Alternate wetting and drying irrigation significantly reduced water consumption, lowered greenhouse gas emissions, and boosted economic and carbon efficiency without reducing grain yield in irrigated rice production, according to a three-year field experiment conducted in northwestern India. Reporting in the journal Frontiers in Agronomy, researchers found that irrigation management, rather than the choice of crop establishment method, served as the primary governing factor for water use, environmental performance, and economic efficiency across the tested agricultural production systems.
The investigation was conducted across the 2023, 2024, and 2025 growing seasons at Punjab Agricultural University in Ludhiana, India. The scientific collaboration included researchers from Punjab Agricultural University, the ICAR Indian Institute of Rice Research in Hyderabad, the IRRI South Asia Regional Centre in Varanasi, and the International Rice Research Institute in Manila, Philippines. Working within the section on field water management, the authors structured the multi-year study to evaluate the relative contributions of crop establishment and irrigation regimes toward production efficiency and environmental performance in rice (Oryza sativa L.).
The field trials evaluated two distinct crop establishment techniques: puddled transplanted rice, designated as PTR, and dry direct-seeded rice, designated as DDSR. These two establishment approaches were tested under three contrasting irrigation regimes: continuous flooding (CF), saturation without flooding (SAT), and alternate wetting and drying (AWD). By observing these specific management combinations under northwestern Indian field conditions, the team analyzed comprehensive agronomic, water-use, greenhouse gas emission, and economic parameters using multivariate statistical methods followed by an integrated system ranking.
The crop establishment methods produced noticeable differences in plant development and reproductive sink traits, although these physiological variations did not generate a difference in overall harvest volume. Specifically, dry direct-seeded rice accelerated the flowering stage by 5 to 10 days and increased panicle density by 18.7 to 39.9 percent compared to puddled transplanted rice. Conversely, puddled transplanted rice maintained heavier panicles and a greater number of grains per panicle. Despite these contrasting reproductive sink traits between DDSR and PTR, grain yield remained statistically similar across both establishment methods and all three irrigation regimes.
The research demonstrated that the irrigation regime, rather than the establishment method, primarily governed water use, environmental impact, and carbon performance. When compared directly with continuous flooding, alternate wetting and drying reduced total irrigation input by 28.3 to 31.4 percent. This marked conservation of water was accompanied by an increase in water productivity of 28.7 to 34.8 percent and an increase in carbon efficiency of 54.7 to 58.2 percent. In addition, alternate wetting and drying decreased hundred-year global warming potential (GWP100) by approximately 35 percent relative to continuous flooding, achieving these environmental benefits without any yield penalty.
Economic efficiency also responded strongly to irrigation scheduling while demonstrating secondary gains from direct seeding. Economic water productivity improved by 43.9 to 55.4 percent under alternate wetting and drying compared with continuous flooding regimes. While irrigation regime was the main driver of economic water productivity, crop establishment method provided additional measurable advantages; dry direct-seeded rice enhanced economic water productivity by 5.5 percent during the 2023 trial year and by 8.7 percent during the 2024 trial year compared to puddled transplantation.
Multivariate analyses conducted on the experimental dataset revealed strong positive associations among water productivity, carbon efficiency, and economic returns. Conversely, continuously flooded systems clustered with greater greenhouse gas emissions and higher environmental burdens, identifying irrigation regime as the primary determinant of overall system sustainability while establishment method primarily governed reproductive sink traits. Using an integrated ranking evaluation, the authors identified dry direct-seeded rice combined with alternate wetting and drying (DDSR-AWD) as the most resource-efficient system, and puddled transplanted rice under continuous flooding (PTR-CF) as the least sustainable production system.
Subject of Research: Resource-use efficiency and environmental impacts of rice irrigation regimes and establishment methods
Article Title: Irrigation regime overrides establishment method effects on water, economic and carbon efficiency in rice (Oryza sativa L.)
Article References: Dhillon, B. S., Vijayakumar, S., Vij, L., Sreedevi, B., Tuti, M. D., Kumar, R. M., & Kumar, V. (2026). Irrigation regime overrides establishment method effects on water, economic and carbon efficiency in rice (Oryza sativa L.). Frontiers in Agronomy, 8, Article 2008950. https://doi.org/10.3389/fagro.2026.2008950
Image Credits: AI Generated
DOI: 10.3389/fagro.2026.2008950
Keywords: alternate wetting and drying, dry direct-seeded rice, puddled transplanted rice, water productivity, carbon efficiency, global warming potential, greenhouse gas emissions, economic water productivity, continuous flooding, saturation without flooding, panicle density, reproductive sink traits, Oryza sativa, Punjab Agricultural University, irrigated rice production, resource-use efficiency, field water management
News Source: Alan Morgan. (November 18, 2026). Alternate Wetting and Drying Improves Rice Resource Efficiency Without Yield Penalty. Scienmag.



