In a randomized controlled trial published in the Journal of Orthopaedics and Traumatology, orthopedic researchers evaluated whether three distinct surgical balancing techniques in primary mechanical alignment total knee arthroplasty produce meaningful differences in implant rotational alignment and five-year functional outcomes. The clinical investigation compared conventional measured resection against gap balancing guided by computer-assisted navigation and gap balancing utilizing an electronic force-sensor soft-tissue balancing device. While the three surgical strategies resulted in statistically significant differences in isolated femoral and tibial component rotations, the combined rotational relationship between the femur and tibia remained statistically indistinguishable across the treatment cohorts. Furthermore, five years following surgical intervention, all patient cohorts demonstrated substantial, comparable improvements in joint function and symptom relief. These findings indicate that technological modifications in soft-tissue balancing alter individual component positioning without disrupting overall knee alignment or compromising mid-term postoperative clinical success.
Achieving optimal rotational orientation remains a central technical challenge in total knee arthroplasty because substantial anatomical variation exists in native human knees. Distal femoral anatomy across surgical candidates exhibits a wide physiological range, spanning from 3.3 to 11 degrees relative to anatomical axes. When prosthetic components are placed in rotational malalignment, the resulting mismatch can generate excessive stress on bearing surfaces, increase strain on the periarticular soft-tissue envelope, and accelerate loosening at bone-implant interfaces. However, orthopedic specialists have debated whether surgeons should strictly replicate native femoral and tibial rotational anatomy or establish a modified orientation tailored to the specific alignment philosophy, bone cuts, and ligament releases performed during surgery.
To resolve these clinical uncertainties, investigators conducted a prospective, randomized study enrolling sixty consecutive patients diagnosed with severe primary osteoarthritis who were unresponsive to nonoperative treatments and scheduled for primary mechanical alignment total knee replacement. Candidates presenting with prior tibial or femoral fractures or osteotomies were excluded to prevent confounding rotational deformities. Between 2015 and 2017, participants were allocated in a one-to-one-to-one ratio into three parallel treatment arms using a computer-generated randomization sequence concealed within sequentially numbered, opaque sealed envelopes. An experienced senior surgeon performed or directly supervised every procedure using cemented posterior-stabilized Nex-Gen implants with symmetrical tibial baseplates and patellar resurfacing under tourniquet control. Following randomization, five participants were excluded from longitudinal evaluation due to progressive Parkinson’s disease, acute infections, foot ischemia, or stroke, leaving fifty-five patients who completed five-year follow-up under a modified intention-to-treat protocol without group crossovers.
In the measured resection group, surgical execution prioritized anatomical bone resections prior to performing soft-tissue balance in knee extension. The proximal tibial resection was executed perpendicular to the mechanical axis in both anteroposterior and sagittal planes using an extramedullary guide, while distal femoral cuts were completed perpendicular to the mechanical axis with an intramedullary rod. A standardized three degrees of external femoral component rotation was established using a posterior referencing cutting guide relative to the posterior condylar axis. Soft-tissue balancing was subsequently achieved through staged ligament releases, including deep medial collateral ligament release and medial osteophyte excision for varus deformities, or lateral osteophyte removal and posterolateral capsule release for valgus deformities. Rotational positioning of the tibial component was fixed by aligning the component with the medial third of the anterior tibial tuberosity, avoiding major collateral ligament detachments.
The computer-assisted gap-balancing technique employed an active wireless, image-free navigation platform combined with specialized knee software to guide implant orientation. Rigid tracking arrays mounted onto bone pins secured in the femur and tibia permitted real-time optical kinematic registration, while an optically tracked stylus palpated the femoral epicondyles to identify the surgical transepicondylar axis and digitally model distal articular surfaces. Distal femoral and proximal tibial bone resections were executed perpendicular to the mechanical axis. Extension gaps were balanced using manual tensioning devices and staged ligament releases until rectangular joint spaces and neutral coronal alignment were attained. The flexion gap was tensioned at ninety degrees of flexion using the tensor device, allowing computer simulations to determine femoral component sizing and rotational orientation to achieve flexion balance without ligament release. Unlike measured resection, tibial component rotation was determined dynamically via self-seeking alignment during passive flexion and extension.
For patients assigned to the force-sensor soft-tissue balancing cohort, femoral and tibial bone cuts and extension gap balancing followed the identical surgical approach applied in the measured resection arm. However, balancing across flexion and extension gaps was refined using an electronic dynamic knee balancing system. With the knee flexed at ninety degrees and the patella reduced, surgeons adjusted femoral component rotation until compartment loading was equilibrated, achieving an inter-compartmental pressure differential between zero and one unit without performing ligament releases. Similar to the computer-assisted navigation group, final rotational seating of the tibial tray was dictated by self-seeking alignment during dynamic knee movement.
Rotational alignment and limb geometry were evaluated through blinded imaging protocols conducted preoperatively and repeated postoperatively. Whole-leg weight-bearing radiographs captured coronal hip-knee-ankle angles, while non-contrast helical two-dimensional computed tomography scans performed one to two months before surgery and six months postoperatively provided definitive axial rotational metrics. Three blinded evaluators, including two orthopedic surgeons and a musculoskeletal radiologist, independently performed duplicate measurements across standardized anatomical levels. Femoral rotation was quantified via Berger’s femoral component angle, measuring the intersection between the surgical transepicondylar axis and the posterior condylar axis. Tibial rotation was assessed using the anatomic tibial angle, derived from perpendiculars to the anatomic tibial axis and posterior tibial boundaries. Furthermore, combined femorotibial orientation was documented through the transepicondylar posterior tibial component angle and the bicondylar posterior tibial component angle, the latter isolating true implant-on-implant rotational congruency independent of bony landmarks.
Preoperative radiographic assessments demonstrated that baseline coronal deformity and native rotational angles were evenly matched across all three cohorts without statistically significant intergroup variations. Postoperatively, all three surgical approaches successfully corrected varus deformities, restoring mechanical hip-knee-ankle angles to within three degrees of neutral alignment without significant differences between groups. In terms of femoral component rotation, measured resection and computer-assisted gap balancing maintained native femoral angles, whereas force-sensor guidance resulted in a slight, statistically significant one-degree reduction in external rotation compared to native values. This divergence produced a significant overall intergroup difference in postoperative femoral rotation, primarily reflecting the contrast between the computer-assisted group, which averaged 3.8 degrees of external rotation, and the force-sensor cohort, which averaged 2.0 degrees of external rotation. Researchers attributed this difference to compensatory external rotation applied during manual distraction in computer navigation to counterbalance natural lateral soft-tissue laxity during flexion.
In contrast to femoral findings, tibial component positioning exhibited pronounced divergence across the techniques. In the measured resection group, postoperative tibial rotation did not significantly differ from native anatomy, averaging minus 8.3 degrees. Conversely, both the computer-assisted navigation and force-sensor groups demonstrated significant shifts toward internal rotation relative to native baselines, averaging minus 18.1 degrees and minus 14.0 degrees, respectively. These differences between measured resection and the two gap-balancing methods were highly significant, demonstrating that self-seeking tibial alignment systematically promotes internal orientation. Despite these isolated component discrepancies, combined femorotibial rotational parameters showed remarkable consistency. Combined transepicondylar posterior tibial component angles decreased slightly across all cohorts relative to native values without intergroup differences. Similarly, while bicondylar device rotation increased significantly from baseline within the computer-assisted group, comparative analysis revealed no statistically significant differences in combined device rotation among the three surgical techniques.
Clinical outcome assessments conducted at the five-year postoperative milestone mirrored this mechanical convergence. Preoperatively, baseline scores for total Knee Society Scores, knee subscores, functional subscores, and Western Ontario and McMaster Universities Osteoarthritis Index scores were statistically equivalent across cohorts. At the five-year examination, every group exhibited marked, statistically significant clinical improvements compared to baseline evaluations. Between-group comparisons revealed no significant differences in total Knee Society Scores or objective knee subscores. Although subtle differences were observed in functional Knee Society Scores and overall osteoarthritis index scores favoring the force-sensor cohort over measured resection, these pairwise comparisons fell just short of formal statistical significance. These clinical results demonstrate that the heightened tibial internal rotation observed in the gap-balancing groups did not translate into inferior five-year functional performance, increased pain, or impaired patient mobility compared to anatomical measured resection.
Synthesizing their radiological and functional findings, the researchers concluded that measured resection most faithfully replicates native femoral, tibial, and combined knee rotational alignment in mechanical total knee arthroplasty, while gap-balancing techniques intrinsically encourage greater tibial internal rotation through self-seeking alignment. The authors hypothesized that the intrinsic geometry of fixed-bearing posterior-stabilized prostheses largely dictates postoperative joint kinematics, enabling periarticular soft-tissue structures to adapt viscoelasticity and absorb minor isolated component mismatches. However, the study authors highlighted important methodological boundaries, noting that their single-surgeon series was limited to fifty-five analyzed patients receiving symmetrical, fixed-bearing implants under a mechanical alignment philosophy. Consequently, these findings may not directly extrapolate to mobile-bearing designs, cruciate-retaining implants, or kinematic alignment strategies, nor do they rule out longer-term kinematic consequences beyond five years, underscoring the necessity of broader multicenter evaluations before establishing definitive rotational balancing standards.
Subject of Research: Rotational alignment and clinical outcomes of surgical balancing techniques in total knee arthroplasty
Article Title: Measured resection, gap balancing, and force-sensor-guided total knee arthroplasty result in different femoral and tibial rotational alignment but similar combined knee rotation and clinical outcomes: a randomized controlled trial
Article References: Hernández-Hermoso, J. A., Nescolarde, L., Yañez-Siller, F., Calle-GarcÃa, J., Pérez-Andrés, R., & GarcÃa-Perdomo, D. (2026). Measured resection, gap balancing, and force-sensor-guided total knee arthroplasty result in different femoral and tibial rotational alignment but similar combined knee rotation and clinical outcomes: a randomized controlled trial. Journal of Orthopaedics and Traumatology, 27(1), Article 41. https://doi.org/10.1186/s10195-026-00936-4
Image Credits: AI Generated
DOI: 10.1186/s10195-026-00936-4
Keywords: total knee arthroplasty, measured resection, gap balancing, force-sensor balancing, computer-assisted surgery, rotational alignment, tibial rotation, femoral component rotation, combined knee rotation, Knee Society Score, WOMAC index, computed tomography, mechanical alignment, randomized controlled trial, knee osteoarthritis, posterior stabilized prosthesis, Berger femoral angle, anatomic tibial angle
News Source: Ophelia Keating. (November 20, 2026). Knee Replacement Techniques Shift Component Rotation but Share Five-Year Clinical Outcomes. Scienmag.



