A prospective, single-blinded randomized controlled trial investigating primary total knee arthroplasty has demonstrated that incorporating a modified Enhanced Recovery After Surgery protocol significantly enhances early postoperative knee muscle performance and active joint mobility compared with conventional perioperative care, although these objective advantages diminish during mid-term follow-up. Conducted by an orthopedic research team at an academic university center specializing in high-volume joint replacement, the clinical trial revealed that patients managed under an accelerated multimodal care pathway achieved significantly superior isokinetic knee strength measures and active knee flexion within five days of surgery. Nevertheless, serial follow-up assessments conducted across twelve postoperative months demonstrated that these initial functional differences gradually decreased over time. By three, six, and twelve months postoperatively, objective biomechanical parameters and subjective patient-reported outcome measures between the treatment cohorts had largely converged, indicating that the primary clinical benefit of the modified recovery pathway lies in expediting immediate functional restitution and patient mobilization rather than establishing persistent, long-term superiority over traditional care pathways.
Persistent postoperative muscular weakness, particularly localized to the quadriceps and hamstring muscle groups, represents a widely acknowledged cause of functional limitation, prolonged rehabilitation, and patient dissatisfaction following total knee arthroplasty. Despite the overall clinical success of modern knee replacement procedures, approximately ten percent of surgical recipients report dissatisfaction with their ultimate surgical outcome, often driven by impaired mobility and delayed physical rehabilitation. While multimodal fast-track and enhanced recovery pathways have gained substantial traction across orthopedic surgery to shorten inpatient hospital stays, mitigate morbidity, and improve early functional recovery, their specific influence on objective, mid-term muscular capacity has remained insufficiently characterized in clinical literature. Prior research in total hip arthroplasty had indicated sustained improvements in objective work metrics up to one year following modified enhanced recovery pathways, but comparable longitudinal investigations combining serial dynamometric evaluations with standardized patient-reported outcomes for total knee arthroplasty were lacking. To resolve whether immediate functional gains translate into enduring biomechanical benefits, the researchers designed a randomized trial tracking knee performance over a full twelve-month recovery trajectory.
The study protocol, which received ethical approval from the Ethics Committee of the University of Regensburg prior to patient recruitment, was conducted in rigorous alignment with the principles of the Declaration of Helsinki and registered in the German Clinical Trials Register. Between May 2020 and March 2021, the investigators initially enrolled sixty-two adult candidates scheduled for primary cemented total knee arthroplasty due to primary or secondary knee osteoarthritis. Four participants withdrew prior to postoperative data collection, leaving a definitive analysis cohort of fifty-eight patients. An independent statistician randomized these participants using sealed envelopes into two parallel arms: thirty-one individuals were allocated to the modified enhanced recovery group, while twenty-seven individuals received standard conventional perioperative care. To preserve single blinding and prevent cross-contamination or treatment awareness among participants, patients remained completely uninformed of their specific pathway allocation and were housed on separate hospital wards located on distinct facility floors throughout their acute inpatient stay. Baseline clinical characteristics, including patient age and body mass index, were statistically comparable between groups, with both cohorts reporting substantial preoperative functional impairment.
All surgical procedures were executed at the academic center using a standard medial parapatellar surgical approach with identical cemented prosthesis components, avoiding patellar resurfacing across all participants. Every reconstruction was carried out according to a mechanical alignment philosophy supported by imageless computer-assisted surgical navigation, resulting in confirmed postoperative mechanical axes within three degrees of neutral alignment. In the modified enhanced recovery cohort, patients received extensive preoperative interdisciplinary education, targeted gait training, and preemptive analgesia utilizing ninety milligrams of oral etoricoxib. Intraoperatively, spinal anesthesia was administered using eighty milligrams of hyperbaric prilocaine combined with ten micrograms of sufentanil and eight milligrams of intravenous dexamethasone. The surgical team operated without employing a pneumatic tourniquet, applied local infiltration analgesia containing two hundred milligrams of ropivacaine with epinephrine, and administered tranexamic acid both intravenously and topically. The surgical incisions were closed without suction drains and dressed with transparent film coverings. Furthermore, recovery patients began assisted ambulation within one to two hours following surgery, targeting an initial walking distance of fifty meters alongside twice-daily physical therapy.
Conversely, patients assigned to the conventional perioperative care pathway were managed with regional nerve blocks comprising a psoas-compartment block and a proximal sciatic nerve block utilizing ropivacaine, prilocaine, and dexamethasone. Their surgical procedures were routinely performed with the application of an inflated pneumatic limb tourniquet, and wound closure incorporated intra-articular suction drains that remained in place until the second postoperative day. Postoperative ambulation in this conventional control group commenced on the first postoperative day rather than the day of surgery, supported by once-daily standardized physiotherapy sessions. In both study cohorts, post-discharge rehabilitation regimens were self-managed by the patients following hospital discharge. Standard systemic pain management followed the World Health Organization analgesic ladder, supplemented by scheduled oral oxycodone during the initial three postoperative days for enhanced recovery patients, while both arms had access to regular non-opioid medications and intravenous piritramide rescue analgesia. Notably, no surgical site infections, thromboembolic events, readmissions, or revision surgeries were documented across either study arm throughout the complete one-year trial monitoring timeframe.
Objective evaluation of muscular performance was conducted preoperatively and at five days, four weeks, three months, six months, and twelve months postoperatively using a calibrated Biodex System 3 isokinetic dynamometer. Considered a gold-standard instrument for functional knee assessment, the system measured reciprocal knee flexion and extension movements across standardized angular velocities of sixty degrees per second and one hundred eighty degrees per second. Following submaximal warm-up contractions, participants executed series of maximal repetitions on both the operated and non-operated limbs to determine peak torque, defined as the maximum rotational force output expressed in newton meters. Cumulative energy expenditure exerted throughout the joint range of motion was quantified as total work in joules, while power output in watts quantified the rate of mechanical work delivery. Additionally, active joint range of motion was recorded during flexion testing at high velocity to assess the operational angular capacity of the surgically treated limb, providing precise numerical benchmarks of dynamic musculoskeletal recovery.
Biomechanical testing at five days postoperatively revealed marked functional disparities favoring the modified enhanced recovery group across multiple objective indicators. Specifically, patients within the accelerated care pathway achieved significantly higher peak torque during knee flexion at sixty degrees per second compared to conventional care controls, demonstrating an immediate strength advantage. Total work output during knee flexion was likewise significantly elevated in the accelerated cohort at both sixty and one hundred eighty degrees per second. Dynamic power measurements exhibited corresponding early superiority, as recovery pathway patients registered significantly higher power output during flexion at both velocity settings, as well as significantly greater extension power at sixty degrees per second. Concurrently, active knee flexion range of motion on postoperative day five was significantly broader in the accelerated protocol group, reaching a median of sixty-seven point five-five degrees compared to forty-two point three degrees in the conventional care cohort. These immediate disparities indicated that the combined multimodal interventions successfully mitigated early post-surgical muscle inhibition.
However, longitudinal assessments demonstrated that these significant functional differences were strictly confined to the acute postoperative window. By four weeks following surgery, group disparities in peak torque, cumulative work, and dynamic power output had markedly diminished, with both groups demonstrating continuous, parallel strength gains. Throughout the three-month, six-month, and twelve-month testing intervals, statistical comparisons revealed no significant differences in isokinetic parameters between the two cohorts. Total work and power output steadily escalated toward near-complete physical recovery in both study arms, with conventional rehabilitation participants steadily narrowing the initial performance deficit. Active range of motion also progressed continuously, with both patient groups surpassing median flexion angles of one hundred ten degrees by six months postoperatively. While the modified protocol cohort displayed narrower interquartile ranges across multiple strength and mobility parameters—suggesting a comparatively more consistent individual recovery trajectory—long-term objective performance metrics demonstrated complete functional equivalence between the accelerated and conventional perioperative approaches.
Subjective recovery patterns evaluated through patient-reported instruments closely mirrored the objective isokinetic trajectory. Pain intensity, quantified via the eleven-point Numeric Rating Scale, declined sharply from a preoperative median score of six down to low levels across both treatment cohorts, with the enhanced recovery group displaying a non-significant trend toward more rapid early analgesia at four weeks. Health-related quality of life and functional capabilities measured by the Knee Injury and Osteoarthritis Outcome Score demonstrated substantial improvements across all five evaluated domains: symptoms, pain, daily living activities, sports and recreation, and joint-related quality of life. The accelerated pathway group exhibited more rapid early score improvements in symptoms and daily activity subscales, but mid-term and one-year scores reached comparable levels. Patient satisfaction ratings were exceptionally high, with over ninety percent of participants in both arms regarding their surgery as successful and expressing willingness to repeat the procedure at one year, although enhanced recovery patients demonstrated a statistically significant advantage in preoperative expectation fulfillment at three months postoperatively.
In evaluating these outcomes, the investigators highlighted several critical methodological strengths and clinical limitations that contextualize the overall findings. Strengths included the prospective randomized design, single blinding, standardized surgical techniques, and the integration of gold-standard objective dynamometry with validated patient-reported metrics over multiple longitudinal intervals. However, the trial was constrained by a modest sample size of fifty-eight patients and the absence of statistical corrections for multiple comparisons, meaning isolated significant values must be interpreted as exploratory. Furthermore, complete patient blinding remained vulnerable to perceptible postoperative pathway differences, such as the conspicuous presence of wound suction drains in conventional care subjects. The simultaneous variation of multiple perioperative factors—including drainage, regional nerve blocks, spinal anesthesia, and early mobilization schedules—also prevents isolating any individual component as the sole causal mechanism. Ultimately, the authors concluded that while modified enhanced recovery protocols do not alter mid-term clinical endpoints, their capacity to accelerate acute muscular recovery and early patient independence establishes them as safe, effective, and clinically valuable perioperative pathways.
Subject of Research: Early isokinetic muscle strength and mid-term functional recovery after total knee arthroplasty within a modified ERAS protocol
Article Title: Mid-term clinical outcomes and isokinetic performance after primary total knee arthroplasty within a modified ERAS protocol: a single-blinded randomized controlled trial
Article References: Schiegl, J., Greimel, F., Zeman, F., Grifka, J., Renkawitz, T., & Leiss, F. (2026). Mid-term clinical outcomes and isokinetic performance after primary total knee arthroplasty within a modified ERAS protocol: a single-blinded randomized controlled trial. BMC Musculoskeletal Disorders, 27(1), Article 912. https://doi.org/10.1186/s12891-026-10535-3
Image Credits: AI Generated
DOI: 10.1186/s12891-026-10535-3
Keywords: total knee arthroplasty, enhanced recovery after surgery, isokinetic dynamometry, muscle strength recovery, peak torque, total work, power output, range of motion, randomized controlled trial, orthopedic surgery, postoperative rehabilitation, knee injury and osteoarthritis outcome score, numeric rating scale, patient-reported outcome measures, multimodal analgesia, early mobilization, mechanical alignment
News Source: Ophelia Keating. (November 12, 2026). Modified ERAS Protocol Accelerates Early Knee Strength Recovery Following Arthroplasty. Scienmag.



