A new scoping review published in BMC Medical Research Methodology has examined how comparisons of multiple interventions are synthesized in infectious diseases research. The study, led by Rukshala K. Gunaratne and colleagues, aimed to provide an overview of the statistical methods used to assess relative efficacy or safety in this field. The authors noted that while evidence synthesis often involves comparing multiple interventions, the specific statistical methods employed and their appropriate application in practice are frequently unclear. This review sought to clarify these methodological practices across a broad range of recent systematic reviews.
The research team conducted a systematic search across PubMed, Embase, Web of Science, and the Cochrane Database of Systematic Reviews. They used search terms related to meta-analyses and infectious diseases to identify relevant literature. Systematic reviews were included in the analysis if they quantitatively compared three or more interventions for the prevention or treatment of infectious diseases. From the 8,160 records identified, 420 systematic reviews were deemed eligible after full-text screening. A random sample of 200 systematic reviews was selected for detailed data extraction to ensure a representative analysis.
To ensure representation of both pre- and post-COVID infectious diseases, the sample was divided into two equal groups. One hundred systematic reviews were selected from the period between 2015 and 2019, while another 100 were selected from 2020 to 2024. The selected reviews covered a wide array of conditions, with systematic reviews of interventions for COVID-19 being the most common, accounting for 32 of the sampled studies. HIV/AIDS and hepatitis B also featured prominently, with 22 reviews each dedicated to these conditions.
The analysis revealed that therapeutic interventions were the primary focus of the majority of the included systematic reviews. Specifically, 153 of the 200 reviews, representing 76.5%, assessed therapeutic interventions. In contrast, 47 reviews, or 23.5%, focused on preventive treatments.
Regarding statistical comparison methods, the review found that 34 systematic reviews, or 17.0%, used only pairwise meta-analyses. A larger proportion, 88 reviews or 44.0%, relied exclusively on network meta-analyses. The remaining 78 reviews, representing 39.0%, utilized both pairwise and network meta-analyses.
Among the 166 network meta-analyses identified in the sample, 83, or 50.0%, were implemented using a Bayesian framework.
A critical finding of the scoping review was the inconsistent assessment of key assumptions in network meta-analyses. Only 41 of the 166 network meta-analyses, representing 24.7%, assessed transitivity. Transitivity is a fundamental assumption that determines whether it is appropriate to combine evidence from direct and indirect comparisons of interventions. Without this assessment, the validity of the network meta-analysis may be compromised. In contrast, 112 reviews, or 67.5%, evaluated consistency, which quantifies the agreement between effect estimates from direct and indirect comparisons.
The authors concluded that while network meta-analysis is widely adopted in infectious diseases research, the key assumption of transitivity is rarely assessed. This gap in methodological rigor could impact the validity and reproducibility of evidence synthesis. The review highlights the need for improved adherence to publicly accessible protocols and thorough evaluation of assumptions. Transparent reporting is also essential to enhance the reliability of these studies.
This scoping review provides a valuable snapshot of current practices in infectious diseases research synthesis. It identifies specific areas where methodological improvements are needed, particularly in the assessment of transitivity. The findings underscore the importance of rigorous statistical methods in producing reliable evidence.
Subject of Research: Methodological practices in network meta-analyses for infectious diseases interventions
Article Title: Synthesis of comparisons of multiple interventions in infectious diseases research: a scoping review
Article References: Gunaratne, R. K., Siriwardena, G. A., Commons, R. J., Rajasekhar, M., Simpson, J. A., & Karahalios, A. (2026). Synthesis of comparisons of multiple interventions in infectious diseases research: a scoping review. BMC Medical Research Methodology. https://doi.org/10.1186/s12874-026-03032-7
Image Credits: AI Generated
DOI: 10.1186/s12874-026-03032-7
Keywords: network meta-analysis, infectious diseases, scoping review, transitivity, systematic reviews, statistical methods, evidence synthesis, Bayesian framework, Synthesis, comparisons, multiple, interventions
News Source: Ophelia Keating. (November 9, 2026). Scoping Review Finds Transitivity Rarely Assessed in Network Meta-Analyses. Scienmag.



