A mixed-methods study conducted at a university of technology in northern Taiwan found that nursing students demonstrated significantly higher scores in communication clarity and handover confidence following a five-week ISBAR-structured simulation teaching program. The research, published in Nursing Open, examined changes in clinical handover performance among 57 third-year undergraduate nursing students enrolled in an elective obstetric simulation and practicum course. The study utilized a single-group pre-post design combined with focus group interviews to evaluate the impact of structured handover training on student competence and learning experiences in a high-acuity clinical context.
Clinical handover is a fundamental means by which nursing professionals communicate with other members of the healthcare team, representing a core skill for nursing students. It constitutes one of the most critical steps in a patient’s care journey, with its core function being to enhance the effectiveness of the incoming clinician’s subsequent actions. Ensuring continuity of care and patient safety is paramount, as omissions of critical details and inaccuracies during handover have been identified globally as a leading cause of medical errors and adverse outcomes. Despite this importance, structured handover training rarely appears in nursing education curricula, leaving students with limited practice in communication and self-efficacy.
The ISBAR framework, which stands for Introduction, Situation, Background, Assessment, and Recommendation, is the most internationally recognized tool for structured handover. Its five components guide nurses in transmitting and receiving cognition about a patient’s current condition, helping to reduce the omission of critical information and eliminate irrelevant content. Simulation-based teaching, grounded in experiential learning theory, provides a controlled and repeatable environment in which nursing students can practice the ISBAR-structured handover process before entering clinical practice. This approach aims to enhance communication clarity and confidence through repeated reflective practice, addressing the structural deficit where students on clinical placements are largely limited to observation rather than active practice.
The study employed a mixed-methods design comprising a single-group pre-post study and focus group interviews. The quantitative component utilized a pre-experimental one-group pretest-posttest design, while the qualitative component encompassed focus group interviews, learning reflection feedback forms, and the researcher’s teaching reflection records. Participants were recruited via convenience sampling from the nursing department of a university of technology in northern Taiwan. All 57 students enrolled in the elective obstetric simulation and practicum course during the study period were eligible and invited to participate, representing the entire population of students in the course rather than a subset. Eligibility criteria included being a third-year student in the four-year nursing program and being enrolled in the specific elective course.
The intervention spanned five weeks, comprising 10 contact hours of ISBAR-structured teaching within a total course duration of 36 hours. The program included didactic instruction and expert modelling, role-play involving antenatal assessment and handover practice, and scenario simulation covering postpartum assessment for normal spontaneous delivery and caesarean section. Standardized patients were used in the simulations, and video-assisted debriefing was conducted after each scenario to encourage peer feedback and connect the simulation experience to authentic clinical contexts. The intervention concluded with an Objective Structured Clinical Examination (OSCE) assessment, which served as the summative learning activity and the primary objective performance assessment instrument of the study.
Quantitative results indicated a significant improvement in communication clarity following the intervention. Students’ overall post-test scores on the Communication Clarity Scale were significantly higher than pre-test scores, with a mean difference of 12.23 points and a Cohen’s d z of 1.04. Post-test mean scores on all 14 items across the five ISBAR domains exceeded pre-test means and demonstrated statistically significant differences. The most notable improvement was observed in the situation domain, particularly in items related to concisely stating the purpose of the handover and conveying urgency or appropriate concern. This suggests that students developed not only structural memory but also greater capacity to discern which information is urgent in real-world practice scenarios.
Handover confidence also showed substantial improvement, with significant increases across all five subscale items of the Confidence Scale. The overall post-test score was significantly higher than the pre-test score, with a mean difference of 5.51 points and a Cohen’s d z of 1.41. The magnitude of improvement in self-efficacy was particularly notable, exceeding that observed for communication clarity. This suggests that students’ beliefs in their own capability may be a prerequisite for translating acquired ISBAR knowledge into clinical practice. Qualitative accounts from focus group interviews corroborated these quantitative gains, with students describing a gradual reduction in anxiety and a progressive building of confidence through repeated simulation practice.
The OSCE results yielded high mean scores with low variability for both the antenatal and postpartum ISBAR handover stations. The mean score for the antenatal assessment and ISBAR handover was 87.75, while the mean score for the normal spontaneous delivery postpartum assessment and ISBAR handover was 87.26. As the OSCE was measured only after the intervention and without a comparison group, these scores document attained performance rather than improvement. The similarity of scores across the two stations indicates that performance was stable across two different obstetric scenarios, although these scores should not be read as evidence of transferable competence beyond the specific content taught during the program.
Qualitative analysis of focus group interviews and reflective journals revealed four main themes: mastering the handover framework to enhance organized expression, scenario simulation strengthening clinical reasoning and adaptability, peer feedback and reflection promoting self-awareness, and progressive practice building handover confidence. Students reported that ISBAR provided a clear handover procedure, enabling them to organize and convey information more systematically and reducing the confusion and omissions they had previously experienced. The scenario simulation facilitated the application of knowledge within simulated contexts, allowing students to practice integrating clinical information and responding immediately within the scenario. Peer feedback helped students identify blind spots in their handover expression, while the progressively structured learning design helped reduce unfamiliarity and anxiety about handover.
The study highlights several limitations that must be considered when interpreting the findings. The single-group pre-post design lacked a control group, making it impossible to exclude maturation and Hawthorne effects. The study was conducted at a single institution, limiting generalizability. The confidence scale instrument is somewhat dated and was not specifically designed for nursing students. Additionally, the course instructor facilitated the focus groups and participated in coding, although interviews and coding took place after grades were finalized and transcripts were anonymized. Interview participants were self-selected volunteers, and their demographic characteristics were not tabulated separately, so their representativeness of the full cohort cannot be established. Patient-safety outcomes were not measured, so implications for patient safety are inferential.
The findings suggest that ISBAR-structured handover scenario simulation teaching should be considered for inclusion as a required component of obstetric nursing curricula. Obstetrics demands particular acuity in detecting changes in patient condition and time-sensitive decision-making, given that communication failures may result in serious consequences for both the mother and infant. The integration of self-report scales, OSCE performance, and qualitative data provides a more comprehensive portrayal of the learning process and its outcomes than any single data source could afford. The study supports the incorporation of systematic, structured scenario-based practice into nursing curricula, particularly in high-acuity units where high-quality handover is essential for patient safety.
Nursing educators should consider incorporating ISBAR-structured simulation practice into specialist nursing curricula, particularly in high-risk areas such as obstetrics. The four-stage sequence of didactic instruction, role-play, scenario simulation, and OSCE offers a potentially useful educational strategy for developing handover competence. This progressively structured model can serve as a flexible template for educators to adapt according to different specialist content. Learning in a low-risk professional environment helps students build a sense of achievement and internalize skills, reducing the anxiety that often leads student nurses to avoid handover or omit critical information in clinical settings. Further research adopting randomized controlled or quasi-experimental designs is recommended to validate these findings and develop handover self-efficacy measurement instruments that are culturally appropriate and specific to obstetric contexts.
Subject of Research: Impact of ISBAR-structured simulation teaching on nursing students' clinical handover performance
Article Title: Changes in Nursing Students' Clinical Handover Performance Following ISBAR‐Structured Handover Simulation Teaching: A Mixed‐Methods Study
Article References: Sun, J.-C., Chang, M.-Y., & Tsai, Y.-C. (2026). Changes in Nursing Students' Clinical Handover Performance Following ISBAR ‐Structured Handover Simulation Teaching: A Mixed‐Methods Study. Nursing Open, 13(10), Article e70955. https://doi.org/10.1002/nop2.70955
Image Credits: AI Generated
DOI: 10.1002/nop2.70955
Keywords: nursing education, clinical handover, ISBAR framework, simulation teaching, obstetric nursing, mixed-methods research, patient safety, communication skills, OSCE assessment, healthcare training, Changes, Nursing
News Source: Ophelia Keating. (November 8, 2026). Obstetric Nursing Students Show Improved Handover Skills After ISBAR Simulation. Scienmag.



