A new brief report published in Patient Safety in Surgery proposes a revised taxonomy for surgical risk management, arguing that patient safety frameworks must account for how risk changes over time. Authored by Shabir Ahmed Dhar, Sumit Kumar, Abdul Maajid, Mohammed Muntasib, Khalid Yousuf, and Sabqat Farooq, the paper re-evaluates existing classifications of clinical risk by introducing a dynamic developmental model. Rather than viewing surgical safety through a static lens, the authors advocate for an approach centered on the progression of surgical proficiency.
The authors examine an existing taxonomy that divided surgical hazard into three distinct components: risky surgery, the risky surgeon, and the risk-taking surgeon. In that previous formulation, risk originating from the procedural demands of an operation was separated from risk arising from the specific individual carrying out the intervention. While this division recognized that both operative procedures and human operators contribute to clinical risk, the authors contend that it overlooks a crucial element necessary for understanding patient safety: the dimension of time.
According to the authors, surgical risk does not remain a permanent or fixed property of either a surgical procedure or an individual surgeon. Instead, risk continuously shifts as an operator accumulates clinical experience, refines operative judgment, and builds technical competence. Because capabilities develop over an entire career, the authors propose that the taxonomy is better understood as an evolving developmental trajectory rather than a static classification system.
To illustrate this temporal framework, the researchers distinguish between two types of clinicians who might appear identical when evaluated solely on short-term outcome data: the developmental risky surgeon and the problematic risky surgeon. The developmental risky surgeon represents a trainee progressing along a learning curve, characterized by an awareness of personal limitations, an active willingness to seek help, and measurable improvement following constructive feedback. In contrast, the problematic risky surgeon exhibits persistent patterns of preventable error and resists external feedback.
The brief report also reframes the conventional notion of the risk-taking surgeon, suggesting the term risk-calibrated surgeon is a more accurate descriptor of clinical expertise. The authors argue that what distinguishes an advanced surgical expert is not an inherently greater appetite for procedural hazards, but rather a superior capacity to evaluate which clinical risks are worth taking.
Connecting individual practice to institutional systems, the authors link this individual-level risk calibration to the organizational principles of high-reliability healthcare. They contextualize the proposed framework within recent evidence regarding surgical never-events, unnecessary surgery, and clinical decision support for difficult operations. Finally, the authors outline how this developmental perspective carries direct practical implications for surgical training programs, operative supervision, clinical assessment, and institutional credentialing.
Subject of Research: Developmental taxonomy for surgical risk management and patient safety
Article Title: From “risk-taking surgeon” to high reliability in patient safety: proposal of a new taxonomy for surgical risk management
Article References: Dhar, S. A., Kumar, S., Maajid, A., Muntasib, M., Yousuf, K., & Farooq, S. (2026). From “risk-taking surgeon” to high reliability in patient safety: proposal of a new taxonomy for surgical risk management. Patient Safety in Surgery. https://doi.org/10.1186/s13037-026-00513-y
Image Credits: AI Generated
DOI: 10.1186/s13037-026-00513-y
Keywords: surgical risk management, patient safety, high-reliability healthcare, surgical taxonomy, developmental trajectory, risk-calibrated surgeon, developmental risky surgeon, problematic risky surgeon, surgical never-events, unnecessary surgery, clinical decision support, surgical training, operative supervision, surgical credentialing, technical competence, surgical judgment, preventable errors
News Source: Ophelia Keating. (November 17, 2026). New Surgical Taxonomy Reframes Risk Management as an Evolving Developmental Trajectory. Scienmag.



