Paid medical malpractice reports involving surgical never events declined significantly across the United States between 2004 and 2025, according to a nationwide retrospective cohort study published in the journal Patient Safety in Surgery. Analyzing physician medical malpractice payment reports recorded in the National Practitioner Data Bank, researchers observed an average decrease in pooled annual report counts of 4.1 percent per year over the twenty-one-year evaluation window. The investigative team, led by Tucker Bettis alongside Quynh Tran, Logan Glosser, Felipe Maegawa, and Snehal Patel, evaluated nationwide trends across specific allegation categories and examined the broader suitability of the national repository for tracking surgical safety.
Surgical never events traditionally encompass serious medical errors such as retained surgical items, wrong-site surgery, wrong-patient procedures, and wrong-procedure occurrences. Within modern patient safety scholarship, many experts prefer more neutral and descriptive terminology, designating these occurrences as surgical largely preventable events. While individual allegation codes within the National Practitioner Data Bank approximate these specific surgical event categories, national trends in malpractice payments involving them have historically remained poorly characterized, and the structural suitability of the database for surgical safety surveillance had not been formally investigated prior to this assessment.
To evaluate these historical trends, the investigators conducted a retrospective analysis utilizing physician medical malpractice payment records extracted from the February 2026 National Practitioner Data Bank Public Use Data File. The team identified and analyzed reports containing allegation codes 322, 330, 333, or 334 in either the primary or secondary allegation position. The research team evaluated these qualifying records both individually by specific allegation category and collectively as a pooled cohort. All reported financial compensation figures were adjusted to 2025 dollars to account for inflation, and annual report counts alongside the proportion of eligible physician reports containing a qualifying code were statistically modeled from 2004 through 2025.
The total pooled study cohort comprised 15,196 malpractice payment reports spanning the analyzed period. Within this aggregated sample, the distribution across individual allegation codes included 7,646 reports associated with code 322, 3,499 reports filed under code 330, 93 reports designated under code 333, and 3,983 reports categorized under code 334. Statistical modeling of pooled annual counts from 2004 to 2025 demonstrated a steady downward trajectory with an annual count ratio of 0.959 and a 95 percent confidence interval ranging from 0.952 to 0.965. The investigators noted that report counts decreased across the three larger code categories, whereas trend estimates for the low-volume code 333 category remained imprecise.
Beyond absolute payment counts, the researchers observed a parallel reduction in the relative prevalence of these allegations among broader physician claims. Specifically, the proportion of eligible physician malpractice reports containing any qualifying surgical never event code decreased from 3.98 percent to 3.05 percent over the study period, reflecting an annual odds ratio of 0.984 with a 95 percent confidence interval between 0.980 and 0.988. This relative decline suggests that the observed decrease in never event payments was not merely an artifact of an overall contraction in general malpractice reporting volume across the medical profession.
Financial and clinical severity analyses revealed wide variations in settlement figures alongside notable clinical consequences. Across the pooled cohort, the median malpractice payment was $75,220, with an interquartile range spanning from $28,847 to $215,003. Among the individual allegation categories, code 334 was associated with the highest compensation levels, recording a median payment of $168,723. In addition to financial determinations, the authors assessed clinical outcomes among reports from 2004 onward, identifying 442 records where patient death was explicitly listed, accounting for 6.1 percent of that subset. The data also revealed that the median interval elapsed between the original surgical act or omission and the formal submission of the malpractice payment report was three years.
In their conclusions, the authors emphasized that these findings specifically reflect paid malpractice reports and must not be interpreted as direct estimates of true clinical never event incidence. The study also incorporated sensitivity analyses restricted strictly to the National Practitioner Data Bank Surgery Related allegation group to verify the robustness of the observed patterns. Furthermore, the analysis delineates key structural boundaries of the public database when utilized for surgical safety research, identifying specific, confidentiality-preserving enhancements that could substantially improve the research utility of future public use data releases.
Subject of Research: Trends in medical malpractice payment reports related to surgical never events from 2004 to 2025
Article Title: National Practitioner Data Bank malpractice payment reports related to surgical never events: 1991–2025 nationwide trends
Article References: Bettis, T., Tran, Q., Glosser, L., Maegawa, F., & Patel, S. (2026). National Practitioner Data Bank malpractice payment reports related to surgical never events: 1991–2025 nationwide trends. Patient Safety in Surgery. https://doi.org/10.1186/s13037-026-00508-9
Image Credits: AI Generated
DOI: 10.1186/s13037-026-00508-9
Keywords: surgical never events, National Practitioner Data Bank, malpractice payment reports, patient safety, surgical largely preventable events, retained surgical items, wrong site surgery, wrong procedure, wrong patient, physician malpractice, public use data file, surgical safety research, allegation codes, malpractice claims, health care quality, annual report trends, surgical adverse events
News Source: Ophelia Keating. (November 17, 2026). Malpractice Reports for Surgical Never Events Decreased Steadily Over Two Decades. Scienmag.



