A multidisciplinary panel of occupational health and construction safety experts in South Africa has established an interdisciplinary consensus framework to govern how worker fitness for work at heights is assessed across the building sector. Published in the Journal of Occupational Medicine and Toxicology, the investigation addresses a longstanding regulatory disconnect surrounding elevated construction tasks, which represent a leading cause of fatal and disabling occupational trauma internationally. Under South Africa’s Occupational Health and Safety Act of 1993 and the Construction Regulations of 2014, employers must guarantee that employees undertaking fall-risk duties possess a valid medical certificate of fitness issued by an occupational health practitioner on the statutory Annexure 3 template. However, existing statutes mandate certification without defining standardized evaluation procedures, technical criteria, or benchmarks determining fitness relative to site-specific hazards. Consequently, assessment practices have varied widely, often reducing complex risk appraisals to basic medical examinations.
The consensus initiative represents the second stage of a broader two-phase research endeavor conducted by Lyndsey Swart, Tania Buys, and Nicolaas Claassen. In Phase 1, the authors conducted a scoping review across domestic and international literature alongside semi-structured interviews with practicing specialists. That preliminary phase exposed an acute lack of standardized assessment tools, established protocols, and validated fitness thresholds throughout the industry. Existing workflows leaned heavily on baseline clinical check-ups prioritizing general physiological health while overlooking cognitive, functional, behavioural, and environmental dimensions essential for working safely at elevation. Informed by expert interview feedback advocating for an approach grounded in the biopsychosocial model and the World Health Organization’s International Classification of Functioning, Disability and Health, the researchers drafted an initial consensus statement. Because defining detailed instruments or pass-fail cut-offs was deemed premature without foundational consensus, the authors adopted a principles- and process-first orientation to establish shared procedural definitions across disciplines.
To rigorously refine the draft consensus statement, Phase 2 deployed a virtual Modified Nominal Group Technique situated within a pragmatic research paradigm. This structured consensus-building strategy was selected to synthesize practical expert judgment among geographically dispersed professionals facing an area where formal clinical trial data remain scarce. The protocol strictly followed the Accurate Consensus Reporting Documents guidelines to maintain scientific rigor and operational transparency. While preserving core mechanisms of standard nominal groups, including moderated discussion and immediate post-session voting, the method incorporated virtual delivery and advance document circulation. Participants received an advance pack seven days before the meeting containing the draft statement, an explanation of nominal procedures, and deliberation targets. To eliminate technical disruptions during the formal meeting, investigators ran a technical pilot session with a single participant prior to the main deliberation, validating Zoom connectivity, audio quality, document display, and web-based survey workflows without discussing study content.
The consensus panel was assembled via purposive sampling across key South African professional associations to ensure cross-disciplinary representation. Candidate recruitment engaged the South African Society of Occupational Medicine, the South African Society of Occupational Health Nursing, the South African Council for the Project and Construction Management Professions, and the Occupational Therapy Association of South Africa, supplemented by peer referrals. Eight qualified specialists were initially invited, but two declined due to time constraints, resulting in a six-member panel comprising two occupational medical practitioners, two occupational health nurses, one occupational therapist, and one construction health and safety practitioner. Four members had participated in Phase 1, while two were newly referred. All panelists practiced in the private sector across Gauteng, Western Cape, Eastern Cape, and KwaZulu-Natal; five were self-employed and one worked for a medium-sized firm. All possessed over ten years of professional experience, four exceeding twenty years. Educational backgrounds were extensive: all held bachelor’s degrees, four held master’s degrees—including one in law—and one held a doctoral degree.
Deliberations were conducted online via Zoom under predefined researcher roles designed to preserve structural neutrality. Swart managed organizational introductions and administered the consensus survey; Buys moderated discussions; and Claassen handled technical support and live documentation. The session was recorded and auto-transcribed, followed by manual transcript cleaning against audio recordings. Directly after discussions, participants independently completed an anonymous Qualtrics survey, rating draft sections without viewing peer responses. Ethical approval was granted by the University of Pretoria Faculty of Health Sciences Research Ethics Committee under reference 486/2021, and all participants provided written informed consent under anonymized codes P1 through P6. To safeguard analytical objectivity, Swart refrained from moderating the panel because she had developed the foundational framework. The investigative team practiced ongoing reflexivity and debriefing to challenge interpretative assumptions. Aside from one occupational therapist known to Swart and Buys in a non-hierarchical, collegial capacity, researchers had no prior professional or evaluative ties with participants.
Quantitative assessment utilized a structured survey consisting of twenty-seven items covering ten sections of the draft statement, evaluating clarity, relevance, practicality, framework robustness, and process credibility. Experts provided responses using a five-point Likert scale ranging from one for strong disagreement to five for strong agreement. Because single-item Likert scores represent ordinal data and the panel comprised six specialists, statistical analysis relied exclusively on descriptive measures. Median values measured central tendency, while interquartile ranges, computed via Tukey’s method in Stata version 18.0 BE, evaluated dispersion and agreement strength. A priori benchmarks defined consensus as a median of four or greater with an interquartile range of one or less. Items scoring a median of four or higher but with an interquartile range exceeding one were designated as having general support without consensus. Items with a median below four were categorized as lacking consensus. The study excluded inferential statistics, focusing entirely on expert convergence.
Quantitative results revealed that consensus was reached on twenty of twenty-seven ratings, representing an overall agreement rate of seventy-four percent across the draft statement. Complete consensus occurred across six sections: introduction, worker-job specification, evaluation approach, Annexure 3 certification, regulatory compliance, and conclusion. Conversely, seven ratings failed predefined consensus criteria across four areas: key definitions, the five-step procedure, the occupational risk exposure profile, and worker follow-up. Four of these seven ratings earned a median of four or higher but exceeded the interquartile threshold, demonstrating general support hampered by varying practical interpretations. These concerned the practicality of the five-step procedure, the clarity and practicality of risk exposure profiling, and the relevance of worker follow-up. Three ratings failed consensus completely with medians below four and wide dispersion, reflecting serious concerns regarding definitional clarity and the clarity and feasibility of follow-up. One panelist consistently rated items lower, urging strict legal precision and clearly demarcated professional duties.
Directed qualitative content analysis of session transcripts, researcher field notes, and participant screen annotations explored the reasoning behind divergent ratings and guided targeted statement revisions. A primary challenge involved ambiguities surrounding statutory designations under the Occupational Health and Safety Act and Construction Regulations, particularly regarding who qualifies as an authorized occupational health practitioner. To establish legally defensible wording without infringing upon professional scopes of practice, the research team obtained external legal counsel. This consultation prompted the adoption of the standardized phrase competent, registered, and authorised person throughout the framework. Qualitative deliberations also resolved key conceptual distinctions, separating fitness for job—the formal assessment documented on Annexure 3 certificates—from fitness for duty, defined as daily, site-based operational safety oversight. Furthermore, the expert panel expanded fitness classifications beyond binary outcomes to incorporate a fit with limitations category, offering practitioners a formal mechanism to document conditional clearances, workplace accommodations, or restricted duties.
The resulting consolidated framework structures fitness assessments into a sequential five-step pathway operating under comprehensive governance principles. In the initial step, an occupational risk exposure profile is established to map hazards, physical stressors, cognitive loads, and psychosocial pressures linked to elevated tasks. Second, these exposures are converted into a worker-job specification detailing functional performance requirements and physiological baselines. Third, clinicians conduct an integrated evaluation matching worker capabilities against job specifications. Fourth, authorized practitioners execute task-specific Annexure 3 certification reflecting determined capabilities and restrictions. Fifth, employers and occupational health personnel implement workplace follow-up and monitoring to support worker safety and reintegration over time. This procedural pathway is embedded within governance principles requiring statutory adherence, cross-disciplinary collaboration, and a biopsychosocial perspective. Implementation relies on fundamental organizational enablers: standardized clinical guidelines, professional training programs, administrative and electronic recording systems, and alignment between national regulatory policies and occupational health practices across diverse construction environments.
The persistence of non-consensus surrounding follow-up and surveillance highlighted operational barriers characteristic of the construction sector, such as short-term contracting, mobile worksites, and fragmented healthcare access. Because the study sampled six private-sector experts and deliberately excluded construction laborers and site contractors, findings reflect specialized clinical and managerial perspectives rather than full operational realities across informal or resource-limited settings. Furthermore, the authors noted that the framework provides procedural and conceptual principles rather than validated testing instruments or numerical fitness cut-offs, which have yet to undergo empirical field testing. Moving forward, the researchers emphasized translating these agreed principles into standardized operational tools, such as exposure profile templates and job specification matrices. Subsequent efforts will focus on piloting these tools across diverse construction environments, engaging industry stakeholders and regulatory authorities to refine professional scopes of practice, and establishing equitable surveillance systems to enhance worker protection during elevated construction activities throughout South Africa.
Subject of Research: Interdisciplinary consensus framework for evaluating construction worker fitness for work at heights in South Africa
Article Title: Development of an interdisciplinary consensus statement for assessing fitness for work at heights in the South African construction industry: a virtual Modified Nominal Group Technique study
Article References: Swart, L., Buys, T., & Claassen, N. (2026). Development of an interdisciplinary consensus statement for assessing fitness for work at heights in the South African construction industry: a virtual Modified Nominal Group Technique study. Journal of Occupational Medicine and Toxicology, 21(1), Article 7. https://doi.org/10.1186/s12995-026-00500-0
Image Credits: AI Generated
DOI: 10.1186/s12995-026-00500-0
Keywords: fitness for work at heights, occupational health and safety, construction industry, nominal group technique, interdisciplinary consensus, occupational risk exposure profile, worker-job specification, Annexure 3 certification, occupational medicine, occupational health nursing, occupational therapy, biopsychosocial model, fall risk management, South African construction, Occupational Health and Safety Act, qualitative content analysis, workplace medical surveillance, International Classification of Functioning
News Source: Ophelia Keating. (November 20, 2026). Interdisciplinary Experts Establish Consensus Framework for Assessing Construction Fitness at Heights. Scienmag.



