric Dentistry warns that benzocaine-containing products are contraindicated in children younger than two years due to the danger of methemoglobinemia, while lidocaine formulations carry risks of severe adverse reactions including paresthesia, hypotension, convulsions, bradycardia, and cardiac arrest. Given the historical scarcity of cellular data on how varied formulations affect oral mucosal barriers, this study established an empirical baseline to evaluate whether commercial teething gels alter cellular monolayer permeability and cellular survival in controlled cell cultures.
To investigate these cellular responses in vitro, researchers established two complementary cell culture systems utilizing human gingival mesenchymal stem cells and the HaCaT human keratinocyte cell line, both sourced from MARSTEM Cell Technologies in Istanbul, Turkey. The gingival mesenchymal stem cells were cultured in Dulbecco’s modified Eagle medium supplemented with ten percent fetal bovine serum, one hundred micrograms per milliliter of streptomycin, and one hundred units per milliliter of penicillin at thirty-seven degrees Celsius in five percent carbon dioxide until reaching confluency at the third passage. Third-passage HaCaT keratinocytes were seeded at one hundred thousand cells per well onto transwell inserts with zero-point-four micrometer pores in low-glucose medium containing ten percent fetal bovine serum and one percent penicillin-streptomycin, monitored daily for three days to verify monolayer confluence. Six commercial formulations were evaluated: Dentinox, Gengigel Teething, Osanit Gel, Jack N’ Jill Teething Gel, Buccotherm Teething Gel, and Aftamed Teething Gel.
The research team prepared experimental extracts by diluting each commercial teething gel in distilled water to achieve concentrations of zero-point-one percent, twenty percent, fifty percent, and eighty percent, followed by filtration through zero-point-twenty-two micrometer sterile filters. Epithelial barrier integrity was quantified using transepithelial electrical resistance, an established non-invasive biophysical method that measures electrical opposition across cell monolayers. Because intact epithelial layers form dense tight junctions that restrict ion movement between apical and basolateral chambers, higher electrical resistance corresponds to preserved barrier integrity. The authors recorded resistance readings with an EVOM-2 meter at twenty-four, forty-eight, and seventy-two hours. According to the manufacturer protocol, initial readings were multiplied by ten to obtain tissue resistance, corrected by subtracting ten times the basal background resistance to determine final resistance, and multiplied by the insert surface area to compute total resistance in ohms per square centimeter across each time point.
In parallel with electrical barrier measurements, investigators assessed cellular viability in human gingival mesenchymal stem cells using the colorimetric MTT assay following seventy-two hours of gel exposure. This assay relies on active mitochondrial dehydrogenase enzymes in viable cells converting yellow tetrazolium salt into insoluble purple formazan crystals. The stem cells were seeded into ninety-six-well plates at five thousand cells per well and treated with fifty microliters of gel extract across three independent biological replicates. Formazan crystals were dissolved in dimethyl sulfoxide, and absorbance was measured at five hundred and forty nanometers in triplicate spectrophotometric readings. Statistical analyses in IBM SPSS Statistics version twenty-seven applied three-way mixed-design analysis of variance for electrical resistance data, incorporating Mauchly’s sphericity test and Greenhouse-Geisser corrections alongside Bonferroni adjustments and Tukey’s honestly significant difference post hoc tests, with two-way analysis of variance evaluating viability data at a significance threshold of p less than zero-point-zero-five.
The resulting transepithelial electrical resistance data demonstrated significant variations influenced by gel formulation, concentration level, and exposure duration. At the lowest tested concentration of zero-point-one percent, epithelial electrical resistance remained generally elevated across all groups, indicating that basic barrier integrity was maintained, although significant intergroup differences emerged at twenty-four hours and seventy-two hours. At twenty-four hours, Dentinox produced significantly lower resistance values than Gengigel, Aftamed, Buccotherm, and Jack N’ Jill, while Osanit recorded lower values than Gengigel and Buccotherm. At twenty percent concentration, intergroup differences proved statistically significant across all measurement intervals. Gengigel demonstrated significantly higher resistance than Dentinox and Aftamed at twenty-four hours, whereas Buccotherm exhibited significantly higher resistance than all five other gel groups at forty-eight hours. By seventy-two hours of twenty percent exposure, Dentinox showed significantly lower resistance than Gengigel and Aftamed, while Aftamed demonstrated a significant temporal increase in resistance between twenty-four and seventy-two hours.
At elevated concentrations of fifty percent and eighty percent, the tested products caused more pronounced disruptions to epithelial electrical resistance across the keratinocyte monolayers. Under fifty percent exposure, Dentinox exhibited significantly lower resistance than Gengigel, Osanit, Aftamed, Buccotherm, and Jack N’ Jill at twenty-four hours, remaining significantly lower than all other formulations through seventy-two hours. At eighty percent concentration, significant differences were evident after twenty-four and forty-eight hours; Dentinox produced significantly lower resistance than Gengigel, Aftamed, and Jack N’ Jill at twenty-four hours, while Osanit was significantly lower than Gengigel and Aftamed. At forty-eight hours under eighty percent concentration, Dentinox again displayed significantly lower resistance than every other tested gel brand, while Aftamed and Buccotherm maintained significantly higher resistance than Dentinox, Osanit, and Jack N’ Jill. Within individual brand groups, zero-point-one percent dilutions consistently yielded significantly higher resistance than fifty percent or eighty percent dilutions, demonstrating that higher product concentrations progressively impaired epithelial barrier function.
Cellular viability measurements in human gingival mesenchymal stem cells via the MTT assay confirmed distinct formulation-dependent and concentration-dependent differences after seventy-two hours. At twenty percent concentration, Jack N’ Jill produced significantly higher cell viability than all other formulations and the untreated control group, while Buccotherm, Aftamed, and Osanit showed significantly higher viability than Gengigel and Dentinox. At fifty percent and eighty percent concentrations, the untreated control, Jack N’ Jill, and Buccotherm demonstrated significantly higher viability than Gengigel, Dentinox, Osanit, and Aftamed, with Osanit also exceeding Gengigel, Dentinox, and Aftamed. Concentration-dependent analyses within individual formulations revealed that Gengigel, Dentinox, and Aftamed experienced significant reductions in cell viability when concentrations increased above zero-point-one percent. Jack N’ Jill exhibited its highest viability at twenty percent before decreasing at higher doses, while Gengigel and Dentinox consistently exhibited lower cell viability across elevated concentrations, mirroring the diminished electrical barrier resistance observed in the keratinocyte monolayer experiments.
In their evaluation of these experimental outcomes, the authors explored potential mechanisms related to specific active and excipient ingredients present in the commercial formulations. Dentinox, which consistently yielded lower electrical resistance measurements, contains local anesthetic agents; prior studies have reported that compounds such as benzocaine and lidocaine can increase cell membrane lipid solubility, alter ionic equilibrium, and increase cellular permeability. Conversely, although hyaluronic acid is recognized for tissue hydration and barrier support, hyaluronic acid-based gels like Gengigel and Aftamed demonstrated reduced viability and lowered barrier resistance at higher concentrations, a phenomenon previously attributed to excipients like polyvinylpyrrolidone or high-molecular-weight hyaluronic acid toxicity in keratinocytes. Botanical components like chamomile extract also exhibited variable concentration-dependent effects; while bioactive flavonoids and terpenoids possess soothing and anti-inflammatory qualities at lower doses, the observed decrease in resistance at higher concentrations indicates that concentrated herbal extracts can alter epithelial permeability, underscoring that natural origin does not ensure barrier neutrality across all doses.
The investigators emphasized several crucial experimental limitations that caution against directly extrapolating these laboratory observations to clinical safety in pediatric populations. As an in vitro study, the experimental models could not replicate the dynamic oral environment, which features continuous salivary clearance, mechanical shear, enzymatic activity, and complex tissue interactions that dilute applied products in vivo. Furthermore, the protocol tested static concentrations over short durations without evaluating formulation viscosity, molecular tight junction protein expression, or mucosal permeability markers. While statistical correlations were observed between electrical resistance and metabolic viability, the authors noted that association does not establish direct causation. The researchers concluded that commercial teething gels produce formulation-, concentration-, and time-dependent effects on epithelial barrier integrity and stem cell viability in vitro, but emphasized that comprehensive animal models and clinical investigations are necessary before definitive conclusions regarding biological relevance and product safety for infants and young children can be established.
Subject of Research: In vitro effects of commercial teething gels on epithelial barrier integrity and cellular viability
Article Title: Transepithelial electrical resistance and cellular viability responses to teething gels: an in vitro study
Article References: İlisulu, S. C., Birant, S., Kılıç, S. S., Tunca, Z., Özcan, H., Akkoç, T., & Seymen, F. (2026). Transepithelial electrical resistance and cellular viability responses to teething gels: an in vitro study. Head & Face Medicine, 22(1), Article 71. https://doi.org/10.1186/s13005-026-00630-0
Image Credits: AI Generated
DOI: 10.1186/s13005-026-00630-0
Keywords: teething gels, transepithelial electrical resistance, cellular viability, MTT assay, HaCaT keratinocytes, human gingival mesenchymal stem cells, epithelial barrier integrity, benzocaine, hyaluronic acid, Dentinox, Gengigel, Osanit, Buccotherm, Jack N' Jill, Aftamed, tight junctions, pediatric oral health, tooth eruption
News Source: Ophelia Keating. (November 19, 2026). Teething Gels Alter Epithelial Barrier Integrity and Cell Viability in Laboratory Tests. Scienmag.



