“Imagine one of those spectacular opening ceremonies at the Olympics, where a huge crowd suddenly gathers as a unit and synchronizes its movements like a flock of starlings. In a few very special and strange cases, the same occurs in the world of atoms. In them, a million atoms that have all entered the same quantum state behave completely synchronously,” explains University of Copenhagen math professor Søren Fournais.
Credit: Jim Høyer/University of Copenhagen
“Imagine one of those spectacular opening ceremonies at the Olympics, where a huge crowd suddenly gathers as a unit and synchronizes its movements like a flock of starlings. In a few very special and strange cases, the same occurs in the world of atoms. In them, a million atoms that have all entered the same quantum state behave completely synchronously,” explains University of Copenhagen math professor Søren Fournais.
Fournais is referring to the mysterious quantum phenomenon known as Bose-Einstein condensates. These can occur if certain kinds of atoms are successfully cooled to temperatures near absolute zero. Here, anywhere from 100,000 to several million atoms entangle, with all of them transitioning into the same quantum state at the same moment – a point at which the substance is neither solid, liquid, gas nor plasma. It is often described as being in its own fifth state.
While Bose and Einstein predicted the existence of such a phenomenon in the 1920’s, it wasn’t until 1995 that a Bose-Einstein condensate was produced in the lab – a Nobel Prize winning achievement. And even though researchers worldwide are busy exploring the new quantum state, much remains a mystery.
“Our general understanding of these extreme physical systems is incomplete. We lack the mathematical tools to analyse and understand condensates and thereby the ability to possibly put them to good use. The mathematical challenge is that you have a tremendous number of particles interacting with each other, and that the correlations between these particles are crucial for their behavior. The equations were written down a long time ago, but one cannot just solve them. In the years ahead, we’ll focus on understanding these solutions,” says University of Copenhagen mathematics professor Søren Fournais.
Fournais is one of the world’s leading researchers in quantum mechanical equations and has already spent ten years of his career wrestling with the wondrous nature of Bose-Einstein condensates. He is now dedicating the next five years to getting closer to the phenomenon’s complex mathematical solutions. To do so, the European Research Council has awarded him DKK 15 million through one of its highly prestigious ERC Advanced Grants.
An atom visible to the naked eye
Quantum mechanics takes place in the micro-world of atoms, within which the quantum effects are so minuscule that we do not experience them in our daily lives. The truly fascinating aspect of a Bose-Einstein condensate is that because it is made up of huge masses of atoms, it is nearly large enough to be observed with the naked eye. This makes it ideal for teaching us about quantum mechanics and for conducting experiments on a scale large enough to actually see them.
Researchers around the world are working to exploit the quantum properties of Bose-Einstein condensates in various ways. In 2022, Dutch scientists built an atomic laser based on a Bose-Einstein condensate. Danish professor Lene Hau of Harvard University has demonstrated that she can stop the light using a Bose-Einstein condensate. Work is also underway around the world to base a quantum computer on these icy atoms. However, there are still plenty of bumps in the road and the condensates are still only used at the basic research level.
According to Søren Fournais, the missing answers are found in the equations – or at least the theoretical answers:
“The beautiful and fascinating thing about mathematical physics is that we can write down the laws of nature in relatively simple equations on a piece of paper. Those equations contain an incredible amount of information – in fact, all the answers. But how can we extract the information that tells us what we want to know about these wild physical systems? It’s a huge challenge, but it’s possible,” says Fournais.
The big dream
As with the phase transition that occurs when water freezes into ice, Bose-Einstein condensation, in which atoms transition to a quantum state, is a phase transition. It is this physical transformation that Søren Fournais dreams of finding the mathematical solution to.
“My big dream is to mathematically prove the phase transition that the Bose-Einstein condensation is. But demonstrating phase transition is notorious for being extremely difficult, because you go from particles moving randomly about to them sticking. A symmetry is broken. It is very difficult to see why the particles do so and exactly when it will happen. Consequently, up until now, there is only one physical system where we have succeeded in saying something mathematical about this phase transition,” says Fournais, who adds:
“I think that it’s unrealistic to solve this task in five years but hope that the project will get us closer than we are today. And then we have many intermediate objectives that we hope to achieve along the way.”
Over the past 5-10 years, Professor Fournais has been behind some of the most significant global breakthroughs having to do with the mathematical understanding of Bose-Einstein condensates. Among other things, he proved the formula for the ground-state energy of a Bose-Einstein condensate – a question that had remained unanswered since about 1960.
Blackboard, chalk and lots of coffee
So, how does one of Europe’s leading mathematicians approach such a task? According to Søren Fournais, it doesn’t happen in front of a computer:
“A computer can make a numerical calculation for 10 or 20 particles, but not a million. So, the computer is not a useful tool for us. Instead, it’s a matter of a lot of coffee, good ideas and hard work at the blackboard with chalk,” says the researcher, who concludes:
“A typical week begins with a few good new ideas from the previous weekend that you are eager to pursue. And then you work – Monday, Tuesday and Wednesday – until it seems to be progressing. Except that on Thursday, you realize that it isn’t. But you get wiser. And then, the next round of ideas for the following week is perhaps a bit more tested. And then at some point, everything falls into place.”
FACT BOX: SØREN FOURNAIS
- Søren Fournais was born in 1973 and is a professor at the University of Copenhagen’s Department of Mathematical Sciences and QMATH research centre. He has previously received an ERC Starting Grant (2008) and the prestigious EliteForsk Prize (Elite Research Prize) in 2018.
- Professor Fournais’ new research project will take place at QMATH (Centre for the Mathematics of Quantum Theory). The centre is a world leader in the mathematical understanding of quantum physics.
- The ERC Advanced grant is awarded by the European Research Council for world-class research. Grants are awarded to excellent researchers at the highest level and are to be used to build a team around an original and groundbreaking research idea.
FACT BOX: WITH A LITTLE HELP FROM EINSTEIN
- In the 1924, Indian physicist Satyendra Nath Bose predicted that, at temperatures around absolute zero, the elementary particle photons can be in a special state where they are unable to be separated and all behave quantum mechanically. Since no one wanted to print Bose’s theory, he enlisted the help of the more renowned Einstein to have it published in a journal. Einstein later developed the theory himself to include massive particles. The phenomenon was named Bose-Einstein condensates.
- In 1995, the physicists Wolfgang Ketterle, Eric A. Cornell and Carl E. Wieman were the first to produce a Bose-Einstein condensate in a laboratory. For this, they were awarded the 2001 Nobel Prize in Physics.
