A longitudinal investigation evaluating survey data from the Adolescent Brain Cognitive Development study has revealed that earlier pubertal progression is marginally associated with a wider gap in the dual systems imbalance among adolescent boys, while an autism spectrum disorder diagnosis is associated with a lower imbalance score. In contrast, researchers observed no statistically significant direct associations between pubertal development, autism diagnosis, and dual systems imbalance among female youth. Furthermore, statistical modeling demonstrated that autism spectrum disorder did not moderate the relationship between pubertal timing and dual systems imbalance for either sex, pointing to sex-specific patterns in how pubertal progression and neurodivergence relate to adolescent cognitive development.
The dual systems model serves as a prominent neurodevelopmental framework designed to explain elevated tendencies toward risky behavior during the transition through adolescence. Within this theoretical structure, risk-taking behaviors are understood as emerging from a temporal imbalance between two distinct, non-synchronous neurocognitive systems: the socioemotional network and the cognitive control network. Sensation-seeking represents the drive to pursue novel, exciting, and thrilling experiences and is governed in part by the dopaminergic system within the socioemotional network. During puberty, this dopaminergic system undergoes rapid maturation, establishing new neural pathways that release dopamine in response to novel stimulation, thereby reinforcing engagement in excitatory behaviors throughout early adolescence.
In contrast to the rapid acceleration of sensation-seeking drives, the capacity for impulse control develops on a far slower and more protracted developmental trajectory. Impulse control, defined as the ability to stop and consider the potential consequences of an action prior to acting, is governed by the brain’s cognitive control network, which is anchored in part by the prefrontal cortex. The prefrontal cortex facilitates critical communication across distributed neural regions to support deliberate decision-making, but it matures gradually across adolescence and typically does not achieve full biological maturity until an individual reaches their mid-twenties. This developmental mismatch produces a prolonged developmental interval during which adolescents experience heightened novelty-seeking impulses while possessing relatively immature neurobiological apparatus to regulate their behavior.
To investigate how biological timing interacts with neurodivergent conditions to alter this cognitive gap, the study analyzed survey responses drawn from the first three waves of the Adolescent Brain Cognitive Development study across the United States. The initial sample enrolled 11,880 children aged 8 to 10 years at baseline across 21 regional study sites using a probability cluster sampling design targeting catchment schools. The analytical cohort for this investigation evaluated multiple imputed samples consisting of 6,189 male participants and 5,667 female participants. Parents provided written informed consent alongside minor participant assent, and researchers conducted secondary analyses on deidentified survey data to map temporal sequencing across the multiple observational waves.
Researchers operationalized dual systems imbalance at Wave 3 as the primary dependent variable by standardizing and combining subscales from the UPPS Impulsive Behavior Scale. Sensation-seeking was measured using a four-item sensation-seeking subscale capturing enthusiasm for novel experiences, while impulse control was assessed using the four-item lack of premeditation subscale, which captures an individual’s inclination to deliberate before acting. The lack of premeditation subscale was reverse coded such that higher combined additive scores reflected a greater developmental imbalance characterized by elevated sensation-seeking and diminished impulse control. Conversely, negative composite scores indicated an inverse pattern defined by higher impulse control relative to sensation-seeking tendencies.
The primary independent variable was pubertal progression at Wave 2, evaluated using the self-reported Pubertal Developmental Scale converted into five categorical stages aligned with biological Tanner Stages. Because natural chronological aging correlates with pubertal maturation, researchers statistically residualized the pubertal stage score on chronological age separately for male and female participants, isolating the unique variance in pubertal timing independent of age. Autism spectrum disorder status was assessed at baseline via parent or guardian reports, categorized as a binary diagnostic indicator. The empirical models also controlled for Wave 1 baseline dual systems imbalance, baseline household annual income, race, Latinx ethnicity, Wave 2 exposure to violence via the Adverse Life Events Scale, community socioeconomic deprivation using the Area Deprivation Index, and participant age at Wave 3.
Using ordinary least squares regression with cluster-robust standard errors clustered at the study recruitment site level, the primary direct-effects model for male participants indicated that advanced pubertal progression exhibited a marginally significant positive association with dual systems imbalance, yielding an unstandardized regression coefficient of 0.045 with a p-value of 0.054. In this same model, an autism spectrum disorder diagnosis at baseline demonstrated a statistically significant negative association with dual systems imbalance, recording a coefficient of -0.267 with a p-value of 0.043. Across all estimated models for male youth, older age, documented history of violence exposure, and higher initial dual systems imbalance at Wave 1 consistently predicted higher dual systems imbalance scores at Wave 3.
When researchers introduced a multiplicative interaction term between pubertal status and autism spectrum disorder in the second regression model for male youth, the interactive effect failed to achieve statistical significance. However, inclusion of the interaction term altered the individual direct parameters: the positive direct effect of pubertal progression rose to statistical significance with a coefficient of 0.051 and a p-value of 0.029, whereas the negative association of autism diagnosis was slightly attenuated to marginal significance with a coefficient of -0.252 and a p-value of 0.059. Additional subgroup calculations indicated that male youth with autism reported an absolute negative average imbalance score of -0.121 at Wave 3, reflecting higher impulse control paired with dampened sensation-seeking relative to their neurotypical peers.
Parallel analytical models conducted among female participants produced distinctly different empirical patterns. Neither pubertal progression nor autism spectrum disorder diagnosis demonstrated statistically significant associations with dual systems imbalance at Wave 3 in either the baseline direct-effects specification or the interaction specification. Just as in the male sample, the interaction between autism diagnosis and pubertal progression was nonsignificant among female youth. Instead, higher dual systems imbalance in girls was significantly predicted solely by chronological age, prior exposure to violence, and earlier Wave 1 baseline imbalance levels, demonstrating that the observed influences of pubertal tempo and autism status on dual systems divergence were specific to male youth.
To evaluate the robustness of these findings, the author conducted multiple sensitivity checks examining sensation-seeking and impulse control as isolated dependent variables. These disaggregated models revealed that neither pubertal development nor autism diagnosis was significantly associated with sensation-seeking or impulse control when evaluated independently, and all interaction terms remained nonsignificant across both sexes. Additional sensitivity checks testing alternative missing-data treatments, including listwise deletion and varying the number of imputed datasets to 5, 10, and 30 imputations via chained equations, confirmed the overall consistency of the primary findings, preserving the positive trajectory of pubertal timing and negative trajectory of autism diagnosis in male youth.
The study highlights several methodological limitations that warrant cautious interpretation of the findings. Most notably, autism diagnosis was established using a parent-reported binary classification that precluded assessments of symptom severity across the broader autism spectrum. Furthermore, statistical power to detect effects among female participants was severely constrained by sample composition, as only 28 female participants possessed an autism diagnosis compared to 173 male participants, reflecting recognized diagnostic disparities. Additionally, the dual systems imbalance score utilized an additive subtraction metric that cannot distinguish between distinct underlying configurations of equivalent sums, impulse control excluded emotional urgency subscales, biological sex omitted gender identity nuances, and the analytical framework modeled associative between-person variance rather than verified within-person developmental trajectories over time.
Subject of Research: Association of pubertal timing and autism spectrum disorder with dual systems imbalance in adolescent youth
Article Title: Association of Pubertal Timing and Progression with Variation in the Dual Systems Imbalance Gap: The Moderating Role of Autism Spectrum Disorder
Article References: Wojciechowski, T. (2026). Association of Pubertal Timing and Progression with Variation in the Dual Systems Imbalance Gap: The Moderating Role of Autism Spectrum Disorder. Child Psychiatry & Human Development. https://doi.org/10.1007/s10578-026-02126-z
Image Credits: AI Generated
DOI: 10.1007/s10578-026-02126-z
Keywords: dual systems model, pubertal timing, autism spectrum disorder, adolescent development, impulse control, sensation-seeking, Adolescent Brain Cognitive Development study, ABCD study, cognitive control network, socioemotional network, neurodevelopmental differences, prefrontal cortex, dopaminergic system, ordinary least squares regression, sex differences, UPPS Impulsive Behavior Scale, Pubertal Developmental Scale
News Source: Cassandra Pierce. (November 19, 2026). Pubertal Timing and Autism Linked to Adolescent Dual Systems Brain Development. Scienmag.



