A rigorous three-round Delphi consensus study incorporating Fuzzy Delphi principles has established and expert-validated twenty-four core strategies for promoting information and communication technology-based agro-advisory services in India. Drawing upon a purposive panel of seventy-five specialists from agricultural universities, Indian Council of Agricultural Research institutes, Krishi Vigyan Kendras, and allied professional organizations, the investigation appraised twenty-eight candidate strategies across five literature-derived domains. Following iterative evaluations and controlled feedback, twenty-four candidate strategies, representing eighty-five point seven percent of all items, satisfied all pre-established statistical consensus criteria and were retained. The findings indicate that digital extension achieves the strongest endorsement when emphasizing localized linguistic accessibility, rapid problem resolution, and administrative facilitation. Delivering digital content in regional languages earned the highest consensus score, followed by ICT-enabled Quick Response Teams, frequently asked question repositories, digital claim-processing systems, and digital knowledge libraries. Four candidate strategies were rejected because an interquartile range of two indicated insufficient consensus despite moderate-to-high central ratings.
The research addresses the operational challenges confronting agricultural extension systems in developing contexts where smallholder farmers face severe environmental and economic vulnerabilities. Agriculture remains a foundational livelihood for a substantial proportion of the global population, directly underpinning rural poverty reduction and food security. Smallholder producers face compounding challenges, including climate variability, pest and disease outbreaks, degrading natural resources, and fluctuating market conditions. While conventional agricultural extension systems strive to address these challenges, they frequently encounter constraints related to limited manpower, inadequate outreach, delayed information delivery, and persistent information asymmetry. Digital agro-advisories complement conventional approaches by delivering timely, location-specific information covering weather, crop husbandry, pest control, irrigation, and markets. In India, public and private initiatives like m-Kisan, Kisan Call Centers, Kisan Suvidha, Digital Green, e-Choupal, and Agro-Meteorological Advisory Services have demonstrated digital outreach potential. However, technological expansion alone cannot ensure sustained utilization without addressing farmers’ literacy, landholding size, language constraints, and perceived credibility.
To construct a validated strategic framework grounded in practical institutional experience, the researchers purposively recruited a cross-institutional panel of seventy-five qualified experts across India. Panel selection prioritized professional experience and subject-matter relevance over statistical representativeness, capturing multidisciplinary perspectives across research, policy implementation, and grassroots field delivery. Participating specialists represented state agricultural universities, Indian Council of Agricultural Research institutes, Krishi Vigyan Kendras, and allied professional institutions. The panel embodied expertise spanning agricultural extension, ICT-enabled advisory services, digital agriculture, e-governance, plant protection, agronomy, rural communication, and field-level delivery. Panelists participated through iterative, structured online questionnaires, ensuring wide geographical representation while mitigating the conformity pressures of face-to-face meetings. Conducted under institutional research ethics approval from Banaras Hindu University in Varanasi, the study obtained written informed consent from all participating experts. Responses were handled in aggregate form across all survey rounds to preserve judgmental independence, protect participant confidentiality, and maintain strict methodological integrity throughout the multi-stage evaluation process.
The study employed an integrated three-round Delphi design incorporating Fuzzy Delphi principles to resolve ambiguity and uncertainty in subjective expert judgments. Conventional Delphi procedures use iterative questionnaires and controlled feedback to build consensus on unstructured problems, but standard numerical rating scales do not always adequately represent the cognitive vagueness of human opinions. The Fuzzy Delphi Method incorporates fuzzy set theory to address this uncertainty during the screening and validation of strategic indicators. The process began with a literature-informed seed framework derived from research on digital extension, knowledge management, decision support, and digital public infrastructure. This foundation established five domains: digital knowledge management, decision-support and advisory services, communication and farmer engagement, digital infrastructure and institutional collaboration, and governance and service facilitation. In Round I, experts reviewed the domain structure and proposed modifications, additions, and practical strategies. The research team removed duplicates, harmonized wording, and merged overlapping suggestions, synthesizing twenty-eight non-duplicate candidate strategies for quantitative evaluation.
In Round II, the twenty-eight candidate strategies were converted into a structured five-point rating instrument evaluating relevance, operational feasibility, and potential developmental contribution. To summarize panel ratings without prematurely eliminating candidate items, the authors calculated a normalized relevance weight for each strategy by dividing total expert ratings by the product of panel size and maximum scale value. Simultaneously, linguistic response categories were represented as triangular fuzzy numbers across a zero-to-one interval: strongly disagree mapped to zero point zero, zero point zero, zero point two; disagree to zero point zero, zero point two, zero point four; neutral to zero point two, zero point four, zero point six; agree to zero point four, zero point six, zero point eight; and strongly agree to zero point six, zero point eight, one point zero. Centroid defuzzification principles documented the aggregated judgments. Ratings were returned to experts as controlled feedback, with no strategies rejected during Round II.
Round III served as the final decision round, wherein seventy-five experts independently re-rated all twenty-eight candidate strategies. Panel responses were summarized using four statistical measures: arithmetic mean, median, mode, and interquartile range. The mean and median represented the direction and strength of support, while the absolute difference between median and mode assessed distributional stability. The interquartile range, calculated as the difference between the third and first quartiles, served as the primary measure of dispersion. To ensure that high average ratings did not mask polarized or dispersed opinions, four retention criteria were pre-specified before final analysis. A strategy was retained only when all four rules were met: mean and median at least three point five zero, absolute difference between median and mode at most one, and interquartile range at most one point five zero.
Following Round III evaluations, twenty-four of the twenty-eight strategies satisfied all consensus criteria and were formally retained. Delivering digital content in regional languages ranked highest overall, achieving a mean of four point eight nine, an interquartile range of one, and a Round II relevance weight of zero point nine seven. Establishing ICT-enabled Quick Response Teams placed second with a mean of four point eight two and an interquartile range of zero. ICT-based frequently asked question repositories and digital claim-processing systems for crop and livestock schemes tied for third with means of four point seven four and interquartile ranges of zero. Establishing digital knowledge libraries for farmers followed with a mean of four point seven zero. Other accepted strategies included agricultural social networking at four point six three, generic farmer experience sharing at four point six two, disaster early warning at four point six one, and Indigenous Technical Knowledge documentation at four point six zero.
Four candidate strategies were rejected after Round III because an interquartile range of two indicated insufficient consensus despite moderate-to-high central ratings. The rejected items comprised a digital farmer experience-sharing platform modeled specifically after e-Gyan Munch with a mean of four point twelve, Digital Farmers Schools with a mean of three point eight five, mobile-based veterinary advisory services with a mean of four point zero four, and ICT-industry collaboration for agricultural input home delivery with a mean of three point five zero. This divergence reveals a clear distinction between generic advisory functions and specific implementation formats. The expert panel endorsed a generic experience-sharing communication interface with a mean of four point six two and an interquartile range of one, but lacked consensus on specific branded platforms. Furthermore, veterinary advisories extended beyond conventional crop-oriented extension mandates, while input home delivery introduced complex logistical, quality control, and regulatory challenges that varied across local contexts.
The accepted strategies were distributed across all five operational domains, reflecting an integrated ecosystem approach to digital extension. Decision-support and advisory services attained the highest domain mean at four point five three across six accepted items, highlighting time-sensitive guidance via diagnostic tools, weather forecasts, and varietal selection systems. Digital knowledge management averaged four point five two across six accepted items, emphasizing localized, credible content via regional languages, knowledge libraries, and calendars. Governance and service facilitation averaged four point five zero across four accepted items, demonstrating support for integrating advisory services with digital claims, farm records, and value chains. Digital infrastructure and institutional collaboration averaged four point four five across four accepted measures, prioritizing interoperable farmer data systems and public-private partnerships. Communication and farmer engagement averaged four point three four across four items, favoring two-way dialogue through kiosks and chatbots. The authors proposed translating these domains into measurable service-level monitoring indicators, including language availability, response latency, and claim turnaround times.
The authors documented several methodological strengths alongside explicit limitations that govern how the validated framework should be interpreted. Strengths included a relatively large multidisciplinary panel of seventy-five experts, pre-specified consensus criteria that prevented high means from masking dispersed judgments, and transparent reporting of all accepted and rejected items. However, purposive expert selection supports informed consensus but precludes statistical generalization to all extension stakeholders across India. Additionally, archived datasets omitted detailed demographic distributions by institutional affiliation and round-specific response rates, highlighting the need for future studies to follow DELPHISTAR guidelines. The archived records retained summary statistics rather than the full item-by-expert fuzzy matrix, preventing independent reconstruction of fuzzy distance diagnostics. Furthermore, farmers, rural youth, women users, and frontline service providers were not directly included in the final consensus round. The authors emphasized that the framework was expert-validated rather than experimentally tested, requiring rigorous field validation with farmers before being utilized as a standardized evaluation instrument.
Subject of Research: Expert consensus on strategies for promoting ICT-based agro-advisory services
Article Title: Identifying and validating suitable strategies for promoting ICT-based agro-advisory services: an expert consensus study in Eastern Uttar Pradesh, India
Article References: Paliwal, H., Singh, A. K., Kumar, S., Shinde, M. S., A., D. T., Kumari, J., Singh, P., Lekha, U. S. S., Kumar, O., & Kumar, G. (2026). Identifying and validating suitable strategies for promoting ICT-based agro-advisory services: an expert consensus study in Eastern Uttar Pradesh, India. Frontiers in Sustainable Food Systems, 10, Article 1953396. https://doi.org/10.3389/fsufs.2026.1953396
Image Credits: AI Generated
DOI: 10.3389/fsufs.2026.1953396
Keywords: agricultural extension, ICT-based agro-advisory services, Fuzzy Delphi method, expert consensus, digital agriculture, digital knowledge management, decision-support systems, regional-language content, quick response teams, digital claim processing, Krishi Vigyan Kendras, Indian Council of Agricultural Research, interoperability, India Digital Ecosystem of Agriculture, two-way farmer communication, program evaluation indicators, agricultural innovation systems, public-private partnerships
News Source: Alan Morgan. (November 12, 2026). Delphi Expert Consensus Validates Twenty-Four Strategies for Promoting Digital Agricultural Extension. Scienmag.



