Biologging data collected from adult oilbirds (Steatornis caripensis) in northern South America indicate that individuals undertaking non-seasonal intra-tropical migrations reduce their overall flight effort during the non-breeding season compared to conspecifics that commute regularly from a central cave roost. Tracking twenty-one adult frugivores captured at Cueva del Guácharo in Venezuela revealed three distinct behavioral strategies, defined by how frequently birds returned to their primary colony and how long they occupied alternative daytime roosts. Rather than incurring elevated movement costs from traversing substantial geographic distances, migrating oilbirds sustained significantly lower average nightly flight durations than both roost-faithful individuals and intermediate excursionists termed venturers. By establishing temporary day-roosts near remote fruiting patches for extended stretches lasting several weeks, the migratory birds bypassed the requirement for sustained, daily round-trip commuting flights. This empirical observation demonstrates that flexible spatial strategies within a single colonial population can fundamentally modify movement budgets, offering an alternative mechanism for managing the energetic trade-offs inherent to central-place foraging.
In colonial wildlife systems, hundreds or thousands of individuals frequently aggregate at shared nesting or resting sites, drawing sustenance from a common landscape. Classic optimal foraging theory and ideal free distribution frameworks predict that high consumer density near a central aggregation causes rapid local resource depletion, obliging animals to travel increasingly greater distances to reach productive foraging patches. For central-place foragers that must commute repeatedly between a communal roost and peripheral feeding grounds, transit flights typically dominate the total energetic expenditure of the foraging cycle. In species characterized by specialized or obligate frugivorous diets, where opportunities for dietary differentiation are constrained, individual animals must navigate the logistical friction between commuting costs and patch profitability. While field investigations in colonial seabirds, kestrels, and bats have documented individual variations in foraging ranges and site fidelity, the precise degree to which distinct movement strategies alter relative effort among free-ranging frugivores has historically remained difficult to record without continuous, high-resolution movement data.
To investigate how colonial obligate frugivores resolve these spatial challenges, researchers captured twenty-one adult oilbirds as they emerged after dark from the main chamber of Cueva del Guácharo on August 21st, 2008. The team used a twelve-meter-long by two-meter-high mist net positioned near the cave entrance, processing birds immediately upon capture. Selection criteria were strictly restricted to mature individuals exhibiting characteristic wing and tail feather wear, a minimum wing length of 308 millimeters, and a body mass exceeding 400 grams, with undersized birds released at once. Selected individuals were fitted with custom twenty-two-gram battery-powered loggers manufactured by e-obs GmbH of Munich, Germany, secured to their backs using Teflon ribbon crossover wing harnesses. These instrument packages represented a maximum of approximately five percent of total body weight, aligning with standard historical biologging thresholds. Every instrumented bird was released within ten to sixty minutes of capture, flying strongly into the surrounding forest or back into the cavern.
Tracking extended from August 22nd, 2008, through February 14th, 2009, encapsulating the non-breeding phase of the oilbird annual cycle. Given the practical impossibility of recapturing birds across rugged tropical rainforests, data were recovered using a handheld base station tuned to 868.3 megahertz during late-afternoon surveys inside the cave’s main chamber. To conserve limited battery capacity across the multi-month sampling campaign, Global Positioning System receivers collected coordinates during one night per week, recording hourly locations between 17:30 and 05:30 local time. Simultaneously, integrated single-axis accelerometers recorded vertical movement dynamics at 17.5 hertz in two-second bursts every two minutes each night. Because oilbirds rely entirely on flapping locomotion rather than soaring or walking, wingbeats generate a distinctive vertical acceleration waveform. Researchers categorized bursts into flapping flight when the difference between maximum and minimum raw values exceeded 600, whereas values below 599 signified stationary roosting, maintaining greater than ninety-five percent classification agreement across extensive sensitivity evaluations.
The combination of periodic geographic coordinates and continuous accelerometry permitted the classification of individual tracking nights into six discrete nocturnal movement patterns based on activity duration and temporal symmetry. Nights were partitioned into four equal quarters spanning an individual’s active window. Symmetrical nights—exhibiting a ratio between 0.66 and 1.5 when comparing flight time in the first half to the second half—reflected round-trip journeys returning to the origin roost. Within these round trips, researchers distinguished long commutes, where combined transit time in the first and fourth quarters exceeded the population mean minus 0.25 standard deviations (3,632 seconds), short commutes below that boundary, and exploratory nights characterized by prolonged mid-night flight indicative of visiting multiple patches. Conversely, asymmetric nights indicated one-way movements between distinct roosts, separated into outbound commutes, dawn return flights, and high-intensity excursions defined as nights exceeding an individual’s historical flight duration by more than two standard deviations.
Synthesizing these nightly patterns across the entire sampling duration revealed three overarching movement strategies among the tracked population. Two individuals were categorized as roost-faithful, as they never engaged in multi-day excursions and spent only five percent of their total days roosting away from the primary cave. Fourteen birds adopted a venturer strategy; these individuals undertook long-distance excursions but consistently returned to Cueva del Guácharo within three days, spending up to twenty-five percent of their days roosting near external foraging sites. The remaining five individuals functioned as intra-tropical migrants. These migratory oilbirds conducted long-distance excursions that transitioned directly into prolonged stays at alternative day-roosts located 66 to 324 kilometers from the tagging cave, remaining away for continuous blocks lasting between 17 and 73 days. Cumulatively, intra-tropical migrants passed up to forty-two percent of their monitored days stationed at alternative forest roosts, displaying behavioral dynamics aligned with nomadic resource tracking.
Across 2,178 accelerometer-monitored bird-nights and 296 GPS tracking nights, oilbirds exhibited marked individual variation in movement effort, using total nightly flight time as a standardized proxy. Linear mixed-effects models incorporating a continuous first-order autoregressive error structure revealed moderate consistency in individual flight activity, with a gross repeatability of R = 0.244 and a 95 percent bootstrap confidence interval spanning 0.115 to 0.362. A strong positive autoregressive coefficient of 0.473 documented that an individual’s flight volume was correlated between consecutive nights. Model comparisons identified significant divergence among behavioral strategies. Intra-tropical migrants averaged 2.26 ± 1.34 hours of total nightly flight across 599 bird-nights, which was significantly less than the 3.28 ± 1.12 hours recorded across 177 nights for roost-faithful birds (B = 0.80, SE = 0.37, t = 2.18, p = 0.04) and the 3.03 ± 1.24 hours recorded across 1,351 nights for venturers (B = 0.50, SE = 0.23, t = 2.17, p = 0.04). Post-hoc testing detected no significant difference between venturers and roost-faithful individuals.
Despite traversing extensive geographic areas, oilbirds demonstrated remarkable spatial partitioning and site fidelity across their nocturnal foraging grounds. Monitored birds engaged in an average of 10.07 ± 1.47 hours of nightly activity, including 54.9 ± 44.62 minutes of commute flight and an average of 4.6 ± 2.4 localized foraging bouts lasting 12.1 ± 8.5 minutes each. GPS fixes gathered between the completion of outbound transit and the start of return commuting revealed zero spatial overlap among tagged individuals across an area of approximately thirty square kilometers. The mean minimum distance separating any two individuals within foraging zones was 4,608.5 meters, with ninety-five percent of paired locations separated by more than one hundred meters. Birds repeatedly visited one to five discrete, localized feeding sites situated up to 297 kilometers away from Cueva del Guácharo, showing that individuals relied upon memorized patches rather than searching randomly near the cave.
The substantial reduction in flight effort documented among intra-tropical migrants directly resolves the mechanical tension between extensive travel distances and cumulative expenditure. While long commutes characterized 43.8 percent of all recorded nights across the entire study population, intra-tropical migrants significantly decreased their proportion of long-commute nights once they relocated their daytime base. By day-roosting in tree canopies or satellite caves adjacent to distant fruit resources, migratory individuals eliminated hundreds of kilometers of recurring transit that roost-faithful conspecifics had to perform night after night. Although embarking on multi-day transit excursions entails short-term spikes in locomotion, amortizing those travel costs over several weeks of localized foraging substantially lowers season-wide energetic expenditure. This spatial flexibility mirrors phenomena noted in other avian taxa, indicating that adopting nomadic habits can effectively alleviate the intense density-dependent costs typically imposed on animals tied permanently to a central breeding or roosting location.
The study authors emphasize several vital constraints regarding the biological interpretation of these movement patterns. Total nightly flight time functions as a standardized behavioral proxy for transit effort rather than an absolute measure of daily energy expenditure, as single-axis accelerometry cannot quantify fine-scale hovering, maneuvering, or metabolic variation. Furthermore, the dataset covers twenty-one adult birds sampled over a single non-breeding interval, leaving open whether observed strategies persist throughout multi-year lifespans or whether individual birds switch tactics as environmental conditions change. Prolonged day-roosting in exposed forest environments may also impose unmeasured costs, such as increased vulnerability to predators compared to the protected interior of deep caves. In addition, strategies requiring elevated flight effort near the main colony might confer seasonal fitness advantages during subsequent breeding phases when parent birds must regularly provision nestlings. Future technological advances will be necessary to examine how individual variations in movement effort shape long-term survival, reproductive output, and the crucial seed dispersal services oilbirds provide across tropical forest ecosystems.
Subject of Research: Individual movement strategies and nocturnal flight effort in oilbirds
Article Title: Oilbirds performing non-seasonal intra-tropical migrations reduce flight effort compared to individuals that frequently return to the colony roost
Article References: Alarcón-Nieto, G., Maldonado-Chaparro, A. A., Bosque, C., Kümmeth, F., Safi, K., & Wikelski, M. (2026). Oilbirds performing non-seasonal intra-tropical migrations reduce flight effort compared to individuals that frequently return to the colony roost. Movement Ecology, 14(1), Article 53. https://doi.org/10.1186/s40462-026-00686-2
Image Credits: AI Generated
DOI: 10.1186/s40462-026-00686-2
Keywords: Oilbirds, Steatornis caripensis, Movement ecology, Biologging, Accelerometry, Central-place foraging, Intra-tropical migration, Flight effort, Foraging strategies, Site fidelity, Spatial segregation, Cueva del Guácharo, Resource partitioning, Colonial birds, Frugivores, Nomadic movement
News Source: Drew Townsend. (November 20, 2026). Migrating Oilbirds Reduce Flight Effort by Roosting Close to Foraging Grounds. Scienmag.



