In a Matters Arising analysis published in the Journal of Cardiovascular Imaging, researchers Maajid Mohi Ud Din Malik and Rajesh Prasad Jayaswal evaluated left ventricular longitudinal strain measurements comparing feature-tracking cardiac magnetic resonance and 2D speckle-tracking echocardiography. Their work re-examines an earlier study by Khidr and colleagues involving 55 stable patients with chronic ischemic heart disease and reduced ejection fraction. While the original study demonstrated a strong global longitudinal strain correlation, Malik and Jayaswal extended two methodological points concerning multiple-comparison adjustments and the clinical interpretation of limits of agreement.
The original investigation by Khidr and colleagues established that feature-tracking cardiac magnetic resonance and 2D speckle-tracking echocardiography tracked global longitudinal strain similarly across the patient cohort, demonstrating a strong correlation of r = 0.793 with P < 0.001. Despite this population-level agreement, the original authors explicitly warned against treating the two modalities as interchangeable for individual or longitudinal patient assessments. Malik and Jayaswal endorsed these central conclusions, noting that their commentary does not unsettle the primary observation that both imaging platforms correlate strongly at the population level.
The authors first addressed statistical reporting regarding segment-level comparisons. In Table 4 of the original paper, 17 segment-level paired comparisons were presented without explicit multiplicity adjustments. Malik and Jayaswal recalculated these comparisons using a Bonferroni threshold of approximately 0.00294, derived from dividing alpha by 17. Under this adjusted threshold, 11 of the 17 segmental differences remained statistically significant. This finding demonstrates that the segmental differences identified in the initial analysis are statistically more robust than an unadjusted reader might have assumed.
To enhance future analytical precision, Malik and Jayaswal recommended the explicit reporting of adjusted P-values for segmental data. They also proposed utilizing a unified mixed-effects formulation designed to account for correlation between different myocardial segments within the same patient. The authors noted that incorporating multiplicity adjustments and mixed-effects modeling would tighten segmental statistical inference. Crucially, they pointed out that this methodological tightening refines the analytical structure without altering the substantive direction or clinical meaning of the original findings.
The second methodological consideration centers on clinical communication regarding the limits of agreement. In the cohort evaluated by Khidr and colleagues, the limits of agreement for global longitudinal strain spanned 8.3 percentage points, ranging from −3.2% to +5.1%. Malik and Jayaswal emphasized that this width is substantial enough to misclassify individual patients across established strain thresholds. To demonstrate the practical importance of this spread, the authors supplied a worked example showing how such variation could alter patient classification in clinical settings.
Because the agreement width can influence diagnostic classification, Malik and Jayaswal argued that the recommendation to restrict longitudinal follow-up to a single platform deserves greater prominence. Rather than appearing as a single sentence within the study conclusions, they maintained that this guidance should be placed visibly in both the abstract and conclusions. The authors concluded by stating that no new datasets were generated or analysed during their study, underscoring that their contribution serves to clarify the statistical reporting and clinical interpretation of the existing data.
Subject of Research: Statistical reporting and modality agreement for cardiac longitudinal strain
Article Title: Segmental strain in chronic ischemic cardiomyopathy: clarifying the role of multiple-comparison adjustment and the clinical interpretation of limits of agreement
Article References: Malik, M. M. U. D., & Jayaswal, R. P. (2026). Segmental strain in chronic ischemic cardiomyopathy: clarifying the role of multiple-comparison adjustment and the clinical interpretation of limits of agreement. Journal of Cardiovascular Imaging, 34(1), Article 14. https://doi.org/10.1186/s44348-026-00076-7
Image Credits: AI Generated
DOI: 10.1186/s44348-026-00076-7
Keywords: cardiac magnetic resonance, feature-tracking CMR, 2D speckle-tracking echocardiography, global longitudinal strain, segmental strain, chronic ischemic heart disease, reduced ejection fraction, multiple-comparison adjustment, Bonferroni threshold, limits of agreement, mixed-effects formulation, intermodality comparison, Journal of Cardiovascular Imaging, ischemic cardiomyopathy, left ventricular strain, longitudinal follow-up
News Source: Ophelia Keating. (November 19, 2026). Segmental Strain Differences Remain Significant After Bonferroni Adjustment in Heart Cohort. Scienmag.



