Researchers Pierre-Alain Jacqmin and Jean Liénardy have uncovered significant security weaknesses in four recently submitted arbitrated quantum signature protocols, demonstrating that each scheme fails against targeted attacks. Arbitrated quantum signature frameworks are designed to guarantee the authenticity of transmitted content using an arbitrator while securing communications across quantum channels. Crucially, these cryptographic protocols are intended to prevent repudiation, ensuring that a sender cannot falsely deny originating a message and that a receiver cannot disavow receiving it.
The researchers first examined an arbitrated quantum signature scheme proposed by Zhang, Sun, Zhang, and Jia, which was created to sign quantum messages using chained CNOT encryption. The investigation demonstrated that the protocol cannot uphold its core repudiation defenses, as the sender can repudiate transmitted messages and generate false allegations of reception against the receiver. In addition to sender-side vulnerabilities, the cryptanalysis revealed that a dishonest receiver can forge signatures within this chained CNOT encryption architecture.
In their second evaluation, Jacqmin and Liénardy analyzed an arbitrated quantum signature protocol published by Ding, Xin, Yang, and Sang, which utilizes GHZ states to sign classical messages. Despite relying on GHZ states to safeguard message exchanges through an arbitrator, the protocol exhibits critical security shortcomings. The cryptanalysis demonstrated that both the sender and the receiver can execute simple repudiation strategies, undermining the protocol’s fundamental objective of preventing the denial of sent or received classical messages.
The third assessment focused on an arbitrated quantum signature scheme developed by Lu, Li, Yu, and Han, which employs controlled teleportation to protect quantum messages. The researchers identified multiple critical vulnerabilities against this design, showing that it is susceptible to signature forgeries and false-allegation attacks. Furthermore, the analysis proved that both the sender and the receiver retain the capability to repudiate messages, demonstrating that controlled teleportation fails to preserve non-repudiation guarantees for either communicating party.
Finally, the authors evaluated an arbitrated quantum signature scheme formulated by Zhang, Xin, Sun, Li, and Li, which was designed to authenticate classical messages without using entangled states. The cryptanalysis established that a participant in this scheme can successfully disavow the reception of transmitted messages. Moreover, the findings revealed that the protocol fails to achieve information-theoretic security across its other security goals, demonstrating that all four analyzed quantum signature frameworks fall short of their claimed protections.
Subject of Research: Cryptanalysis and security vulnerabilities of four arbitrated quantum signature schemes
Article Title: Cryptanalysis of four arbitrated quantum signature schemes
Article References: Jacqmin, P.-A., & Liénardy, J. (2026). Cryptanalysis of four arbitrated quantum signature schemes. Quantum Information Processing, 25(12), Article 378. https://doi.org/10.1007/s11128-026-05351-6
Image Credits: AI Generated
DOI: 10.1007/s11128-026-05351-6
Keywords: arbitrated quantum signature, quantum signature schemes, cryptanalysis, message authenticity, repudiation prevention, quantum communication, quantum messages, chained CNOT encryption, false-allegation attacks, signature forgery, GHZ states, classical messages, controlled teleportation, disavowal of reception, information-theoretic security, entangled states, quantum information processing, security attacks
News Source: Katie Riggs. (November 19, 2026). Cryptanalysis Exposes Repudiation and Forgery Flaws in Four Quantum Signature Schemes. Scienmag.



