Leather has long carried a reputation as one of the dirtier corners of global manufacturing, but a sweeping new review argues that the industry may be an overlooked candidate for circular economy leadership, provided its environmental claims are measured with far greater rigor. The analysis, published in the journal Collagen and Leather, compiles decades of life cycle assessment research to chart where leather production burdens the planet, where it actually prevents waste, and why the numbers reported so far often refuse to agree with one another.
Life cycle assessment, or LCA, is the accounting method behind most credible environmental claims about products. It traces a material from raw extraction through manufacturing, use, and disposal, tallying emissions, energy, water, and toxicity along the way. In leather’s case, the technique has evolved from a diagnostic curiosity into what the review describes as a decision-support system, underpinning green certifications such as the European Union’s Product Environmental Footprint Category Rules, carbon labeling schemes, and eco-design practices that matter in global trade.
The review traces the methodology’s own history, noting that LCA concepts date to the late 1960s as energy analyses of packaging, matured through the Society of Environmental Toxicology and Chemistry’s four-phase framework in the 1990s, and were later codified in the ISO 14040 and 14044 standards. Leather-specific application began in 1998 with a study of leather production in Spain. A search of the Web of Science Core Collection through September 2025 identified 82 peer-reviewed English studies pairing the terms life cycle assessment and leather, with publication activity clustering into three phases: a budding period before 2013, a slight upturn from 2014 to 2016 triggered by the EU’s Product Environmental Footprint policy pilot, and a hot spot stage from 2017 onward after the leather PEFCR became formal legislation in 2020, peaking at 11 papers in 2023.
The circular economy argument sits at the heart of the review. Hides are by-products of meat and milk production, and over 99 percent of global leather raw materials come from them. By converting hides that would otherwise be discarded, leather manufacturing prevents methane and other greenhouse gases from decomposition and cuts upstream disposal costs by roughly 20 percent, according to studies cited in the review. One estimate suggests unprocessed hides in major producing countries could release more than 40 million tons of carbon dioxide equivalent annually if simply thrown away. The review also contrasts leather with petrochemical textiles: polyester alone consumes around 350 million barrels of oil yearly and accounts for about 35 percent of primary oceanic microplastics, while finished bovine leather in the European Union carries an average carbon footprint of roughly 8 kilograms of carbon dioxide equivalent per square meter, well below the 15 to 20 kilograms typical of polyurethane or polyvinyl chloride-based synthetic alternatives.
Yet the same body of evidence shows how dramatically the picture shifts depending on where analysts draw the boundary. When the entire chain from cattle farming is counted, the carbon footprint of leather reaches approximately 110 kilograms of carbon dioxide equivalent per square meter of finished leather, according to United Nations Industrial Development Organization figures cited in the review. Starting the analysis at the slaughterhouse instead drops the figure to just 17 kilograms. That gulf reflects an unresolved methodological debate over whether emissions from animal husbandry, which exists primarily for meat and milk, should be charged to leather at all. A footwear supply chain study that treated hides as minimally allocated by-products found slaughterhouses and tanneries together contributed about 75 percent of climate change impacts, with proposed mitigation including transportation optimization for 15 percent emission reductions, cotton-based material substitution saving 71 percent of water, and green procurement delivering up to 30 percent combined reductions.
Within the tannery itself, the hotspots are more consistent. Cradle-to-gate studies repeatedly identify tanning, especially chrome tanning, as the dominant contributor to leather’s environmental footprint. Chrome tanning uses trivalent chromium salts, delivers superior efficiency, and accounts for 80 to 90 percent of global leather production, but it contributes substantially to global warming potential, human toxicity, and eutrophication. A Chilean tannery study found the tanning subsystem, spanning deliming, pickling, and chrome tanning, was the principal hotspot, with chromium discharges representing 69.4 percent of the total impact score. An Italian tannery reportedly emitted 75.8 kilograms of chromium annually in wastewater and sludge. A cradle-to-gate comparison of goat hide production found chrome tanning carried a markedly higher footprint than vegetable tanning, which relies on natural tannins and showed substantially lower impacts across all toxicity categories with negligible carcinogenic risk. A Bangladeshi study likewise flagged full-chrome tanning, along with trivalent chromium and ammonia from deliming and bating, as key pollutants affecting aquatic ecotoxicity, acidification, and ecosystem quality.
Regional context matters enormously. In Italy, where the electricity mix leans on fossil fuels, energy consumption for processes like drum rotation dominates climate change, acidification, and human toxicity impacts. In New Zealand, where 78 percent of electricity is renewable, the burden shifts to chemical production, with chromium oxide, aniline, and synthetic polymers driving toxicity, resource depletion, and climate impacts. Allocation methods add another layer of divergence: economic allocation based on market value increased climate change-related impacts by up to 80 percent in studies of Danish pork production, while mass allocation may underestimate leather’s share. Several studies recommend hybrid approaches combining economic and mass factors, with sensitivity analyses to reveal how allocation choices reshape results.
The review catalogs a wave of LCA-guided innovations that quantify real gains alongside stubborn trade-offs. Vegetable tanning achieved reductions of up to 50 percent in global warming potential and 82 percent in freshwater ecotoxicity relative to chrome tanning, though post-tanning steps like waterproofing with zirconium salts can raise global warming potential by 13 to 14 percent and eutrophication potential by 44 percent. A biomass-derived aldehyde acid added to a salt-free chrome tanning system cut global warming potential by 19.8 percent, primary energy demand by 14.7 percent, and abiotic depletion by 21.5 percent. Pine bark waste substituted for mimosa tannin reduced the carbon intensity of tanning agent production by 94 percent, though higher water and energy use during tanning offset part of the benefit. In waste management, solid-state fermentation of hair waste reduced impacts across 18 environmental categories compared with chemical depilatory products, enzymatic dehairing with Bacillus subtilis outperformed conventional methods across 16 impact categories with a 24 percent overall reduction, and an oxidative dehairing process using hydrogen peroxide eliminated sulfide emissions entirely while cutting water ecotoxicity by more than 99 percent. Chromium recycling via alkaline thermal hydrolysis reduced carbon emissions and metal consumption by over 93 percent, though caustic soda use drove 98 percent of fossil resource consumption in that process. Pyrolysis of chromium-tanned shavings cut waste disposal impacts by up to 60 percent versus incineration, and enzymatic hydrolysis of leather waste reduced carbon dioxide emissions by 57 percent, fossil energy use by 26 percent, and water use by 78 percent compared with chemical methods.
Energy findings are equally concrete. Although energy represents only about 3 percent of tannery operating expenses, it remains a significant emissions source. Solar energy scenarios in metal-free tanning reduced particulate matter impacts by 25 percent and human toxicity by up to 56 percent in one Italian study, while a Spanish tannery analysis proposed boiler replacement, pipe insulation, and solar thermal collectors that could cut natural gas consumption by more than 90 percent depending on system scale. Artificial intelligence has entered the field as well: machine learning models paired with a genetic algorithm optimized chrome tanning parameters, cutting tanning time from 5 to 3 hours, reducing energy consumption by 34.95 percent and carbon dioxide emissions by 33.87 percent, which scales to annual savings of 8353.33 kilograms of coal equivalent and 87295.6 kilograms of carbon dioxide for a tannery processing 300,000 cowhides. Microwave drying demonstrated an 89 percent reduction in carbon dioxide emissions, and tannery wastewater treatment was quantified at 3.9 kilowatt-hours per kilogram of chemical oxygen demand removed, versus 1.4 for municipal wastewater.
The review is candid about the obstacles ahead. Reported carbon footprints for leather span 0.75 to 202.29 kilograms of carbon dioxide equivalent across studies, driven by differing functional units, system boundaries, software tools, and impact assessment methods such as TRACI and ReCiPe that often yield significantly different outcomes. Data collection is hampered by complex value chains, trade-secret chemical formulations, and reliance on generic background databases like Ecoinvent that poorly represent leather-specific operations. Small and medium-sized enterprises face cost barriers to professional software and consultants, and the industry’s thin profit margin of 3.7 percent in 2023 constrains investment in greener technologies. The authors also invoke the term circular washing, coined by Marrucci and colleagues, to describe superficial invocations of circular economy principles without meaningful environmental gains, noting one recycling scenario that improved 14 environmental indicators yet deteriorated 15 others by an average of 4 percent due to higher energy demands. Their prescriptions are specific: a unified leather-specific life cycle inventory database with harmonized methods, multidimensional frameworks combining environmental, cost, and social assessment, and AI-assisted modeling to fill data gaps. Without those foundations, the review concludes, leather’s circular promise risks remaining more rhetorical than real.
Subject of Research: Life cycle assessment applications, environmental hotspots, and circular economy challenges in the leather industry
Article Title: A comprehensive review of life cycle assessment in the leather industry: progress toward circularity, key challenges, and future directions
Article References: Li, B., Wan, X., Wang, S., Chen, X., Lu, W., Cao, S., & Zhu, D. (2026). A comprehensive review of life cycle assessment in the leather industry: progress toward circularity, key challenges, and future directions. Collagen and Leather, 8(1), Article 19. https://doi.org/10.1186/s42825-026-00246-9
Image Credits: AI Generated
DOI: 10.1186/s42825-026-00246-9
Keywords: life cycle assessment, leather industry, circular economy, carbon footprint, chrome tanning, tannery waste, recycling, sustainability, environmental hotspots, ISO 14040, EU PEFCR, artificial intelligence
News Source: Sloane Callahan. (November 8, 2026). Leather’s Circular Makeover: Landmark Review Maps Life Cycle Assessment Progress and Pitfalls. Scienmag.



