Standard population reference intervals fail to judge nutrient sufficiency, training readiness, and long-term health in athletic populations, according to a perspective article published in Frontiers in Nutrition under the section on Sport and Exercise Nutrition. In the perspective, author Masaki Kaneko from KYB Medical Service in Tokyo, Japan, examines how conventional reference intervals, which define the central 95 percent of an apparently healthy reference population, are designed to describe that population and support routine clinical interpretation rather than determine whether an athlete possesses sufficient nutrients to sustain rigorous athletic training and long-term physical wellbeing.
The analysis emphasizes that population reference intervals fail athletes across two opposing directions. On one hand, typical training physiology—including plasma-volume expansion, exercise-induced muscle damage, and hemolysis—pushes completely healthy, normal athletic values outside of the conventional population reference interval. On the other hand, true nutrient insufficiency regularly falls within the standard reference interval boundaries, preventing clinicians and athletic support staff from recognizing when an athlete is actually deficient or at risk.
Although purpose-defined decision thresholds exist to guide clinical and nutritional decisions, the author points out that these thresholds cannot be derived directly from standard population reference intervals. For iron evaluation, appropriate decision thresholds sit well inside the reference interval. For vitamin D, any statistically derived interval is fundamentally contaminated by prevalent insufficiency throughout the broader population. For zinc assessment, a single measured value provides little diagnostic insight without standardized sampling procedures. Furthermore, evaluation rules for hydration were never based on reference intervals, and the primary physiological indicators for energy availability either lie entirely within the reference interval or fall beyond its upper limit.
To illustrate this disconnect, the perspective cites the 2026 American Society of Hematology ferritin threshold, which clearly demonstrates that a statistical lower limit is not an accurate diagnostic threshold.
To overcome these limitations, Kaneko proposes a comprehensive three-layer interpretive framework for evaluating athletes’ laboratory results. The first layer consists of the traditional population reference interval, which serves solely to flag unusual or outlying values. The second layer introduces purpose-defined decision thresholds, which are specifically designed to identify nutrient insufficiency or clinical risk and differ from one another based on the quality and status of their supporting evidence.
The third layer of the proposed model introduces a personalized “nutritional passport,” explicitly modeled on the Athlete Biological Passport used in competitive sports. This individualized layer evaluates an athlete’s ongoing laboratory results directly against their own personal baseline by utilizing reference change values, thereby shifting clinical interpretation away from static general population distributions toward individualized longitudinal tracking.
A worked ferritin example presented in the article demonstrates that these three layers frequently disagree with one another in practice. Furthermore, the practical utility of the third layer depends heavily on reliable within-subject variation data; for ferritin, the only athlete cohort studied to date found within-subject variation to be far too heterogeneous to permit a single common estimate across individuals.
Consequently, the author establishes four critical guardrails for applying this multi-layered framework: implementing standardized sampling procedures, testing exclusively when there is a clear indication, exercising rigorous restraint regarding nutritional supplementation, and consistently keeping what is merely “usual for athletes” distinct from what is genuinely “sufficient.” Finally, the perspective defines the forward-looking research agenda, which requires systematically testing this three-layer framework against concrete athletic performance, illness, and injury outcomes.
Subject of Research: Clinical laboratory reference intervals and nutritional evaluation in athletes
Article Title: Normal is not sufficient: reading athletes’ laboratory results beyond population reference intervals
Article References: Kaneko, M. (2026). Normal is not sufficient: reading athletes’ laboratory results beyond population reference intervals. Frontiers in Nutrition, 13, Article 2030035. https://doi.org/10.3389/fnut.2026.2030035
Image Credits: AI Generated
DOI: 10.3389/fnut.2026.2030035
Keywords: athletes, population reference intervals, nutrient sufficiency, biological variation, reference change values, nutritional passport, ferritin, vitamin D, zinc, hydration assessment, energy availability, plasma volume expansion, hemolysis, muscle damage, standardized sampling, Athlete Biological Passport, sports nutrition
News Source: Daisy Hatcher. (November 18, 2026). Population Reference Intervals Fail to Evaluate Nutrient Sufficiency in Athletes. Scienmag.



