A qualitative exploratory investigation conducted in an Australian hospital setting demonstrates that ward nurses actively employ critical thinking, clinical reasoning, and clinical judgement when identifying acute patient deterioration, yet frequently pause or adapt their communication rather than strictly following automated escalation pathways. When hospitalised patients exhibit physiological warning signs, rapid recognition and immediate intervention within early warning systems are critical to reducing adverse events and clinical complications. However, rather than functioning merely as passive collectors of vital signs within the afferent limb of rapid response systems, nurses continuously evaluate subtle contextual cues, pre-empt diagnostic requirements, and weigh relational dynamics with senior colleagues before initiating formal escalations.
Published in Nursing Open, the investigation explored the fundamental communication dynamics that underpin how ward nurses articulate their cognitive decision-making processes to medical receivers and senior nursing staff. The research team framed their analysis using communication accommodation theory informed by social identity theory, which explains how individuals adjust their communicative behaviours, speech patterns, and interpersonal demeanour to gain approval, reduce perceived social distance, or negotiate power differentials. Within hospital hierarchies, professional roles and power imbalances directly shape whether clinicians choose accommodative strategies such as convergence, where a speaker adapts their communicative style to match the expectations of their conversational partner, or nonaccommodative divergence, where distinct professional boundaries or assertive stances are intentionally highlighted.
The study was situated at a public-private partnership hospital operated between the Western Australian State Government and St John of God Healthcare in Perth, Western Australia. Data collection spanned three months between April and June 2024 across medical, surgical, stroke, and aged care ward environments, purposefully excluding specialised areas such as maternity, peri-operative, intensive care, and mental health units that operate under distinct escalation scopes. Researchers screened adult observation and response charts across these clinical units using a combination of convenience, purposive, and snowball sampling, identifying instances where patient vital signs crossed pre-defined thresholds requiring medical review or emergency response activation.
Semi-structured interviews lasting between 20 and 60 minutes were conducted with 27 nurse-speakers who initiated escalations and 10 clinical receivers, comprising five senior registered nurses and five medical doctors of varying designations. Thirteen of these interviews formed seven distinct conversational dyads between speakers and corresponding receivers. The data analysis integrated deductive content analysis, mapping transcripts against established cognitive constructs including analysis, interpretation, inference, self-regulation, and reasoning habits, alongside inductive thematic analysis following Braun and Clarke’s six-step framework to identify communicative themes aligned with communication accommodation theory.
Deductive content analysis of the interview transcripts established that 81 percent of nurse-speakers demonstrated explicit markers of clinical reasoning, while 74 percent formulated distinct clinical judgements. Across the cognitive constructs of critical thinking, habits such as confidence were articulated by all nurse-speakers, with reflection, intuition, integrity, perseverance, and context perspective reported by 85 percent of participants. Conversely, the critical thinking construct of explanation appeared in only 19 of the 27 nurse-speakers, and creative cognitive habits were described by only two-thirds of the cohort, illustrating that clinicians frequently perform intricate clinical evaluations without openly verbalising their cognitive rationale during bedside interactions.
A primary finding from the chart screening and nurse interviews was that escalation was documented inconsistently on adult observation and response charts for lower-level calling categories, such as requirements for increased surveillance or routine medical review. Out of 34 instances where escalation criteria were identified during screening, six cases represented afferent limb failure where the nurse was unaware that escalation was indicated, 15 involved nurses who escalated care but forgot to document their actions, and 13 involved nurses who made a deliberate clinical decision not to escalate immediately. In contrast, when patients met higher-level medical emergency response criteria, nurses almost universally activated emergency protocols without delay, confirming that deviations from protocol occur predominantly during lower-acuity, ambiguous physiological shifts.
The authors identified four overarching inductive themes: the influence of communication accommodation on escalation, the impact of relationships and intergroup dynamics, the influence of healthcare culture on protocol adherence, and bedside decision-making. Nurse-speakers reported that perceived nonaccommodative behaviour from receivers, including abrupt tones, dismissive demeanours, or unwelcoming body language, generated formidable barriers to communication. In multiple instances, negative past interactions led junior nurses to fear looking foolish or being reprimanded by physicians, occasionally prompting them to bypass formal reporting hierarchies or deliberately silence their concerns until a patient deteriorated further.
To navigate interprofessional hierarchies, nurses frequently engaged in deliberate communicative adjustments. While nurses generally initiated conversations using polite, overaccommodative approaches to preserve working relationships with higher-status medical teams, persistent barriers or severe patient deterioration led some nurses to deploy intentional divergence. Clinicians shifted to blunt, highly assertive vocal tones to seize the receiver’s attention and compel an in-person clinical review. Interestingly, medical receivers often interpreted this assertive, nonaccommodative communication favourably, viewing it as clear alignment with the urgent clinical needs of the patient rather than interpersonal conflict.
The findings also uncovered the common phenomenon of pausing to escalate, wherein nurses intentionally delayed formal notifications for a few minutes to gather collateral diagnostic data, perform electrocardiograms, review fluid balance charts, or observe baseline physiological trends. Rather than representing clinical negligence or failure to recognize deterioration, these pauses reflected active critical thinking and clinical judgement aimed at reducing administrative cognitive burdens on physicians. However, because nurses rarely documented these reasoning pauses or explicitly explained their rationale to receivers, the practice remained hidden and technically violated standard hospital compliance protocols.
The investigators concluded that clinical escalation guidelines should evolve beyond rigid track-and-trigger mechanisms by incorporating structured provisions for documenting critical thinking, clinical reasoning, and clinical judgement directly on bedside observation charts. Furthermore, the authors recommend that interprofessional hospital training incorporate communication accommodation principles, equipping both junior nurse-speakers and senior medical receivers with shared language to articulate and receive complex clinical assessments collaboratively. Such systemic adjustments would legitimate clinical intuition and analytical reasoning, bridging the gap between mandatory protocol compliance and realistic clinical decision-making.
To ensure qualitative rigour, the researchers established credibility, dependability, transferability, and confirmability using Lincoln and Guba’s evaluative framework. The primary interviewer maintained reflexivity regarding insider positionality as a registered nurse by wearing a university uniform to distinguish research activities from clinical hospital duties and recording observational field notes during ward visits. Ethical safeguards included a structured research distress protocol, which was initiated on four occasions; following clinical debriefing, all four participants elected to continue their interviews. Information redundancy was reached after 37 interviews, with only one nurse and four physician receivers lost to follow-up. Member checking conducted with four independent participants, including a senior nurse speaker, two junior nurse speakers, and a senior physician receiver, confirmed unanimous agreement with the resulting themes.
The study also captured the perspectives of clinical receivers in the efferent limb, who frequently experienced cognitive overload from high volumes of lower-level escalations. Senior nurses and doctors reported that rigid single-parameter early warning thresholds often interrupted ward rounds and outpatient clinics for clinically benign physiological variations, such as an asymptomatic young patient presenting with an isolated heart rate of 40 beats per minute. Physicians expressed frustration when calls resembled administrative box-checking exercises rather than substantive collaborative reviews. However, medical receivers simultaneously acknowledged an essential dependence on nursing assessments, emphasizing that attending physicians cannot remain at the bedside continuously and must rely on nurses’ clinical judgement to discern true deterioration from routine baseline fluctuations.
An important distinction emerged between formally recognized clinical concern and unexpressed clinical intuition. While nurse-speakers felt fully empowered to escalate care using the early warning system’s designated clinical concern parameter—even when vital signs fell within normal physiological boundaries—they consistently hesitated to invoke intuition alone. Experienced ward nurses frequently noted subjective hunches, gut feelings, or an internal radar signaling subtle patient instability, yet they avoided communicating these impressions to medical staff without accompanying objective measurements. Participants feared that citing intuition would elicit dismissive responses, expose them to criticism from senior colleagues, or diminish their professional credibility by framing their clinical rationale as overly subjective or unsubstantiated.
To bridge these interprofessional divides, the investigators formulated a conceptual framework mapping the rapid response system directly onto communication accommodation theory. The framework positions nurse-speakers within the afferent limb and receivers within the efferent limb, linked through shared healthcare cultural norms. Although physicians routinely verbalize their clinical reasoning aloud as part of medical culture, ward nurses rarely articulate their cognitive deductions during urgent escalations. The authors demonstrated that structuring conversations through explicit cognitive terminology allows nurses to state their critical thought, present their clinical reasoning, and offer their clinical judgement directly. This structured phrasing enables nurses to justify clinical pauses or request targeted interventions without expending excessive relational effort navigating hierarchy.
Building on these findings, the authors recommended reforming bedside documentation and interprofessional education. They proposed integrating dedicated sections for critical thinking, clinical reasoning, and clinical judgement into adult observation charts, providing clinicians with a legitimate mechanism to document rational clinical pauses alongside objective parameters and intuition. Furthermore, the researchers emphasized that communication training must expand beyond traditional assertiveness models for junior nurses. Grounding education in communication accommodation theory requires training medical receivers to exhibit receptive behaviours that foster psychological safety, including demonstrating approachability, acknowledging personal knowledge limits, inviting active participation, and maintaining direct, collaborative language when responding to bedside escalation calls.
Subject of Research: Qualitative exploration of nurses' communication of critical thinking, clinical reasoning, and clinical judgement during patient care escalation
Article Title: Nurses' Communication of Their Critical Thinking, Clinical Reasoning and Clinical Judgement When the Escalation of Care of the Acutely Deteriorating Patient Is Indicated: A Qualitative Exploratory Study
Article References: Jones, S., Brown, J., Barlow, M., & Gower, S. (2026). Nurses' Communication of Their Critical Thinking, Clinical Reasoning and Clinical Judgement When the Escalation of Care of the Acutely Deteriorating Patient Is Indicated: A Qualitative Exploratory Study. Nursing Open, 13(11), Article e71055. https://doi.org/10.1002/nop2.71055
Image Credits: AI Generated
DOI: 10.1002/nop2.71055
Keywords: clinical judgement, critical thinking, clinical reasoning, patient escalation, early warning systems, communication accommodation theory, deteriorating patients, nursing practice, rapid response systems, interprofessional communication, acute deterioration, qualitative exploratory study, hospital patient safety, vital sign tracking, clinical hierarchy, afferent limb failure, adult observation chart, health communication
News Source: Ophelia Keating. (November 21, 2026). Study Analyzes How Nurses Communicate Critical Judgement When Deteriorating Patients Need Escalation. Scienmag.



