A single-centre study conducted at West China Hospital in Chengdu, China, reports declines in expert-assessed hazard scores and operational error rates following Healthcare Failure Mode and Effect Analysis (HFMEA) implementation in cold-chain pharmaceutical delivery. The research, published in Frontiers in Medicine, focused on a specific workflow segment ranging from pharmacy dispensing to patient signature confirmation. By excluding upstream manufacturing logistics and post-receipt home storage, the authors aimed to isolate and address latent safety risks inherent in open-system third-party logistics. The study utilized a multidisciplinary expert panel to identify failure modes and implement targeted corrective interventions over a one-year period.
The research team followed the VA-NCPS HFMEA guidance, employing an eight-member multidisciplinary expert panel to assess potential failure points. Severity and occurrence were scored on a 1–4-point scale to calculate hazard scores, while detectability was evaluated qualitatively using a decision-tree model rather than being incorporated into quantitative scoring. This methodological approach allowed for a structured identification of risks across dispensing, packing, delivery, and signature stages. The panel identified a total of 27 distinct failure modes and 17 root causes within the defined workflow scope.
Following the implementation of corrective interventions, the aggregated hazard score decreased substantially from 243 to 73. Additionally, the number of high-priority failure modes dropped from 25 to 12.
Concurrently, the hospital experienced continuous expansion in operational throughput. Non-parametric Mann-Kendall trend analysis revealed statistically significant upward trends in both monthly pharmaceutical dispensing volume and cold-chain delivery order volume. The Z-scores for these increases were 3.771 and 3.634, respectively, with P-values less than 0.001. This growth in volume occurred during the same period that corrective interventions were being implemented and evaluated.
Despite the increase in operational volume, safety metrics improved markedly. Both absolute event counts and exposure-adjusted safety rates exhibited statistically significant downward trends. The monthly dispensing error count and dispensing error rate both showed a Z-score of −4.046, with P-values less than 0.001. Similarly, the monthly abnormal delivery order count decreased with a Z-score of −3.652, and the abnormal delivery rate declined with a Z-score of −3.771, both with P-values less than 0.001.
The study design was a before-after assessment at a single centre, which limits the generalizability of the findings to other institutions or regions. The authors note that the observed favourable temporal changes in operational safety metrics are associated with the HFMEA-guided quality improvement within this specific context.
The standardized risk-control strategies developed in this study provide practical references for pharmaceutical quality management in internet hospitals.
In conclusion, the VA-NCPS-aligned HFMEA approach identified multi-link risks in cold-chain pharmaceutical delivery, with declines in expert-assessed hazard scores and favourable temporal changes in operational safety metrics observed within this single-centre assessment.
Subject of Research: Application of HFMEA framework to reduce safety risks in cold-chain pharmaceutical delivery for internet hospitals
Article Title: Risk identification and intervention of cold-chain pharmaceutical delivery in internet hospitals based on the HFMEA framework
Article References: Zhang, L., Zhang, Y., He, L., Ruan, Z., Wang, S., & Hu, C. (2026). Risk identification and intervention of cold-chain pharmaceutical delivery in internet hospitals based on the HFMEA framework. Frontiers in Medicine, 13, Article 1999126. https://doi.org/10.3389/fmed.2026.1999126
Image Credits: AI Generated
DOI: 10.3389/fmed.2026.1999126
Keywords: HFMEA, cold-chain logistics, internet hospitals, pharmaceutical safety, risk management, quality improvement, West China Hospital, third-party logistics, failure mode analysis, patient safety, operational metrics, Mann-Kendall test, dispensing errors, delivery management, regulatory science, digital healthcare, supply chain risk, clinical logistics, safety interventions, healthcare quality
News Source: Ophelia Keating. (November 12, 2026). Cold-Chain Delivery Hazard Scores Fell Following HFMEA Implementation in Single-Centre Study. Scienmag.



