Researchers at Istanbul Technical University and Gebze Technical University have demonstrated that precise thermal treatment near the glass transition temperature can effectively double the carbon dioxide to methane selectivity in 6FDA-based polyimide membranes. Published in Frontiers in Membrane Science and Technology, this study combines experimental gas permeation tests with high-pressure molecular simulations to elucidate how residual solvents and thermal history dictate separation performance. The team found that while trapped solvents typically act as plasticizers that increase permeability at the expense of selectivity, a specific thermal protocol near the polymer’s glass transition temperature tightens chain packing and shifts the material into an anti-plasticization regime.
The study focused on dense 6FDA-DAM polyimide membranes, a material class known for its high thermal and chemical stability. The researchers cast these membranes using three different solvents with varying boiling points: N-methyl-2-pyrrolidone (NMP) at 204 degrees Celsius, N,N-dimethylformamide (DMF) at 153 degrees Celsius, and tetrahydrofuran (THF) at 67 degrees Celsius. Each solvent system was subjected to distinct annealing protocols, including treatments below the solvent’s boiling point, above the boiling point, and near the polymer’s glass transition temperature (Tg). This systematic approach allowed the team to isolate the effects of evaporation kinetics and thermal relaxation on the final membrane structure.
Experimental evaluations revealed that achieving a completely solvent-free matrix is practically unattainable. Solvent molecules become structurally locked within the polymer chains depending on the rate of evaporation, a phenomenon the authors describe as persistent solvent entrapment. Thermogravimetric analysis (TGA) confirmed that membranes annealed at lower temperatures, such as 80 degrees Celsius, retained significantly more solvent than those treated at higher temperatures. For instance, the NMP-cast membrane annealed at 80 degrees Celsius exhibited a cumulative mass loss of 10.40% at 300 degrees Celsius, whereas the same membrane annealed at 160 degrees Celsius showed a mass loss of only 0.868%.
Despite the low mass loss at 160 degrees Celsius, the NMP-cast membrane displayed an anomalously high d-spacing of 6.13 Angstroms, suggesting a temporary structural expansion. This expansion likely creates open diffusion pathways that facilitate solvent evacuation before the polymer chains can collapse. In contrast, annealing at temperatures near or above the solvent’s boiling point, such as 210 degrees Celsius or 385 degrees Celsius, triggers rapid flash evaporation. This rapid removal leads to premature structural compaction, reducing the d-spacing to 5.99 Angstroms and potentially trapping trace amounts of solvent in isolated voids.
Gas separation performance measurements conducted at 35 degrees Celsius and 4 bar upstream pressure highlighted the impact of these structural changes. The NMP and DMF series generally followed a trend of increasing selectivity and decreasing permeability as thermal annealing progressed. However, the THF series exhibited a deviation, with CO2/CH4 selectivity initially dropping from 28.3 to 21.9 when heated from 30 to 80 degrees Celsius. This initial drop was attributed to the rapid removal of the highly volatile THF, which favored chain relaxation and local densification over solvent-induced expansion.
At the final thermal stage of 385 degrees Celsius, the transport properties of all three solvent systems converged into a nearly identical regime. This convergence indicates that high-temperature annealing acts as a morphological reset, erasing the processing history induced by the different casting solvents. The CO2/CH4 selectivity underwent a dramatic surge, at least doubling compared to the initial low-temperature baselines. This enhancement is driven by the collapse of larger free volume paths, which obstructs the diffusion of bulkier methane molecules (kinetic diameter 3.80 Angstroms) while allowing smaller carbon dioxide (3.30 Angstroms) and nitrogen (3.64 Angstroms) molecules to pass through with less hindrance.
To understand the microscopic mechanisms behind these macroscopic changes, the researchers performed molecular simulations at an elevated pressure of 10 bar. These simulations focused on the coupled effects of residual solvent and CO2 on both rigid 6FDA-DAM and flexible 6FDA-ODA polyimide matrices. The computational models revealed that structural alterations are driven by the combined presence of both CO2 and the trapped solvent, rather than the isolated effect of the solvent alone. There is a direct competition between CO2 and the solvent for preferential sorption sites, primarily the nitrogen in the imide group and the ether linkages.
Fractional free volume (FFV) analyses identified a critical transition threshold between 1 and 2 weight percent solvent content. Below this threshold, the matrix behavior shifts from synergistic plasticization to anti-plasticization. At low solvent concentrations, the remaining solvent molecules act as anti-plasticizers, stiffening the local free volume paths and reducing the CO2-induced FFV increase. However, beyond this critical threshold, the combined plasticizing nature of the residual solvent and high-pressure CO2 cooperatively softens the matrix, leading to a sharp increase in free volume expansion.
The location of this anti-plasticization minimum is sensitive to the intrinsic flexibility of the polyimide backbone. For the highly flexible 6FDA-ODA/NMP system, the minimum FFV increase occurred at 1 weight percent solvent content, where swelling dropped to 6.73%. In contrast, the rigid 6FDA-DAM/NMP matrix required a higher threshold of 2 weight percent to reach its minimum swelling of 15.1%. This difference highlights how the rigid DAM backbone, with its bulky methyl side groups, resists structural distortion more effectively than the flexible ODA backbone, which preserves a thermodynamic imprint of the casting solvent.
Radial distribution function (RDF) analyses provided atomistic evidence of the competitive sorption mechanism. In the rigid 6FDA-DAM matrix, the intensity and spatial positioning of CO2 peaks remained steady across varying solvent concentrations, reflecting the structural rigidity of the chain architecture. Conversely, the flexible 6FDA-ODA matrix experienced pronounced structural transformations at the bridging oxygen sites. As residual solvent content increased, the intensity of the CO2 peak underwent a non-monotonic shift, initially decreasing at intermediate thresholds before rising again. This fluctuation provides direct evidence of the transition from solvent-induced anti-plasticization to penetrant-driven plasticization.
The study acknowledges several limitations in interpreting the computational results. The simulations were performed at 10 bar, whereas the experimental gas transport tests were conducted at 4 bar. Additionally, the exact mass fraction of residual solvent in the real membrane samples after distinct annealing protocols is difficult to isolate and report with standardized protocols. Therefore, the computational predictions are qualitatively, rather than quantitatively, comparable to the experimental results. The simulations serve as a mechanistic bridge to explain the thermodynamic interactions that govern the macroscopic permeation trends.
These findings establish a new fundamental perspective for optimizing the fabrication of high-performance polyimide membranes. By detailing the dependence of gas transport properties on specific solvent selection and thermal treatment, the study offers a predictive blueprint for tailoring next-generation polymeric membranes. The dual-methodological approach bridges the gap between processing history and transport performance, providing crucial guidelines for achieving optimized structural stability and high-pressure separation efficiency in industrial applications.
The synthesized 6FDA-DAM polyimide exhibited high thermal stability, with glass transition temperatures of 385 and 392 degrees Celsius for two distinct polymer batches. This rigidity is attributed to the bulky methyl substituents on the diamine moiety, which create severe steric hindrance that restricts segmental chain rotation. Consequently, the material resists solvent-induced relaxation; even when retaining over 10 weight percent residual solvent, the glass transition temperature shifted by only approximately one degree Celsius. This contrasts sharply with flexible perfluorinated membranes, where trace solvent amounts can reduce the glass transition temperature by 60 degrees Celsius. The aromatic backbone of the 6FDA-DAM network physically resists the molecular lubrication effects that typically accelerate structural collapse in less rigid polymers.
Thermogravimetric analysis indicated that the mass loss observed in the membranes cannot be exclusively assigned to the casting solvent, as absorbed moisture and other volatile species may also contribute to weight reduction. Therefore, the thermal data serves as an indirect assessment of residual solvent content rather than a direct quantitative measure. Similarly, X-ray diffraction and density measurements provide information on average chain packing and bulk free-volume characteristics but do not resolve the size or distribution of individual free-volume cavities. The researchers noted that while positron annihilation lifetime spectroscopy could offer more direct microstructural insights, the selected techniques were chosen for their reliability in capturing macroscopic bulk structural trends necessary for evaluating thermal history.
Gas permeability measurements were conducted using a pressure-rise apparatus, with samples sealed between aluminum tapes and epoxy resin to prevent edge leakage. The permeation experiments were performed at steady state, ensuring that the rate of pressure increase in the downstream volume remained linear. Permeability coefficients were calculated using the ideal gas constant, membrane thickness, and the leak-corrected pressure-rise rate. To ensure reproducibility and exclude macroscopic defects such as pinholes, measurements for each gas were repeated on replicate films until the slope of the pressure-versus-time plot remained constant. This rigorous validation allowed the researchers to attribute observed permeation anomalies to intrinsic matrix plasticization rather than film failure.
In the molecular simulations, the cohesive energy density served as an indicator of intermolecular force strengths pinning the polyimide chains within their nearest-neighbor coordination spheres. THF-containing polyimides consistently displayed higher cohesive energy density values than their NMP-containing counterparts, suggesting a more closely packed and structurally cohesive unrelaxed network. At a 4 weight percent solvent loading, the rigid 6FDA-DAM matrix with THF reached a cohesive energy density of 67 MCal per cubic meter, compared to 53 MCal per cubic meter for the NMP equivalent. This variation suggests that the rapid evaporation of THF locks the polymer chains into a highly unrelaxed, kinetically trapped state, preventing proper macromolecular relaxation during the casting stage.
The computational models revealed that the flexible 6FDA-ODA matrix experiences more massive structural compressions upon solvent incorporation compared to the rigid 6FDA-DAM network. Initial fractional free volume reductions reached 13.3 percent for NMP and 19.5 percent for THF in the flexible matrix, mirroring a corresponding densification where the density jumped from 1.316 to 1.361 grams per cubic centimeter. This behavior underscores how unconstrained polymer chains can easily rearrange to accommodate solvent molecules within their free volume voids. In contrast, the rigid 6FDA-DAM matrix showed smaller initial fractional free volume decreases, reflecting its limited capacity for structural rearrangement in the presence of trapped solvent molecules.
The study highlights that the overall separation capability of a membrane is a synergistic balance between sorption affinity and diffusion selectivity. At low solvent contents, the enhanced sorption affinity leads to the accumulation of carbon dioxide molecules at the upstream interface, creating a stronger driving force for these penetrants to diffuse through the matrix. This mechanism operates alongside the strict size-exclusion limits of the compacted network, where the diffusion paths for bulkier methane molecules are effectively blocked. The dual-methodological approach thus provides a predictive blueprint for tailoring polymeric membranes, demonstrating that processing history and thermal treatment are critical levers for optimizing high-pressure separation efficiency and structural stability in industrial applications.
Subject of Research: From plasticization to anti-plasticization: the critical role of residual solvent and thermal history on CO2 transport in 6FDA polyimide membranes
Article Title: From plasticization to anti-plasticization: the critical role of residual solvent and thermal history on CO2 transport in 6FDA polyimide membranes
Article References: Kahraman, D., VelioÄŸlu, S., Ahunbay, M. G., & Tantekin-Ersolmaz, Åž. B. (2026). From plasticization to anti-plasticization: the critical role of residual solvent and thermal history on CO2 transport in 6FDA polyimide membranes. Frontiers in Membrane Science and Technology, 5, Article 1950898. https://doi.org/10.3389/frmst.2026.1950898
Image Credits: AI Generated
DOI: 10.3389/frmst.2026.1950898
Keywords: plasticization, anti-plasticization, critical, role, residual, solvent, thermal, history, transport, polyimide, membranes, scientific research
News Source: Denise Maddox. (November 10, 2026). Thermal Annealing Doubles CO2 Selectivity in 6FDA Polyimide Membranes. Scienmag.



