In correspondence published in the medical journal Patient Safety in Surgery, researchers Tuhin Mistry and Abhijit Sukumaran Nair have raised significant methodological concerns regarding a systematic review and meta-analysis by Zegeye and colleagues that estimated the global incidence and predictors of failed spinal anesthesia. While acknowledging that investigating failed spinal blocks addresses an important and clinically relevant topic, Mistry and Nair argued that multiple methodological issues throughout the synthesis substantially limit both the interpretability and the generalizability of its reported conclusions.
A major concern identified in the critique centers on the lack of uniformity in how spinal anesthesia failure was defined across included studies. Reported clinical outcomes ranged from inadequate sensory block to requirements for secondary local supplementation or complete conversion to general anesthesia, yet these distinct clinical endpoints were pooled together as a single outcome. Contemporary neuraxial anesthesia literature stresses the importance of distinguishing partial, patchy, and complete failures, as these specific entities differ fundamentally both mechanistically and clinically. Without harmonized definitions, the reported pooled incidence of 8.36 percent becomes difficult to interpret and likely misrepresents true clinical failure rates.
Interpretation of several failure predictors reported in the meta-analysis also warrants caution. The review identified risk variables including elevated body mass index, emergency surgical procedures, limited provider experience, and multiple needle puncture attempts. Mistry and Nair emphasized that these clinical factors are inherently interrelated. Without multivariable statistical adjustment, reported observational associations risk reflecting confounding rather than independent predictor effects. Prospective clinical studies have repeatedly demonstrated that operator skill and anatomical difficulty serve as primary determinants of spinal anesthesia success, often mediating the apparent influence of factors such as patient obesity or surgical urgency.
The critique highlighted an additional contradiction regarding pharmacological findings, specifically an increased failure risk linked to the administration of isobaric bupivacaine. Mistry and Nair pointed out that this finding directly contradicts evidence from randomized controlled clinical trials and previous meta-analyses demonstrating comparable efficacy between hyperbaric and isobaric bupivacaine formulations when dosing, patient positioning, and procedural technique are standardized. Consequently, the authors noted that the reported difference likely reflects study-level procedural variability across individual investigations rather than intrinsic pharmacological differences between the formulations.
Methodological concerns were also raised regarding the statistical modeling used to estimate the overall pooled incidence. The systematic review utilized a traditional DerSimonian–Laird random-effects model, but made no mention of variance-stabilizing transformations such as the Freeman–Tukey double-arcsine method or generalized linear mixed-model approaches. Given the extreme statistical heterogeneity reported across included studies, with an I-squared value of approximately 98.6 percent, pooling raw proportions with traditional random-effects methods risks generating biased prevalence estimates and inaccurate confidence intervals, especially when true baseline proportions vary widely across different surgical settings.
Further concerns focused on how predictor effect sizes were mathematically synthesized. Although the review stated that adjusted odds ratios were log-transformed before pooling, Mistry and Nair noted that it remains unclear whether all included effect sizes were adjusted consistently or whether adjusted and unadjusted estimates were combined into the same analyses. Mixing effect sizes derived under differing confounding structures limits clinical interpretability and risks distorting causal inference. The authors stressed that transparent reporting of adjustment variables and separate pooling of adjusted versus unadjusted estimates are essential to ensure the validity of meta-analytic conclusions.
The correspondence added that extreme statistical heterogeneity exceeding 98 percent challenges the meaningfulness of calculating a single pooled incidence across mixed surgical cohorts. Obstetric, orthopedic, and mixed surgical cohorts differ substantially in their physiological profiles, block height requirements, and surgical duration. Prior multicenter investigations highlight that obstetric failures often relate to anatomical factors or inadequate block assessment, whereas orthopedic failures stem from insufficient spread for higher dermatomal levels. Because the review omitted surgery-specific pooled estimates, its clinical applicability is limited. Furthermore, reported associations with previous anesthesia or puncture at the L4–L5 level require careful contextualization, as neither represents an established independent predictor in contemporary practice unless confounded by prior spine surgery, difficult anatomy, or institutional preference.
Finally, the predominance of studies from resource-limited settings introduces additional considerations for global generalizability. Differences in equipment availability, provider training, case complexity, and clinical workload between resource-limited and high-resource environments may inflate observed failure rates. Mistry and Nair concluded that while the review drew attention to the multifactorial nature of failed spinal anesthesia, methodological heterogeneity, unstratified populations, and unadjusted analyses limit the strength of its conclusions. Future syntheses would benefit from standardized definitions of partial, patchy, and complete failure, stratified analyses by surgical population, and multivariable-adjusted effect estimates to provide more clinically meaningful guidance.
Subject of Research: Methodological limitations and predictors of failed spinal anesthesia in meta-analytic research
Article Title: Beyond incidence: clarifying the evidence-based predictors of failed spinal anesthesia
Article References: Mistry, T., & Nair, A. S. (2026). Beyond incidence: clarifying the evidence-based predictors of failed spinal anesthesia. Patient Safety in Surgery, 20(1), Article 4. https://doi.org/10.1186/s13037-025-00471-x
Image Credits: AI Generated
DOI: 10.1186/s13037-025-00471-x
Keywords: spinal anesthesia, anesthesia failure, failed spinal anesthesia, systematic review critique, meta-analysis methodology, DerSimonian-Laird model, statistical heterogeneity, isobaric bupivacaine, hyperbaric bupivacaine, multivariable adjustment, obstetric anesthesia, orthopedic surgery, puncture attempts, operator experience, sensory block, conversion to general anesthesia, resource-limited settings
News Source: Ophelia Keating. (November 20, 2026). Methodological Issues Weaken Evidence on Failed Spinal Anesthesia Predictors and Incidence. Scienmag.



