A modified Delphi study has established a consensus-based training syllabus that links 13 competencies to 18 educational topics for spiritual care providers, complete with suggested teaching and assessment methods. The framework was developed to address an existing gap in educational design, where training programs for spiritual care providers have lacked an agreed curriculum connecting defined competencies directly to teachable content and assessment strategies, particularly when programs must accommodate both clinical and non-clinical entrants.
To construct the curriculum, investigators adopted a modified Delphi methodology, in which the modification consisted solely of replacing the traditional exploratory open-ended round with comprehensive literature and institutional reviews. In 2024, the study team conducted systematic searches across PubMed, Scopus, PsycINFO, ScienceDirect, and Google Scholar without applying any publication time restrictions, while simultaneously reviewing educational materials from 13 international organizations.
From these literature and organizational reviews, the researchers generated an initial draft containing seven broad competencies and 21 subtopics. This preliminary draft was submitted to an expert panel of 18 participants for evaluation during a first structured rating round. Following synthesis of the panel’s initial feedback, the curriculum was refined into 13 distinct competencies and 18 specific educational topics organized across five broad domains.
The refined framework was subsequently submitted to a confirmatory second round of evaluation conducted between 21 and 27 October 2026, during which panel members re-rated each item word-by-word. Seventeen of the original 18 experts completed this second stage, representing a 94.4 percent retention rate. Panelists evaluated items using a five-point scale, where ratings of 4 or 5 were classified as agreement, and consensus was formally operationalized as at least 80 percent agreement among valid responses.
Across the 31 revised curricular items evaluated in the confirmatory stage, 29 achieved full consensus and two achieved near-consensus, with researchers documenting full counts, percentage agreement, medians, and interquartile ranges. Eleven of the 13 competencies achieved full consensus with agreement levels between 82.4 percent and 100 percent. The remaining two competencies, team dynamics and digital literacy, reached near-consensus at 76.5 percent agreement and were retained exclusively as enabling components. Meanwhile, all 18 educational topics achieved full consensus, with panel agreement ranging from 88.2 percent to 100 percent.
The authors emphasized that the consensus-derived syllabus represents a curricular starting point rather than empirical evidence of educational effectiveness. Future work will require direct piloting and implementation evaluation to determine how the framework functions in practice, and researchers noted that the transferability of the proposed training model beyond similar institutional contexts remains to be tested.
Subject of Research: Consensus-based training syllabus development for spiritual care providers
Article Title: A consensus-based syllabus for training spiritual care providers: a Delphi study
Article References: Memaryan, N., Mortazavi, F. S., Nouri, M., & Zaidi, S. N. (2026). A consensus-based syllabus for training spiritual care providers: a Delphi study. BMC Health Services Research. https://doi.org/10.1186/s12913-026-16184-5
Image Credits: AI Generated
DOI: 10.1186/s12913-026-16184-5
Keywords: spiritual care providers, training syllabus, modified Delphi design, competency framework, educational topics, team dynamics, digital literacy, consensus methodology, clinical entrants, non-clinical entrants, assessment methods, expert rating, health services research, curricular domains, program implementation, literature review
News Source: Ophelia Keating. (November 20, 2026). Delphi Study Establishes Consensus Training Syllabus for Spiritual Care Providers. Scienmag.



