A prospective observational study conducted at a tertiary public hospital in Turkey reveals that defensive medical practices and low paternal engagement significantly shape the landscape of prenatal combined screening. Researchers found that all 97 consultations used verbal counseling with a protocol note, and 95.9 percent included a false-negativity disclaimer given for explicitly medicolegal reasons. These findings suggest that the desire to mitigate perceived legal risk plays a pervasive role in obstetric communication and decision-making processes.
The study followed 97 pregnant women and their partners through their first-trimester screening journey, collecting data at both the initial test-ordering visit and a follow-up session 10 to 15 days later. Attending physicians completed parallel questionnaires to track their own clinical reasoning and perceptions of the patient-parent communication. The research team specifically defined defensive testing as the ordering of second-trimester sequential screening for patients identified as low-risk, where the primary stated motivation was concern over potential medicolegal consequences.
Among the 87 cases identified as low-risk pregnancies, 18 patients received sequential screening. In 16 of these instances, the attending physician cited medicolegal concerns as the driving factor for the additional testing. Statistical analysis confirmed a strong association between reported defensive intent and the clinical decision to perform sequential screening, characterized by a Firth-adjusted odds ratio of 96.1. This pattern highlights a clear disconnect between established clinical guidelines and actual practice when physicians perceive a threat of future litigation.
Communication dynamics within the study also highlighted significant disparities between parents. Physicians consistently rated maternal comprehension of the test significantly higher than paternal comprehension at both visit intervals. Furthermore, paternal involvement remained notably low, with over one-third of fathers reporting no prior knowledge of the screening process and only 15.5 percent characterized as active participants by the attending medical staff.
The research also found that physician discontinuity was associated with lower physician-rated maternal comprehension ratings. Physicians gave lower comprehension ratings to mothers seen by a different physician at the results visit compared to those seen by the same doctor (median 6 vs. 7; P = 0.005). This difference was not observed in paternal comprehension ratings.
The authors acknowledge that these findings are based on a single-center design and rely heavily on physician-reported metrics. While the study provides a valuable real-world perspective on defensive medicine, the researchers emphasize the need for further validation using standardized instruments and multi-observer designs to confirm these patterns across broader clinical settings. These results underscore the complex interplay between medicolegal pressure, provider continuity, and the quality of parent-physician communication in obstetric care.
Obstetric defensive medicine has historically been documented almost exclusively through physician attitude surveys rather than prospective bedside evaluations. In addressing this gap, investigators documented that false-negativity disclaimers were delivered for explicitly medicolegal reasons in 95.9 percent of consultations. To evaluate comparisons, the team employed Wilcoxon signed-rank, Mann–Whitney U, and Fisher exact tests, alongside Firth penalised logistic regression for sparse data.
Although defensive motivation strongly associated with sequential screening, the researchers noted that the estimated 95 percent confidence interval was wide, spanning from 25.4 to 829.3. Precise physician ratings placed maternal comprehension at a median score of 7 across both visits, whereas paternal comprehension yielded medians of 6 at test ordering and 5 at results delivery.
Subject of Research: Clinical practice and communication in prenatal combined screening
Article Title: Defensive medicine in prenatal combined screening: physician–parent communication discordance and paternal involvement in a prospective observational study
Article References: Erbakırcı, N. M., Dayan, Ş., Kılıçarslan, İ., Sari, H., Zambak, A. B., Soysal, C., & Taşcı, Y. (2026). Defensive medicine in prenatal combined screening: physician–parent communication discordance and paternal involvement in a prospective observational study. BMC Pregnancy and Childbirth. https://doi.org/10.1186/s12884-026-10240-y
Image Credits: AI Generated
DOI: 10.1186/s12884-026-10240-y
Keywords: Defensive medicine, Prenatal screening, Combined screening, Obstetric practice, Medicolegal concerns, Patient-physician communication, Paternal involvement, Guideline discordance, Prospective study, Turkish healthcare, Clinical decision-making, Sequential screening, Informed consent, First-trimester screening, Tertiary hospital, Physician-rated comprehension, Maternal healthcare, Clinical protocols
News Source: Ophelia Keating. (November 17, 2026). Defensive Intent Associated with Repeat Prenatal Screening in Turkish Study. Scienmag.



