A theory-building scoping review published in the journal BMC Nursing has synthesized existing health literature to introduce a preliminary conceptual framework integrating self-leadership and caring within primary nursing systems. By systematically charting diverse research publications across nursing scholarship, the authors identified five central thematic domains and proposed relational accountability as a candidate mechanism designed to connect autonomous nurse decision-making directly with ethical caring practices.
The research team emphasized that primary nursing delivery models traditionally center on three core operational pillars: clinical continuity of care, individual practitioner accountability, and individualized patient care. Despite these established core values, the implementation of primary nursing in contemporary clinical settings remains conceptually fragmented. According to the review authors, existing academic literature has predominantly evaluated the structural, cognitive-behavioral, and relational-ethical dimensions of nursing practice in isolation, which has significantly restricted understanding regarding how these fundamental elements may interact within active clinical environments.
To address this conceptual fragmentation, the authors conducted a scoping review following the formal Preferred Reporting Items for Systematic Reviews and Meta-Analyses extension for Scoping Reviews, known as PRISMA-ScR guidance. The investigative team carried out comprehensive literature searches across four major scientific and biomedical databases: Scopus, PubMed, CINAHL, and Web of Science. To ensure a thorough synthesis, these electronic database queries were supplemented by structured manual searching alongside backward and forward citation tracking. The search protocol specifically targeted publications making substantive theoretical or empirical contributions to primary nursing, self-leadership and related concepts, or caring and related relational-ethical concepts.
Following data extraction and charting, the reviewers subjected the literature to thematic synthesis to isolate recurrent patterns, conceptual relationships, and notable evidence gaps. A total of fifteen publications satisfied all eligibility criteria for inclusion in the final review. The resulting evidence base exhibited substantial methodological diversity, incorporating five conceptual or theoretical papers, four qualitative studies, two quantitative cross-sectional studies, one quasi-experimental study, and three literature reviews.
Thematic analysis of the fifteen included publications revealed five distinct thematic categories characterizing nursing practice. First, primary nursing was identified as the structural foundation of accountable practice, providing the organizational framework within which care occurs. Second, self-leadership emerged as the critical cognitive-behavioral dimension underpinning autonomous clinical practice. Third, clinical decision-making was recognized as the operational expression through which professional practice is actively executed. Fourth, caring was categorized as the essential relational-ethical dimension governing practitioner interactions with patients. Finally, the authors documented persistent conceptual fragmentation across these domains, noting that existing publications rarely bridge these separate functional facets.
Drawing these disparate themes together, the authors conducted a higher-order synthesis that positioned relational accountability as a candidate integrative mechanism within primary nursing. Under this proposed conceptual model, relational accountability operates to conceptually link structural responsibility, self-regulated professional autonomy, and relational engagement. However, the study authors explicitly noted a crucial limitation: this proposed integrative mechanism was not empirically established by the included literature, representing a conceptual formulation derived from existing theories rather than direct experimental or observational verification.
In their concluding analysis, the investigators presented their preliminary conceptual framework as an initial model integrating the structural, cognitive-behavioral, and relational-ethical dimensions of nursing practice. The framework organizes potentially related operational constructs and generates specific propositions for future empirical investigation across clinical settings.
Subject of Research: Conceptual framework integrating self-leadership and caring in primary nursing
Article Title: Integrating self-leadership and caring in primary nursing: a theory-building scoping review
Article References: Yuwanto, M. A., Yosep, I., Pramukti, I., & Mediawati, A. S. (2026). Integrating self-leadership and caring in primary nursing: a theory-building scoping review. BMC Nursing. https://doi.org/10.1186/s12912-026-05603-x
Image Credits: AI Generated
DOI: 10.1186/s12912-026-05603-x
Keywords: primary nursing, self-leadership, caring, theory-building, scoping review, PRISMA-ScR, relational accountability, clinical decision-making, autonomous practice, accountable practice, individualized care, continuity of care, cognitive-behavioral dimensions, relational-ethical dimensions, structural foundation, healthcare delivery models
News Source: Ophelia Keating. (November 11, 2026). Scoping Review Outlines Framework Linking Self-Leadership and Caring in Primary Nursing. Scienmag.



