A comprehensive scoping review synthesizing decades of health systems research has identified sixty-seven distinct challenges that obstruct the effective implementation and maintenance of perinatal regionalization across diverse global settings. Perinatal regionalization is an established public health and clinical delivery framework established to ensure that pregnant women and critically ill newborns receive risk-appropriate care within facilities equipped with commensurate clinical technology, specialized personnel, and institutional capabilities. Although systematic regionalization has historically demonstrated meaningful reductions in neonatal morbidity, mortality, respiratory complications, mechanical ventilation dependency, bronchopulmonary dysplasia, and intraventricular hemorrhage, its operational execution remains severely compromised. The newly published synthesis, conducted by an international research team and adhering to the PRISMA-ScR guidelines for scoping reviews, systematically grouped the sixty-seven reported challenges into twenty-seven recurring subthemes nested under seven overarching categories. These core structural domains encompass clinical and medical unpredictability, socio-economic and geographic barriers, cultural and patient-centered considerations, provider-centered behavioral and reputational dynamics, healthcare organization and financial disincentives, transport logistics, and severe infrastructure constraints specific to low-resource settings.
Perinatal regionalization systematically coordinates maternal and neonatal health services through stratified tiers of care, integrating community-based facilities with advanced tertiary referral centers to optimize clinical outcomes and prevent acute complications. Under this stratified framework, facilities are classified according to the complexity of services provided, with Neonatal Level I units designated for low-risk term infants representing approximately eighty-five percent of all births, typically delivering neonates at thirty-six weeks of gestation or greater. Level II community facilities accommodate approximately twelve percent of neonates who require moderately intermediate clinical care, generally managing infants delivered between thirty-two and thirty-six weeks of gestation. Level III tertiary referral hospitals provide specialized intensive interventions for approximately three percent of newborns who present with severe illness or very low birth weight, specifically designated for infants born prior to thirty-two weeks of gestation. The functional architecture of regionalization relies upon distinct mechanisms for antenatal maternal transfer and postnatal neonatal transfer, which are governed by separate level-of-care criteria and distinct clinical indications. It also incorporates back-transfer protocols, which facilitate the planned transfer of clinically stabilized mothers or infants from tertiary referral centers back to lower-level community facilities located closer to their homes.
To rigorously identify and map the barriers documented in the published literature, the review team executed an expansive multi-stage search strategy across PubMed, Science Direct, and Web of Science. An initial literature search conducted in May 2024 yielded 388 records with no lower publication-year limit, which was subsequently updated in June 2026 with an expanded complementary query that captured an additional 695 records. Following duplicate removal and independent dual-reviewer screening of titles, abstracts, and full texts against predefined inclusion criteria, a total of 41 peer-reviewed research papers were incorporated into the final qualitative thematic synthesis. Eligible studies were restricted to English-language peer-reviewed articles reporting system-level, organizational, or clinical barriers to perinatal regionalization. Reflecting geographic publication distributions, the vast majority of included publications originated from the United States, which contributed thirty-four studies, alongside one comparative United States-Japan study, single investigations from France, Portugal, and Malawi, one multi-country European investigation, and two global studies. The qualitative synthesis employed an inductive thematic coding approach using verbatim extractions, intentionally omitting formal methodological quality or risk-of-bias appraisal in accordance with standard scoping review methodologies designed to map broad conceptual terrains.
The review demonstrates that clinical and medical unpredictability forms a primary point of vulnerability in regionalized referral networks. Despite estimates suggesting that seventy to eighty percent of very low birth weight births are theoretically predictable and preventable from occurring in lower-level facilities, sudden and catastrophic obstetric emergencies routinely impede timely antenatal transfers. Severe maternal conditions, such as acute eclampsia, uncontrolled preeclampsia, major obstetric hemorrhage, placental abruption, and HELLP syndrome, frequently emerge abruptly without sufficient clinical lead time to organize safe inter-facility transit. Furthermore, maternal contraindications to transport, including placenta previa, advanced cervical dilation exceeding four centimeters, precipitate labor, severe fetal heart rate abnormalities, and acute maternal instability, strictly preclude transfer to tertiary centers. Neonatal complications, such as meconium aspiration syndrome, intrapartum asphyxia, or critical congenital anomalies not detected during routine antenatal care, present unexpected post-birth emergencies in community hospitals lacking specialized intensive care. Compounding these factors, clinical judgment errors, inaccurate assessments of maternal or fetal severity, and differing interpretations of gestational viability limits between referring and receiving clinicians lead to missed opportunities for risk-appropriate delivery.
Geographic isolation and deep socio-economic inequalities further undermine equitable access to regionalized perinatal facilities. The scoping review highlighted that residential distance from Level III maternity centers and hospitals equipped with neonatal intensive care units significantly decreases the statistical probability of very low birth weight infants being born in appropriately designated settings. In a multi-country European study synthesized in the review, pregnant women residing in the fourth quartile of geographic distance experienced half the likelihood of delivering infants under thirty-two weeks of gestation in a Level III hospital compared with women living in the nearest quartile. Geographic barriers are severely exacerbated by widespread rural maternity unit closures, which eliminate local obstetric services, isolate frontier communities, and impose substantial financial and logistical burdens associated with long-distance travel, lodging, and temporary childcare. Socio-demographic determinants, including younger maternal age, lower educational attainment, pervasive poverty, and substance use, correlate with lower rates of risk-appropriate care. In the United States, systemic disparities mean that women from racial and ethnic minority backgrounds, as well as those reliant on Medicaid, TRICARE, or lacking health insurance altogether, are significantly less likely to deliver in tertiary hospitals compared to commercially insured peers.
Cultural, relational, and provider-level factors create substantial resistance against the seamless movement of patients through regionalized hierarchies. From the patient perspective, centralized transfer protocols often cause significant psychological distress by severing established relationships with trusted local primary caregivers, removing women from familial and community support networks, and fostering a perception of depersonalized, bureaucratic care. Additionally, families frequently resist back-transfer to local community hospitals once their infants stabilize, preferring the perceived security of tertiary institutions. On the provider level, inter-facility dynamics and clinical attitudes heavily influence referral patterns. Referring obstetricians and community hospitals frequently associate transferring high-risk patients with a diminished professional standing, perceived erosion of institutional prestige, or fear that abandoning high-risk care will lead to the total closure of their community obstetric services. Furthermore, provider misconceptions regarding fetal viability and unjustified confidence in local capabilities regularly lead to delayed transfers. Malpractice concerns and defensive medicine in the United States have additionally incentivized community obstetricians to push for local neonatal unit expansions, prompting the proliferation of lower-level facilities rather than coordinating regional transfers.
Structural and financial misalignments across healthcare systems have actively accelerated trends toward deregionalization, particularly throughout recent decades. The review documents how reimbursement structures, particularly fee-for-service reimbursement and bundled payment packages that tie compensation predominantly to the physical delivery event rather than antenatal management, financially penalize community hospitals that refer patients to tertiary centers. In market-driven environments, hospital competition for lucrative commercial insurance contracts has driven the unregulated proliferation of small, ambiguously defined Level II neonatal intensive care units within community institutions. These community facilities frequently engage in selective patient retention, keeping moderately high-risk infants to maintain institutional revenues despite lacking comprehensive multi-specialty coverage. Simultaneously, tertiary Level III centers have engaged in reciprocal cream-skimming behaviors, selectively admitting low-risk commercially insured deliveries to subsidize expensive specialized capabilities while avoiding underinsured referrals. Regulatory hurdles, such as rigid state-border restrictions within the United States that prevent cross-state transfers to physically closer tertiary facilities, combined with inconsistent, non-standardized definitions of maternal versus neonatal levels of care, generate systemic operational fragmentation.
Logistical and vehicular challenges during emergency transfers represent another critical domain compromising perinatal outcomes across regionalized networks. The scoping synthesis emphasizes that postnatal inter-hospital neonatal transport carries substantial physiological risks, with transferred infants experiencing higher documented rates of intraventricular hemorrhage, bronchopulmonary dysplasia, and mortality compared to infants delivered following planned in-utero maternal transfer. These elevated adverse outcomes stem from transport-related complications, including equipment malfunction, vehicle breakdown, inadequate neonatal monitoring tools, thermal instability during transit, and iatrogenic injuries resulting from inexperienced staff. The literature demonstrates that inter-hospital transfers occur with relatively low frequency at individual referring facilities, meaning local staff rarely maintain specialized transport expertise. In several evaluated settings, transfers relied upon municipal ambulances or military helicopters staffed by personnel lacking specialized neonatal resuscitation credentials. These acute risks underline the clinical necessity for dedicated, highly trained neonatal transport teams deployed directly from receiving tertiary hospitals to stabilize compromised infants prior to and during transit.
In low- and middle-income nations, the foundational prerequisites for functional perinatal regionalization are obstructed by severe infrastructural and resource deficits. Rather than grappling with managed care competition or subspecialty market proliferation, developing regions confront pervasive shortages of basic physical facilities, clean water, consistent electrical power, and essential diagnostic technologies across primary and secondary health tiers. Severe health workforce shortages, particularly of obstetricians, neonatologists, midwives, and specialized pediatric nurses, leave rural health centers chronically understaffed, with remaining personnel frequently isolated from formalized consultation or supervision mechanisms. In several sub-Saharan African countries, the systemic burden of the HIV epidemic has historically depleted institutional capacities and disrupted traditional family and community care structures. Furthermore, the almost complete absence of organized public emergency transport systems, combined with dilapidated road networks and unreliable telecommunication links, renders timely inter-facility referral impossible for impoverished families. Catastrophic out-of-pocket medical fees and private transit costs create insurmountable financial walls, forcing vulnerable pregnant women to deliver in unequipped local environments.
Addressing the multi-level barriers identified in this scoping synthesis requires deliberate, context-specific systemic reforms and policy interventions. High-income nations have established distinct adherence targets for regionalized delivery, such as Canada targeting over ninety percent of births prior to thirty-two weeks in Level III hospitals, France setting an eighty percent benchmark, and the United States Healthy People 2020 framework establishing an 83.7 percent objective. Achieving these benchmarks requires realigning economic incentives through bundled outcome-based payments that reimburse early referral and back-transfer, implementing Certificate of Need regulations to curb unnecessary Level II unit expansions, and harmonizing cross-state medical licensing. In low-resource settings, policy priorities must center on foundational infrastructure investments, expanded midwifery training, subsidized emergency transport networks, and universal financial protection. The review authors emphasize that while their synthesis provides an unprecedented conceptual map of sixty-seven operational challenges, the findings are bounded by important methodological limitations, including the heavy predominance of United States literature, restriction to English publications, and the absence of formal empirical quality appraisal across the included studies.
Subject of Research: Systemic challenges and barriers to implementing perinatal regionalization in maternal and neonatal healthcare
Article Title: Challenges in implementing optimal perinatal regionalization: a scoping review
Article References: Heidarzadeh, M., AbdollahiAbed, L., Nakhaee, M., Parnian, E., & Daemi, A. (2026). Challenges in implementing optimal perinatal regionalization: a scoping review. Maternal Health, Neonatology and Perinatology, 12(1), Article 46. https://doi.org/10.1186/s40748-026-00294-3
Image Credits: AI Generated
DOI: 10.1186/s40748-026-00294-3
Keywords: Perinatal Regionalization, Maternal Health, Neonatal Intensive Care Unit, Scoping Review, Very Low Birth Weight, High-Risk Pregnancy, Healthcare Disparities, Maternal Transfer, Neonatal Transport, Health Systems, Obstetric Care, Clinical Governance, Reimbursement Models, Rural Healthcare, PRISMA-ScR, Inter-Hospital Transfer, Perinatal Mortality
News Source: Harold Sullivan. (November 18, 2026). Scoping Review Identifies Sixty-Seven Systemic Barriers Undermining Perinatal Regionalization. Scienmag.



