In a cross-sectional study evaluating diagnostic workflows across human and veterinary clinical medicine, microbiology laboratory personnel estimated that human medicine practitioners submitted an average of 18.5 incorrectly requested samples for every 100 incoming submissions. Published in BMC Microbiology, the interface analysis evaluated empirical survey responses gathered from laboratory professionals who oversee specimen reception, sample processing, and diagnostic interpretation in inpatient and outpatient settings throughout German-speaking countries. Across every professional category participating in the survey, respondents consistently identified swabs as the most error-prone sample material encountered during routine diagnostic laboratory operations.
The primary objective of the investigation was to perform an interface analysis to evaluate and characterize the specific sources and frequencies of errors occurring within diagnostic workflows for both human and animal microbiological specimens.
To capture diagnostic experiences across diverse healthcare sectors, the research team conducted an extensive web-based cross-sectional survey between October 7, 2022, and July 14, 2023. The surveyed population comprised German-speaking healthcare workers employed in human and veterinary medicine across both outpatient facilities and inpatient hospital environments. Distribution of the survey was executed using the snowball sampling method, enabling the investigators to circulate a broad questionnaire containing 166 questions to clinicians, veterinarians, technicians, and laboratory professionals situated throughout German-speaking regions.
From the broader recruitment effort, the researchers received and analysed a total of 2,464 valid survey responses. Among this overall sample, 372 individuals, representing 15.1 percent of total respondents, were explicitly identified as sample recipients who manage specimen intake, laboratory handling, and result interpretation. Within this focal cohort of 372 sample recipients, the single largest occupational group was situated in human medicine, accounting for 166 respondents or 44.6 percent of the sample-recipient workforce. To assess their unique perspectives, 20 of the survey’s 166 questions were specifically tailored to recipients of diagnostic specimens.
Analytical evaluations of the tailored survey responses involved descriptive summaries alongside formal inferential testing using two-sample t-tests and chi-square tests to determine differences between occupational groups. These analyses revealed distinct error estimates depending on the professional background of the submitter. While sample recipients estimated an error frequency of 18.5 incorrect requests per 100 samples from human medicine providers, the estimated rate stood at 15.4 per 100 samples for veterinarians and 14.8 per 100 samples for medical technicians. Despite these numerical differences in estimated error rates across provider streams, all participating professional groups unanimously cited swabs as the most error-prone specimen material.
The researchers also investigated whether professional longevity among laboratory staff correlated with the daily administrative workload required to correct ordering errors. Survey respondents with more than 10 years of professional experience reported more frequently that managing incorrect requests consumed over 60 minutes of post-processing time per day. However, statistical evaluation revealed that this observed difference was not statistically significant.
Synthesizing the survey findings, the authors concluded that sample recipients continue to face substantial systemic challenges arising from insufficient clinical information on request forms, ongoing communication gaps between submitters and laboratory personnel, and inconsistent sample quality at reception. Specifically, they recommended instituting interprofessional education, deploying automated digital decision-support tools, and establishing standardized test-requesting processes to reduce pre-analytical errors and safeguard diagnostic quality across all microbiological workflows.
Subject of Research: Diagnostic errors and sample quality challenges at the human and veterinary microbiology laboratory interface
Article Title: Bridging the gap in One Health: challenges at the diagnostic interface – laboratory insights on sample quality and stewardship
Article References: Schneitler, V., Schneitler, S., Abd El Wahed, A., Ceruti, A., Heenemann, K., Knaack, D., Kotsias-Konopelska, S., Pikalo, J., Dornaika, A., Toepfner, N., Wienemann, T., Joean, O., Siegel, M., & Bischoff, J. (2026). Bridging the gap in One Health: challenges at the diagnostic interface – laboratory insights on sample quality and stewardship. BMC Microbiology, 26(1), Article 1013. https://doi.org/10.1186/s12866-026-05873-0
Image Credits: AI Generated
DOI: 10.1186/s12866-026-05873-0
Keywords: One Health, diagnostic interface, sample quality, diagnostic stewardship, microbiology laboratory, specimen reception, human medicine, veterinary medicine, swabs, cross-sectional survey, error-prone samples, snowball method, medical technicians, interprofessional education, digital decision-support, standardised test-requesting, post-processing time
News Source: Ophelia Keating. (November 16, 2026). Laboratory Survey Identifies Swabs as Most Error-Prone Material Across Diagnostic Workflows. Scienmag.



