In clear aligner therapy for adults, the clinical success of anterior tooth movements is primarily governed by the specific movement category, the position of the tooth in the arch, and the prescribed movement magnitude, rather than by attachment design alone. According to findings from a retrospective cohort study published in Head & Face Medicine, rotational adjustments and incisor lingual inclination represent especially demanding mechanical tasks that exhibit lower predictability at the first refinement stage of treatment.
The investigation evaluated treatment outcomes by analyzing digital orthodontic records from ninety-one adult patients treated with Invisalign at a single academic orthodontic center between 2018 and 2025. Within this clinical sample, the participants had a mean age of 37.1 ± 11.2 years, and 78.0 percent of the cohort was female. Researchers examined movements across the anterior dentition, encompassing maxillary teeth from canine to canine (teeth 13 to 23) and mandibular teeth from canine to canine (teeth 31 to 43).
To isolate clinically meaningful changes, the authors assessed anterior tooth movements that met predefined minimum thresholds, specifically linear movements of at least 0.5 millimeters and angular movements of at least 1.0 degree. The investigators determined clinical acceptability by comparing the initial ClinCheck digital setup directly with the subsequent first refinement treatment plan. Under this analytical criterion, a movement achieved clinical acceptance if the clinician did not include it as a continuing prescription in the refinement plan.
The researchers systematically analyzed eight anterior movement categories: extrusion, intrusion, mesial rotation, distal rotation, buccal inclination, lingual inclination, mesial angulation, and distal angulation. Rotational movements proved to be the least predictable category overall within the examined cohort. Specifically, mesial rotation of mandibular canines registered the lowest individual success rate at 15.4 percent, which was significantly lower than the 50.7 percent success rate observed for mandibular lateral incisors (p < 0.001).
Inclination outcomes also diverged substantially depending on anatomical position. Buccal inclination reached its highest predictability in canines, achieving a 48.9 percent success rate in the maxilla, but dropped to a cohort low of 17.8 percent in maxillary central incisors (p < 0.001). Meanwhile, the success of vertical movements was heavily influenced by tooth position: extrusion achieved its peak rate in mandibular central incisors at 70.6 percent (12 out of 17 cases), whereas intrusion showed its highest predictability in maxillary canines at 51.9 percent.
Attachment designs demonstrated variable associations across the different movement types when evaluated using Chi-square tests. For lingual inclination, optimized attachments provided a statistically significant advantage, yielding a success rate of 40.9 percent compared with 32.9 percent for conventional attachments and 26.9 percent when no attachments were used (p = 0.002). Conversely, conventional attachments outperformed optimized attachments during mesial rotation, achieving 33.8 percent success versus 21.8 percent, though the authors noted this discrepancy was likely confounded by case complexity. Attachment design did not significantly alter outcomes for vertical movements or rotational angulation.
Synthesizing these clinical patterns, the study authors concluded that aligner predictability is fundamentally shaped by tooth location, movement category, and movement magnitude rather than attachment configuration in isolation. Because rotations and incisor lingual tipping carry heightened risk of incomplete expression, the investigators emphasized that clinicians may require adjunctive mechanics or adjusted expectations when formulating anterior digital setups.
Importantly, the authors noted that these success rates capture clinician-determined acceptability at the initial refinement milestone rather than continuous, geometry-based physical measurements of achieved tooth position. Because unexpressed movements might be accepted or modified based on clinical judgment rather than perfect mechanical tracking, the metrics should be interpreted within this clinical decision-making framework to guide evidence-based anterior aligner planning.
Subject of Research: Predictability of anterior tooth movements during clear aligner therapy
Article Title: Effects of tooth position, magnitude, and attachment on anterior tooth movement success in clear aligner therapy: a retrospective cohort study
Article References: Hankewycz, A., Nalabothu, P., Sharma, M., Paul, A., Chen, D., McCracken, C., & Janakiraman, N. (2026). Effects of tooth position, magnitude, and attachment on anterior tooth movement success in clear aligner therapy: a retrospective cohort study. Head & Face Medicine. https://doi.org/10.1186/s13005-026-00654-6
Image Credits: AI Generated
DOI: 10.1186/s13005-026-00654-6
Keywords: clear aligner therapy, Invisalign, anterior tooth movement, orthodontic refinement, ClinCheck, tooth position, retrospective cohort study, canine mesial rotation, mandibular incisors, maxillary canines, buccal inclination, lingual inclination, extrusion, intrusion, optimized attachments, conventional attachments, movement magnitude, clinical predictability
News Source: Ophelia Keating. (November 17, 2026). Clear Aligner Predictability in Adults Depends Strongly on Movement Type and Tooth Position. Scienmag.



