A brief, structured one-hour educational session significantly improves practicing surgeons’ accuracy in assigning American Society of Anesthesiologists Physical Status classifications, according to a prospective pre- and post-intervention pilot study conducted at Ankara Bilkent City Hospital. The findings demonstrate that a targeted lecture delivered by a senior anesthesiologist can rapidly resolve persistent documentation discrepancies, particularly in complex clinical presentations and urgent operative evaluations where baseline inaccuracies are most frequent.
The American Society of Anesthesiologists Physical Status Classification System serves as a foundational instrument in daily perioperative care and preoperative risk stratification across international healthcare settings. While originally established as a descriptive framework rather than a definitive predictive scoring model, advancing classification levels have consistently correlated with elevated rates of postoperative complications, prolonged inpatient stays, increased healthcare resource utilization, and surgical mortality across diverse patient cohorts.
The six-tier classification framework categorizes patients based on systemic disease severity, beginning with ASA I for healthy individuals without systemic pathology and ASA II for patients presenting with mild systemic conditions that lack substantial functional limitations. ASA III encompasses individuals with severe systemic illnesses that result in substantive functional impairment, while ASA IV designates severe disease that poses an ongoing threat to life. ASA V denotes moribund patients who are not expected to survive without surgical intervention, ASA VI is reserved for confirmed brain-dead organ donors, and an appended Emergency modifier denotes urgent procedures carrying heightened perioperative risk.
Despite widespread adoption, the classification framework relies heavily on subjective clinical judgment rather than rigid laboratory thresholds, leading to documented inter-rater disagreement among surgeons, anesthesiologists, and consulting physicians. In modern clinical workflows, the initial assessment is frequently recorded in surgical outpatient clinics before formal anesthesiology consultation occurs. Inaccurate baseline entries can initiate a clinical domino effect, misdirecting initial scheduling decisions, operating room planning, interdisciplinary communication, and institutional risk-adjusted quality reporting.
To assess whether targeted instruction could mitigate these discrepancies, researchers conducted a prospective pilot trial between August and November 2025 involving 50 actively practicing surgeons and senior residents from a major tertiary academic referral center in Türkiye. The participating cohort comprised specialists representing General Surgery, Urology, Orthopedic Surgery, and other subspecialties, spanning diverse institutional roles from senior surgical residents to full academic professors.
The assessment utilized ten standardized clinical case scenarios designed to simulate ambiguous, borderline clinical conditions frequently encountered in surgical practice, such as controlled and uncontrolled systemic disorders, morbid obesity, obstructive sleep apnea, and acute cardiovascular instability. Participants completed an initial baseline evaluation under supervised conditions, attended a one-hour interactive lecture covering updated definitions, diagnostic boundaries, and common pitfalls, and immediately completed a post-intervention assessment featuring randomized scenario sequencing to prevent recall bias.
Following the one-hour educational intervention, overall scoring accuracy exhibited substantial, statistically significant gains across all evaluated clinical scenarios. Correct classifications for ASA II cases rose significantly from 67.3 percent at baseline to 81.2 percent on the post-test. The most pronounced diagnostic improvement occurred in ASA III cases, where the initial baseline error rate dropped markedly from 24.5 percent down to 5.0 percent, yielding a final post-test accuracy of 95.0 percent.
Similar diagnostic improvements were observed in the identification of life-threatening illnesses categorized under ASA IV, where participant scoring accuracy increased from 61.2 percent at baseline to 88.3 percent after the lecture. Furthermore, the appropriate assignment of the Emergency modifier improved from 77.6 percent to 88.6 percent, correcting a critical documentation omission that directly impacts institutional risk benchmarking and perioperative triage.
Statistical evaluation using Fisher’s exact tests revealed that baseline classification accuracy did not differ significantly between junior surgical residents, junior specialists, and senior academic faculty. This parity indicated that cumulative clinical experience and advanced academic rank do not inherently ensure familiarity with standardized anesthetic classification criteria, but rather that baseline documentation gaps persist across all levels of professional experience.
The study authors contextualized these rapid improvements within cognitive learning principles, including the Law of Primacy and retrieval-based learning, which emphasize that structured instruction establishes durable clinical habits more reliably than unguided observational exposure. The rapid reduction in misclassification implies that preoperative documentation errors often stem from a lack of formal curricular instruction rather than deficiencies in underlying surgical judgment.
The investigators emphasized several methodological limitations, noting that the study evaluated a convenience sample of 50 clinicians at a single academic medical center, which may constrain direct generalizability to alternative institutional environments. Additionally, because the post-intervention test was administered immediately after the lecture to capture short-term knowledge acquisition, the trial could not assess the long-term retention or durability of the educational gains over extended clinical practice.
The authors concluded that brief, structured educational modules represent a low-cost, high-yield intervention that can be readily integrated into surgical residency curricula and continuing medical education. Establishing standardized risk terminology across multidisciplinary teams safeguards institutional data integrity, refines perioperative planning, and enhances surgical patient safety without requiring extensive or time-consuming instructional programs.
The investigation enrolled an institutional cross-section of 50 active surgical practitioners at Ankara Bilkent City Hospital, establishing strict enrollment parameters to evaluate the educational intervention. The participating cohort comprised specialists and senior trainees across multiple surgical fields, with General Surgery representing 40.0 percent of participants, Urology accounting for 12.0 percent, Orthopedics representing 10.0 percent, and other surgical specialties making up the remaining 38.0 percent. Stratification by academic seniority demonstrated a broad institutional hierarchy, consisting of 44.0 percent specialists, 24.0 percent associate professors, 18.0 percent full professors, and 14.0 percent senior surgical residents. Participation required voluntary agreement, active clinical practice or senior residency status, and full completion of both baseline and post-intervention evaluations. Individuals who declined, provided incomplete responses, or missed either testing stage were excluded from the final analysis. Ethical oversight was granted by the Institutional Review Board of Ankara Bilkent City Hospital under approval number TABED 1-25-1587, and the trial adhered strictly to the Declaration of Helsinki, with all fifty participants providing formal written informed consent prior to enrollment.
The experimental methodology followed a prospective pre- and post-intervention design structured around formal primary and secondary endpoints. The designated primary outcome was the change in overall scoring accuracy between the initial baseline assessment and the subsequent post-intervention evaluation. Secondary outcomes evaluated accuracy changes across specific classification categories, emergency modifier designation, variations across individual surgical specialties, and comparative accuracy tied to academic rank. Statistical testing was performed using IBM SPSS Statistics version 29. Continuous metrics were summarized as mean values with standard deviations or medians with interquartile ranges depending on underlying data distribution, whereas categorical variables were reported as absolute frequencies and percentages. To analyze paired categorical shifts occurring before and after the one-hour lecture, investigators applied McNemar’s test, while comparisons between independent surgeon subgroups were evaluated using Fisher’s exact test. All analytical tests were two-sided, with statistical significance established at a threshold p-value below 0.05.
Category-specific analyses demonstrated marked, statistically verifiable improvements across distinct clinical presentations following the educational session. For scenarios classified under ASA II, exemplified by patients with well-controlled hypertension, correct classification rose from 67.3 percent to 81.2 percent, achieving statistical significance with a p-value below 0.05. The most substantial diagnostic progress occurred within the ASA III category, which simulated severe systemic illness through cases of morbid obesity accompanied by severe obstructive sleep apnea. Baseline error rates in this cohort dropped markedly from 24.5 percent to 5.0 percent, yielding a final accuracy rate of 95.0 percent with a p-value below 0.001. Similarly, identification of constant life-threatening pathologies under ASA IV, illustrated by advanced heart failure cases, rose from 61.2 percent to 88.3 percent, also reaching high statistical significance at p below 0.001. Appropriate utilization of the emergency modifier climbed from 77.6 percent to 88.6 percent with a p-value under 0.05. Furthermore, post-intervention testing confirmed that both junior and senior surgical cohorts experienced parallel, statistically significant improvements, demonstrating uniform benefit across all experience levels.
The researchers emphasized the critical clinical ramifications associated with baseline misclassification, particularly in high-acuity surgical scenarios. An individual designated as ASA III, such as a surgical candidate exhibiting morbid obesity and severe obstructive sleep apnea, necessitates specialized perioperative management involving distinct postoperative monitoring protocols, intensive care unit triage consideration, and tailored anesthetic strategies compared to an ASA II patient. When higher-risk patients are inadvertently assigned lower status classifications, hospital databases underestimate physiological vulnerability. If such patients subsequently experience severe postoperative complications, institutional quality metrics and risk-adjusted outcome models fail to accurately benchmark institutional performance. Likewise, omission of the emergency modifier severely undermines clinical risk stratification, as unscheduled urgent interventions carry heightened rates of morbidity and mortality. Omitting the modifier compromises surgical audits, distorts multidisciplinary communication, and reduces the reliability of institutional quality indicators.
These observations correspond directly with findings reported in wider international investigations evaluating perioperative risk classification. The authors highlighted data from the international MILESTONE-2 survey, which demonstrated persistent inter-rater variability between surgeons and anesthesiologists despite widespread familiarity with the scoring framework, particularly in borderline or clinically ambiguous cases. Similar discordance documented by Kwa and colleagues revealed that interdisciplinary discrepancies in routine clinical documentation routinely distort communication and compromise risk-adjusted outcome assessments. Rather than indicating fundamental deficiencies in surgical decision-making or diagnostic acumen, these persistent discrepancies reflect divergent interpretations of existing classification boundaries. By demonstrating that a single lecture reduces the ASA III error rate from nearly a quarter of assessments down to 5.0 percent, the study indicates that targeted educational interventions can rapidly harmonize clinical interpretation without altering overall surgical judgment.
Subject of Research: Educational intervention to improve surgical accuracy in preoperative ASA physical status classification
Article Title: Can one hour of education fix the surgeon’s ASA scoring errors: A proof-of-concept pilot study
Article References: Aydin, E. U., & Aydin, O. U. (2026). Can one hour of education fix the surgeon’s ASA scoring errors: A proof-of-concept pilot study. Patient Safety in Surgery, 20(1), Article 41. https://doi.org/10.1186/s13037-026-00502-1
Image Credits: AI Generated
DOI: 10.1186/s13037-026-00502-1
Keywords: ASA Physical Status Classification, Preoperative Risk Stratification, Surgical Education, Patient Safety in Surgery, Clinical Documentation Accuracy, Inter-rater Variability, Emergency Modifier, Ankara Bilkent City Hospital, Perioperative Planning, Pre-Post Interventional Study, McNemar Test, Fisher Exact Test, Systemic Disease Severity, Academic Seniority, Clinical Decision-Making, Medical Residency Curricula, Continuing Medical Education, Multidisciplinary Communication
News Source: Ophelia Keating. (November 17, 2026). One-Hour Training Sharpens Surgeons’ Preoperative ASA Physical Status Scoring Accuracy. Scienmag.



