Traditional standard scores on two commonly used intelligence quotient tests exhibit problematic floor effects and yield differing intellectual disability classifications in individuals with Down syndrome. In an evaluation comparing the Kaufman Brief Intelligence Test, Second Edition, and the Stanford-Binet Intelligence Scales, Fifth Edition, researchers investigated how assessment selection alters standard scores, developmental age equivalents, and theoretical study eligibility cutoffs.
Levels of intellectual functioning are frequently applied as inclusion or exclusion criteria for clinical trials and research investigations, while also being used to control for variations in cognitive abilities among individuals with Down syndrome. Despite these critical methodological roles, comparative research examining estimated intelligence quotients and intellectual disability classifications across different assessment instruments has remained scarce.
The study evaluated a sample of 276 individuals with Down syndrome ranging in age from 6 to 61 years, with a mean age of 22.00 years and a standard deviation of 13.19 years. Participants were drawn from two large multisite studies, with each individual completing both the KBIT-2 and the SB-5 assessment batteries.
Floor effects were identified as problematic when using traditional standard scores on both the KBIT-2 and the SB-5. However, these measurement floor effects were notably reduced when researchers utilized developmental age equivalents or implemented the deviation scoring approach available for the SB-5.
Classifications of intellectual disability varied based on the administered test, with participants significantly more likely to be categorized as having moderate intellectual disability rather than severe or profound intellectual disability under the KBIT-2 compared to the SB-5. Although overall composite scores across the two instruments were broadly similar, scores diverged and failed to align in 33 individuals, representing 12 percent of the study cohort.
When assessing hypothetical study inclusion and exclusion thresholds, the KBIT-2 was consistently more inclusive than the SB-5 across standard scores, deviation scores, and age-equivalent cutoffs, with KBIT-2 Nonverbal standard scores and Verbal age equivalents serving as the least restrictive criteria. The authors concluded that these findings clarify instrument strengths and measurement limitations, providing guidance for selecting cognitive assessments tailored to future clinical trials.
Subject of Research: Comparison of intelligence quotient measures and intellectual disability classifications in Down syndrome
Article Title: Comparison of IQ measures among children and adults with down syndrome
Article References: Schworer, E. K., Esbensen, A. J., Handen, B. L., Fidler, D. J., Clare, I. C. H., Yoon, D. M., Fleming, V. L., Barry, A., Brothers, C., Hartley, S. L., & the Alzheimer Biomarker Consortium-Down Syndrome (2026). Comparison of IQ measures among children and adults with down syndrome. Journal of Neurodevelopmental Disorders. https://doi.org/10.1186/s11689-026-09732-x
Image Credits: AI Generated
DOI: 10.1186/s11689-026-09732-x
Keywords: Down syndrome, intelligence quotient, intellectual disability classification, Kaufman Brief Intelligence Test, KBIT-2, Stanford-Binet Intelligence Scales, SB-5, floor effects, deviation scoring, age equivalents, cognitive assessment, clinical trial eligibility, standard scores, composite IQ scores, verbal age equivalents, nonverbal standard scores
News Source: Ophelia Keating. (November 18, 2026). Floor Effects and Diagnostic Classifications Vary Across Down Syndrome Intelligence Tests. Scienmag.



